Concept
Fixtures and the Default Rule
Purchase-money fixture priority
Purchase-Money Fixture Priority
Fixtures and the Default Rule
A furnace bolted into the basement of an office building sits in two legal worlds at once. A lender who financed the furnace holds an Article 9 security interest in it, because the furnace is goods. A bank that lent against the building holds a mortgage and may claim the furnace as part of the land. Both claimants can point to the same object, and each may believe it has the better right. UCC § 9-334(d) is the rule that sorts them out.
The subsection gives the fixture financier priority, but only conditionally. Except as subsection (h) provides otherwise, a perfected security interest in fixtures has priority over a conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the real property if the debtor has an interest of record in or is in possession of the real property, and if the further conditions that follow in the subsection are met.1 The rule has four parts, and each one narrows the situations in which the fixture creditor wins:
- The security interest must be perfected. An unperfected interest gets no help from this subsection.
- The competitor must be an encumbrancer or an owner of the real property. An encumbrancer holds a claim against the land, such as a mortgagee. An owner holds title to it.
- The debtor must have an interest of record in the real property or be in possession of it.
- The remaining conditions listed after the colon must be satisfied, and subsection (h) can displace the whole rule.
The word if does the work in this rule. Priority is not something a fixture creditor has automatically because it financed the goods. The creditor must bring itself within the subsection, and until it does, § 9-334(d) gives it no priority over the mortgagee or owner. Everything else in this part of the chapter is about how a fixture creditor meets those conditions.
The next unit takes up the purchase-money test and the conditions that go with it. After that, we work a time line to see how the conditions fit together, look at the construction mortgage exception, and finish by applying the test to fact patterns.