Concept
Continuation and Proceeds
Commingling
Commingled Goods and Proceeds
Continuation and Proceeds
After a debtor disposes of collateral, the lender has two places to look: the goods themselves and whatever the debtor received in exchange. Article 9 protects both routes. A security interest, the lender's right to look to the debtor's property if the debtor defaults, continues in the goods unless the lender authorized the disposition free of it, and it attaches to identifiable proceeds as well.1 The lender may claim both the goods and the proceeds, but it may have only one satisfaction of the debt.2
Commingling threatens each route. A security interest does not exist in commingled goods as such, although it may attach to the product or mass that results when goods become commingled.3 Proceeds mixed with the debtor's other property raise a matching problem. If the proceeds are goods, the lender's interest in them exists to the extent Section 9-336 provides.4 If they are not goods, the interest reaches only what the secured party can identify by a tracing method, including equitable principles, that law outside Article 9 permits for commingled property of that type.5 Each limit modifies one of the two baseline rules developed below: first the interest in the original collateral, then the interest in proceeds.
Continuation in Original Collateral
A debtor's sale does not, by itself, strip the lender's interest from the goods. Under § 9-315(a)(1), a security interest continues in collateral notwithstanding sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition, unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of the security interest.6 When the debtor makes an unauthorized sale, the interest therefore stays with the goods in the buyer's hands, unless the buyer takes free under some other provision of Article 9.7
The rule follows from who holds the goods. The debtor decides whether to sell them, while the lender lent in reliance on reaching them after a default. If a sale by the debtor alone could dissolve the lender's rights, borrowers could remove their lenders' protection at will, and lending against goods would be worth little. The statute therefore puts the burden on the lender's own consent: the interest survives unless the lender chose to give it up.
The provision opens with a qualification: it applies 'except as otherwise provided' in Article 9 and in Section 2-403(2).8 That clause sorts the ways a buyer can take free into two groups. In the first, the lender itself authorized the disposition free of its interest. In the second, a priority rule cuts off the interest whatever the lender wanted. The second group includes the protection of a buyer in the ordinary course of business under § 9-320(a); the rule that a buyer who gives value and takes delivery without knowledge of the interest, before it is perfected, takes free under § 9-317(b); and rules for particular kinds of collateral, such as chattel paper and instruments (§ 9-330), negotiable instruments, documents, and securities (§ 9-331), and deposit accounts and money (§ 9-332).9 Each is a priority rule with its own requirements, and priority is a separate subject. The narrower point here is that a buyer who claims to take free relies either on the lender's consent or on one of those separate rules.
When the claim is consent, the security agreement is the first place to look.10 The statute asks one question: did the secured party authorize the disposition free of its security interest?11 The answer reaches only as far as the lender's actual authorization, so a lender that lets the debtor sell one scheduled machine free of the lien has not let it sell every machine it owns.
A right to proceeds is not that authorization. When the debtor makes an unauthorized sale, the interest continues in the goods and also attaches to the proceeds, and the lender may claim both while collecting only once.12 Were a proceeds clause itself consent to a free sale, the lender would lose its claim to the goods the moment it asserted its claim to the money, and the two claims could never coexist. Attachment to proceeds is automatic even when the agreement says nothing about them,13 so treating it as consent would make every secured loan authorize free sales and would erase the continuation rule.
The single satisfaction has a measure: the debt the interest secures. Beth borrowed $10,000 from Farmers' Bank and granted the bank an interest in her cattle, and the agreement contained a future advance clause. When the bank lends her another $5,000, the cattle secure $15,000 in all.14 That total limits what the bank may collect from the cattle and their proceeds together, because whatever it collects from one source reduces what it may collect from the other.15
The two scenes differ in what the lender's agreement addresses. In the first it speaks only to the lender's entitlement to money; in the second it speaks to the debtor's power to sell free of the interest. Only the second supplies the permission the exception requires.
Continuation also rests on a premise the statute never states: there must be an identifiable item of collateral for the interest to continue in. A machine sold to a buyer is still the same machine, and the lender can follow it. Goods physically united with other goods until their identity is lost present a different case, because the original collateral may no longer exist as a separate thing, and a rule that the interest follows the collateral then has nothing to follow. The commingled-goods rule fills the gap: a security interest does not exist in commingled goods as such, but it may attach to the product or mass that results.16 The next subsection takes up the lender's second route, the proceeds, and later sections return to commingled goods and the mass.
Attachment to Identifiable Proceeds
The lender's second route runs through whatever the debtor receives for the collateral. A security interest attaches to any identifiable proceeds of collateral.18 Attachment is automatic: the grant of an interest in the original collateral carries the right to proceeds, so the security agreement need not mention them.19 The Code assumes that parties to a secured transaction intend to cover proceeds unless they agree otherwise, and a requirement that the agreement mention proceeds would likely be a trap for a careless drafter.20
The proceeds rule matters most when the lender's claim to the goods fails. A buyer in the ordinary course of business, for instance, can take free even of a perfected interest, and the lender's claim to the goods is then gone.21 The interest in what the debtor received for them is not gone, because the security interest also attaches to the proceeds of the sale.22
The statute defines proceeds broadly. They include whatever the debtor acquires upon the sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of collateral.23 They also include whatever the debtor receives on collection of collateral or of proceeds themselves.24 Within the definition, one subsection covers insurance payable on injury to or destruction of collateral, and another covers distributions such as cash and stock dividends.25 Proceeds may be cash or something else. Cash proceeds consist of money, checks, deposit accounts, and the like, and the later sections on perfection separate cash from noncash proceeds.26
In most cases proceeds are easy to identify. If a lender has an interest in an automobile and the debtor sells it, taking a note and a security interest from the purchaser, the purchaser's security interest makes specific reference to the automobile and is directly traceable to that collateral.27
Two words in the statute mark the boundaries of the claim. The first is proceeds: what the debtor ends up with must come from a disposition, collection, or similar event involving collateral, meaning property in which the lender's interest has attached. The second is identifiable: the asset must be traceable to that collateral. That second word keeps the lender's claim tied to what it can actually connect to its own collateral and out of everything else the debtor owns.
The two checks differ only in the property they came from, and that difference decides the question. Whatever Kessler later did with the lathe money, the lathe sale gave Northgate's proceeds right nothing to attach to.
The definition also excludes some things that look similar. Suppose the parties agree that a second machine will replace the first as collateral. The second machine becomes subject to the security interest because of the parties' agreement and not because it is proceeds of the first. 'Exchange,' 'disposition,' and the like contemplate a transfer by the debtor to a third party, not a shift of the security interest from one of the debtor's assets to another.28 A calf born to a cow in which the lender holds an interest fits the definition no better, because the debtor received it upon no sale, exchange, collection, or other disposition of the cow. A claim to the calf must therefore rest on how the security agreement describes the collateral and not on the proceeds rule.
The fourth step usually causes no trouble. Difficulty arises when the debtor deposits the buyer's money in an account that already holds the debtor's other funds, because the lender must then show which part of the balance is still its proceeds. Section 9-315 answers differently depending on whether the commingled proceeds are goods, and the later sections on commingled proceeds take up each answer.29