Concept
What Subordination Costs
General subordination to real-property interests
What Subordination Costs
Subordination under UCC § 9-334(c) leaves a lender's security interest in place but ranks it behind the conflicting interest of every encumbrancer or owner of the related real property other than the debtor.1 Against the debtor, the lender is as secured as before. Against everyone else with a stake in the building, it is junior. That junior rank costs the lender the remedy that most directly turns collateral into cash after default: carrying the goods out of the building.
The Code gives the right to remove only to a secured party whose interest has priority over all owners and encumbrancers of the real property.2 A lender that ranks behind even one of them has no right to remove, however firm its claim against the debtor. Priority is measured claimant by claimant, so a single senior claimant is enough to defeat removal. A lender that outranks a later mortgagee but trails an earlier one has priority over some claimants and not over all, and the earlier mortgagee alone bars the removal.
Both lenders hold valid, unpaid security interests in installed goods. Only the second ranks above every claimant on the land, and only the second may remove.
Priority brings the right to remove, but the right carries a price. A lender that removes must reimburse any owner other than the debtor, and any encumbrancer, for the cost of repairing physical injury caused by the removal, such as the bakery's wall and tile.3 The owner or encumbrancer may also condition its permission to remove on receiving security or indemnity for that cost.4 The duty does not reach the loss in the building's value caused by the goods' absence. A claim for lost value says the building is worth less without goods that the lender, having priority, was entitled to take as against that claimant.
The exceptions to the residual rule show who escapes this cost, and why. A fixture filing in the local real estate records protects a lender against certain real estate claimants. A filing at the state capital protects it only against lien creditors and certain other claimants, in cases where the fixture is not important to mortgagees.5 A bankruptcy trustee, as lien creditor, does not rely on the real estate records. Mortgagees and other purchasers of the land do not rely on factory or office machines when they lend or buy. In those cases the Code lets a lender with only a personal property filing take priority.6 Outside them, the residual rule governs, and the lender ranks behind the mortgagee.