Concept
Subordination in Practice
Subordination (§ 9-339)
Subordination in Practice
Accessions show subordination by agreement at work. An accession is a good installed or affixed to other goods, such as a new motor installed in an automobile, and its financer may face a competing claim to the whole, such as a lender holding a security interest in the automobile.1 Article 9 does not preclude subordination by agreement by a person entitled to priority, so the practical questions are who holds priority and whether that person will step back.2
The accession rules have one exception that matters here, and it involves certificate-of-title collateral. A security interest in an accession is subordinate to a security interest in the whole that was perfected by compliance with a certificate-of-title statute.3 The exception overrides not only § 9-322 but also § 9-324, so the titled lender prevails even against a financer of the part.4 It does its work only where the lender on the whole has perfected under the title statute.
The tire seller illustrates the result. A seller that finances tires for a car that is also subject to a security interest securing the car's purchase price will generally be unable to remove the tires on default.5 The seller did not miss a filing. It lacked the one thing that could have changed the outcome, which is the titled lender's agreement to rank behind.
The burden of getting that agreement falls on the financer of the new engine, tires, or other part. If it wants priority over the car lender, it should secure a subordination agreement from the lender whose name appears on the certificate of title.6 The name on the certificate tells the financer whom to ask. The agreement must come from that lender, because a subordination is made by the person willing to give up its position, and the rights of a creditor cannot be adversely affected by an agreement to which it is not a party.7 A priority clause in the financer's contract with the debtor therefore gives the financer nothing against a titled lender that never joined it.
The engine financer and the tire seller each financed a part for a vehicle carrying a titled lender, and they differ only in whether that lender agreed to rank behind. The one who obtained the agreement ranks first. The one who did not generally ranks behind. A financer who wants priority should therefore secure the titled lender's agreement before it extends credit.
Fixtures follow a similar pattern. A security interest in fixtures, whether or not perfected, has priority over the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner who has consented in writing to the security interest or has disclaimed an interest in the goods as fixtures.8 The security interest also has priority if the debtor has a right to remove the goods as against the encumbrancer or owner.9 Written consent does for the fixture financer what the titled lender's agreement does for the accession financer: the party whose interest conflicts gives way.