Concept
Commingled Proceeds
Commingling
Commingled Proceeds
A debtor who sells collateral does not always keep what it receives apart from its other property. The buyer's check may land in a bank account that already holds the debtor's other money, and a payment in kind, such as hay, may be forked onto a stack of similar hay until no one can say which is which. Either way, the secured party must ask whether its proceeds can still be found in the mixture. Under UCC § 9-315(b), proceeds that are commingled with other property are identifiable proceeds in two situations, and the kind of property the proceeds are decides which one applies.1
A security interest attaches only to identifiable proceeds, and in most cases proceeds are easy to identify as coming from particular collateral.2 Commingling is the debtor's easiest way to blur that link, and the statute has to answer it without overcorrecting. If mixing alone ended identifiability, a debtor could defeat a proceeds claim by depositing the buyer's check with other money, and the right to proceeds would fail at the moment it was needed. If mixing instead made the whole mixture the lender's, one sale would give the lender a claim to value that never came out of its collateral. Section 9-315(b) avoids both results by asking what the proceeds are.
If the proceeds are goods, they are identifiable to the extent provided by § 9-336, so the product-or-mass rules taught above do the work.3 If the proceeds are not goods, they are identifiable to the extent the secured party identifies them by a method of tracing, including equitable principles, that law outside Article 9 permits for commingled property of that type.4 The split follows the physical character of the property. Goods that merge lose their identity in a product or mass, and Article 9 already has rules for that result. Money and funds in an account never had a separate physical identity, so the question becomes how much of the pooled fund can be attributed to the collateral, and the secured party answers it with proof. The goods branch comes first, then the tracing branch, then one method for carrying out a trace.
Proceeds That Are Goods
When commingled proceeds are goods, § 9-315(b)(1) sends the problem to § 9-336, the commingled-goods section taught earlier in this chapter.5 The lender therefore needs no separate theory for the mixing, and its claim moves in a fixed order. The debtor disposes of collateral and receives goods, and the lender's interest attaches to them as proceeds, because proceeds are whatever the debtor acquires on the sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of collateral.6 The debtor then unites those goods with other goods until their identity is lost. From that point the product-or-mass rule governs: no security interest exists in the commingled goods as such, but an interest may attach to the product or mass that results.7
The rest of § 9-336 then governs the lender's position as well. A security interest in proceeds is perfected if the security interest in the original collateral was perfected,8 so a lender perfected in the original collateral starts with a perfected interest in the goods it receives as proceeds. Perfection in the mass, and priority among the lenders who claim it, follow the rules taught above for a product or mass. Those rules apply the same way whether the goods entered the mass as original collateral or as proceeds. How long perfection in proceeds lasts is taken up below, in the discussion of cash and noncash proceeds.
One section serves both cases because the physical event is the same. Goods mixed until they cannot be told apart present a single problem whether the debtor bought them, grew them, or received them on a sale, so the lender's claim should depend on the condition of the goods and not on how they arrived. A tracing rule such as the lowest intermediate balance rule answers a different question, which is how much of a pooled balance can be attributed to collateral, and goods in a mass already have an answer in the product-or-mass rule.
The form of what the debtor received separates the two scenes, and exam questions turn on that fact. A second check applies inside the goods branch, because the commingled-goods rules apply only once goods have lost their identity in a product or mass. A trade-in car taken on the sale of inventory is proceeds of that inventory,9 but it remains a distinct item the lender can point to even when it sits among similar cars, so it calls for no product-or-mass analysis. The usual error is to apply the right rule to the wrong form, whether by running a lowest-intermediate-balance calculation on a pile of mixed goods or by treating a bank balance as a mass in which the lender's interest attaches.
Proceeds That Are Not Goods
Commingled proceeds that are not goods, which typically means money and funds in a deposit account,12 are identifiable under § 9-315(b)(2) only to the extent the secured party identifies them by a method of tracing, including equitable principles, that law outside Article 9 permits for commingled property of the type involved.13 Tracing is the process of following value through a mixed fund by attributing part of the fund to a particular source. The paradigm case is a deposit of sale proceeds into a bank account that already holds the debtor's other money.
The statute needs a tracing rule because dollars in a general account are interchangeable and a balance shows only a total. Goods that merge can be reached by attaching the interest to the resulting mass, but no comparable physical whole exists for money. The two simple answers both fail. If mixing ended identifiability, an ordinary deposit would defeat the lender. If mixing made the entire account the lender's, one sale would give the lender a claim to money supplied by other customers and other lenders. The statute takes a middle course: commingled proceeds are identifiable to the extent they can be traced.
Article 9 leaves the accounting convention to other law. It borrows whichever tracing method that law permits for commingled property of the type involved, and the phrase of the type involved matters because the permitted method may vary with the kind of property that was mixed. A bank balance, for example, is the kind of fund to which the lowest intermediate balance rule, taught in the next subsection, applies. The secured party's task has two parts: find a method that tracing law approves, then prove the facts the method requires.
Because the statute reaches commingled proceeds only to the extent the secured party identifies them, the secured party carries the burden of showing what part of the mixed fund traces to its collateral.14 The burden falls on the lender because the lender is the party asserting that the money came from its collateral. The to the extent wording keeps the claim proportioned to the proof: a lender that traces part of a fund reaches that part and no more.
A deposit-account decision shows how the showing works in litigation. In Metropolitan National Bank v. La Sher Oil Co., a bank claiming priority in a deposit account showed that the funds were proceeds of its collateral, which defeated a competing garnishment lien and shifted to the garnisher the burden of producing evidence that the funds came from another source.15 The order matters. The secured party's proof comes first, and the competing claimant must respond only after the lender has made it. A lender that offers no tracing gives the court nothing on which to shift the burden.
In both scenes a debtor deposited the price of collateral into an account fed by other money. The difference lay in the lender's proof. Cardinal's deposit and balance records supplied the facts that a recognized method requires, while Halvorsen had only a sale and a balance. The outcome follows the proof, and the proof reaches only as far as the records go, which is why Cardinal's claim to $7,000 in an account of $67,000 leaves the remaining $60,000 to the debtor and its other creditors.
An exam stem that sends sale proceeds into a mixed account is testing which branch of § 9-315(b) applies, and the form of the proceeds answers that question. Goods go to § 9-336, while cash and funds in an account go to tracing. When the stem leaves open whether the deposit is still identifiable, state the tracing rule, apply it to whatever deposit and balance facts the stem supplies, and note that the secured party must establish the traceable amount.
Lowest Intermediate Balance Rule
Section 9-315(b)(2) leaves the accounting convention for commingled non-goods proceeds to law outside Article 9, and one familiar convention for a mixed bank account is the lowest intermediate balance rule.17 When funds that are proceeds are commingled with funds that are not, the rule presumes that the lowest balance in the total fund, measured from the time of the commingling to the time of the tracing, is identifiable proceeds of the collateral.18 The word intermediate refers to the stretch between those two moments. The rule looks at every balance the account showed along the way and picks the smallest. The previous subsection established that the secured party must prove what part of a pooled account traces to its collateral, and this rule supplies the arithmetic for that proof.
The rule rests on a simple picture of how a debtor uses an account. Withdrawals are treated as coming first from the debtor's own money, so the proceeds are presumed to remain for as long as the balance stays above the amount deposited. Once the balance falls below that amount, the part that fell away is treated as spent, and a later deposit does not restore it, because new money may come from customers or other sources that have nothing to do with the collateral. Looking to the lowest balance, and not the balance on the day of the tracing, keeps the lender from reaching money that entered the account long after the sale. The result is conservative: the lender claims only what must still be in the account if the debtor spent its own money first.
A worked example from the commentary shows how the lowest balance is found. A debtor sells an item of equipment and receives $100 as proceeds. The debtor deposits the $100 in a checking account that held $500, so the balance becomes $600. The debtor then withdraws $550, which leaves $50, and later deposits another $200, which brings the balance to $250. The lowest balance after the proceeds went in is $50, so the identifiable proceeds are $50.19 The withdrawal explains the figure. The first $500 taken out is presumed to be the debtor's own money, so the last $50 must have come out of the proceeds, and only $50 of the $100 deposit survived. The later $200 deposit and the ending balance of $250 come after the low point and cannot revive what the withdrawal consumed. The $500 that sat in the account before the deposit plays no part, because the measuring window opens when the proceeds go in.
The limit in the last step matters when the account is barely touched. If a debtor deposits $100 of proceeds and the account never falls below the post-deposit balance of $600, the lowest balance exceeds the proceeds, and the claim stops at the $100 that was deposited.
The zero decides that result. A balance that bottoms out at $0 leaves the lender nothing, while a balance that bottoms out at $1,500 leaves $1,500 identifiable, and the $9,000 ending balance is the same in both cases. A drained account breaks the chain because the presumption treats the last of the proceeds as having left with the last dollar, and anything that arrives afterward is new money. A worked problem on a debtor's checking account turns on the same point: if the account was totally depleted and then replenished, a competing tax lien would have priority over the lender's claim to the later funds.20
The rule is a presumption borrowed from other law, and § 9-315(b)(2) adopts it only as one of the tracing methods that outside law permits for commingled property of that type.21 A party may therefore argue for a different method, and a different presumption can change the amount. In the tax-lien problem, the $2,000 remaining in the account is presumed to be what is left of the $10,000 that was there on March 6 if a rule like the lowest intermediate balance rule applies. That presumption gives the bank an argument that its interest in the $2,000 has priority over the tax lien, while a different tracing presumption would favor the tax lien.22 Under the lowest intermediate balance rule, the identifiable proceeds in that account are $2,000, and the bank has a perfected security interest in that amount.23
An exam answer on a mixed deposit account should state the presumption, compute the lowest balance from whatever deposits and withdrawals the facts supply, cap the result at the amount of proceeds deposited, and note that the method is borrowed from outside law and that another presumption could be argued. Fixing the identifiable amount settles only what the lender's interest reaches. The next section turns to perfection in proceeds, using crops fed to livestock.