Concept
Priority in Product or Mass
Commingling
Priority in Product or Mass
Commingling leaves competing lenders holding interests in a single asset. No security interest exists in commingled goods as such, but an interest may attach to the product or mass that results, so lenders who financed different ingredients each claim the whole pile.1 Attachment gives each lender a claim to the mass. It does not say whose claim comes first when the mass is worth less than the debts it secures, and once the goods are mixed no lender can point to its own portion and demand it. A rule has to do the ranking.
Section 9-336 supplies that rule in layers. Subsection (d) decides whether a lender's interest in the mass is perfected. Subsection (e) sends most priority contests to the ordinary priority provisions of Article 9. Subsection (f) overrides that default in one situation only: more than one security interest attaches to the product or mass under subsection (c).2 A lender whose interest reached the mass another way, such as an interest in the finished product itself, did not attach under subsection (c) and stays under the default.
A problem is best worked in the same order. First ask whether each lender was perfected before its collateral was mixed. Then ask whether more than one interest reached the mass through commingling; if not, the ordinary rules decide. If more than one did, a lender perfected at commingling beats one that was not, and lenders who were all perfected then share the mass in proportion to the value of their collateral. The subsections below follow that sequence.
Perfection Carries Into the Mass
A lender whose interest has attached to the mass still needs to know whether the interest is perfected there. Section 9-336(d) answers with a rule about timing: if a security interest in collateral is perfected before the collateral becomes commingled goods, the security interest that attaches to the product or mass is perfected.3 The lender takes no new step. The interest in the mass has the perfected status the interest in the goods already had.4
The rule protects a lender against an event it does not control. Under § 9-336(b), the interest in the goods as such no longer exists once the goods are mixed.5 If perfection ended with it, mixing would strip the lender of its perfected status and force it to start over against the mass. Carrying perfection across lets the lender's earlier work follow its claim from the original goods to the whole.
The lender also need not have anticipated the mixing when it filed. Under the 1999 Code, the security interest continues in the product or mass without regard to any mention of products on the financing statement.6 A financing statement that describes flour does not have to name cakes.
The statute asks when the lender was perfected, not whether it is perfected now. Section 9-336(d) looks to the moment the collateral became commingled goods, and a lender that perfected only afterward gets no help from the rule.
Both lenders signed valid agreements, and neither financing statement mentioned the mass. They differ in one fact: only Tamsin was perfected before the mixing. The priority rules in the next subsections turn on that fact, because a lender that was unperfected when its collateral was commingled is subordinated to one that was perfected then.8
Perfection and ranking are separate questions. The carry-over rule settles only whether a lender is perfected in the mass. A perfected lender must still be ranked against the others who claim the mass, and the following subsections supply that ranking.
Default Priority Rules
Section 9-336(e) sets the baseline: except as subsection (f) provides, the other priority provisions of Article 9 determine the priority of a security interest that attaches to the product or mass under subsection (c).11 Mixed goods get no separate ranking system. The first-to-file-or-perfect rule of § 9-322 and the rest of the ordinary scheme rank competing lenders as they would rank lenders anywhere else.
The special treatment in § 9-336 exists to solve one problem. Lenders who financed different ingredients end up claiming a single asset, and none of them can point to its own portion. A lender whose interest did not arrive that way raises no such problem, so nothing justifies leaving the system that lenders already use.
The official comment's example shows the default at work. Bank A has a perfected security interest in baked goods, and Bank B later perfects a non-purchase-money security interest in eggs that go into them. Bank A has priority under § 9-322.12 Only Bank B's interest reaches the finished goods through commingling, because Bank A's interest was in them as original collateral. Subsection (f) requires more than one interest attaching under subsection (c), so it does not apply,13 and the ordinary first-to-perfect rule decides.
The result changes when both lenders reach the mass the same way. Suppose one lender financed the eggs, another financed the flour, and each perfected in its own ingredient. Both interests would attach to the cakes only because the ingredients were commingled, so subsection (f) displaces the default,14 and the next two subsections teach its two rules. The first question when two banks claim one mass is therefore how each interest got there.
Commingled proceeds that are goods follow the same route. Proceeds that are goods and become commingled with other property are identifiable proceeds only to the extent § 9-336 provides.15 When the default asks which lender filed or perfected first, filing or perfection as to the original collateral counts as filing or perfection as to its identifiable proceeds.16
The default ranks secured creditors against one another, and it does not decide every contest over a mixed pile. Where a secured creditor competes with an owner or bailor whose goods were mixed in, other law governs.17 Confine the priority analysis to the contest between lenders and send the owner or bailor to that other law.
Perfected Beats Unperfected
Section 9-336(f)(1) supplies the first special rule: a security interest perfected under subsection (d) has priority over a security interest that is unperfected at the time the collateral becomes commingled goods.20 The rule works only in the contest subsection (f) was written for, where more than one security interest attaches to the product or mass under subsection (c).21 The statute asks one question of each lender in that contest: was its interest perfected before its goods were mixed? Subsection (d) carries perfection into the mass only for an interest perfected before the commingling, so the two halves of (f)(1) look at the same fact from opposite ends. The lender that passes ranks first, and the lender that fails is subordinated to it.22
Perfection is the step the system asks lenders to take, and this rule rewards it. A lender that perfected before the goods were mixed, ordinarily by filing a financing statement, did what was asked. If a lender that never perfected shared the mass equally with it, the diligent lender would gain nothing from having acted, and the idle one would profit from having waited. Priority for the perfected lender preserves the ordinary advantage of perfection through an event that the lenders did not control.
The statute also fixes the moment of comparison. Perfection is measured when the collateral becomes commingled goods, and nothing that happens afterward changes a lender's position. A lender therefore cannot repair a gap by filing once the mass exists, and the ranking is settled when the goods are mixed, so a court need not wait to see which lender hurries to file. The rule asks nothing about whose loan came first or whose security agreement was signed earlier. The only variable is each lender's perfection status at the instant of commingling.
An exam stem that mentions a late filing is testing whether the filing rescues the unperfected lender. It does not, because it came after the only moment the statute examines. Had Cedar filed in June, both lenders would have been perfected before the mixing. Subsection (f)(1) would then have nothing to rank, since it separates perfected interests from unperfected ones, and the contest would pass to the second special rule, which the next subsection teaches.
Subordination is a ranking and does not extinguish the interest. Cedar's interest never ceased to exist, because an interest in commingled goods as such is replaced by an interest in the product or mass, and Cedar's attached to the silo's contents.23 Cedar's claim is paid after Prairie's, so Cedar can look to whatever value remains in the mass once Prairie's secured debt is satisfied. The rule matters most when the mass is worth less than the debts against it, and in that shortfall the lender that failed to perfect before the mixing bears the loss.
Pro Rata Sharing by Value
When every lender competing for a mass was perfected before its collateral was mixed, the perfected-beats-unperfected rule has no one to subordinate. Section 9-336(f)(2) supplies the second special rule: if more than one security interest is perfected under subsection (d), the interests rank equally in proportion to the value of the collateral at the time it became commingled goods.25 Like its companion, the rule operates only where more than one security interest attaches to the product or mass under subsection (c).26 The lenders financed different ingredients, each interest rests on the whole mass, and each was perfected at the moment of mixing. None outranks the others by timing or status, so the statute divides the mass by formula.
The formula has three features, and each answers a distinct problem. Equal ranking answers what mixing does: once the collateral has lost its identity, nothing in the pile shows whose goods are whose, and a first-in-time rule would hand the mass to whichever lender filed earlier even if a later filer contributed more of what the mass holds. Proportion by value ties each share to the source of the mass's worth, so the lender whose collateral supplied most of the ingredients takes most of the product. Measuring at the time of commingling fixes each share at the last moment the contributions can be told apart, before price swings or disputes can distort them. And because the measure is the value of the collateral and not the size of the debt, a lender cannot enlarge its slice by lending more against the same goods.
The official comment works the arithmetic with eggs and flour.27 SP-1 holds a perfected interest in a debtor's eggs, worth $300 and securing a $400 debt. SP-2 holds a perfected interest in the debtor's flour, worth $500 and securing a $600 debt. The debtor bakes the two into cakes worth $1,000. Each interest attached to the cakes through commingling and each was perfected before the baking, so the interests rank equally in proportion to the value of their collateral when it was mixed. The values $300 and $500 reduce to a ratio of 3:5, which makes eight parts, so SP-1 takes three-eighths and SP-2 five-eighths. The fractions apply to the entire value of the cakes, not to the $800 the ingredients were worth, so SP-1 is entitled to $375 (3/8 × $1,000) and SP-2 to $625 (5/8 × $1,000). The value that baking added is shared in the same proportions as the contributions.
The ratio sets each lender's place in the mass, but the statute ranks the interests only up to the amount of each secured party's debt.28 A careful answer checks the comment's entitlements against the debts. SP-2's $625 exceeds its $600 debt, so SP-2 stops at $600. SP-1's $375 falls short of its $400 debt, so the $25 that SP-2 cannot take is available to SP-1, which collects the full $400. Both debts are then paid in full from cakes worth exactly $1,000, the sum of the two debts.29
The silo example shows the same ratio at larger scale. A lender perfected in $10,000 of one farmer's grain and a lender perfected in $20,000 of another's, with both lots stored in one silo, have priority as to one-third and two-thirds of the whole.30 The shares follow the value contributed and ignore how much each lender is owed. The oats illustration makes the point from the other direction: the allocation holds even if one bank is owed $2 million and the other only $800,000, though the bank owed more might get some of the other's oats if that bank's debt is less than $800,000.31
The first step is where exam stems set traps. A fact pattern that names two lenders and two dollar figures invites the 3:5 or 1:2 arithmetic, but if one lender's interest was unperfected at the moment of mixing, the ratio never applies and the perfected lender ranks first.
The two special rules divide the field between them. Perfected beats unperfected where a perfected interest meets an unperfected one, and proportional sharing governs interests that were all perfected.32 A filing made after the mixing, as in Teller's case, cannot move a lender into the second group.