Concept
Assignee Stands in Assignor's Shoes
Assignee subject to account debtor's terms, claims, and defenses
Defenses Against the Assignee
Assignee Stands in Assignor's Shoes
An assignee of an account can collect only what the assignor could have collected. UCC § 9-404(a) writes that rule into the Code: unless the account debtor has made an enforceable agreement not to assert defenses or claims, and subject to subsections (b) through (e), the rights of an assignee are subject to the categories of defense and claim that the subsection goes on to list.1 Courts reduce the command to an image: the assignee stands in the shoes of the assignor.2
Each of those objections is a defense, or a claim in recoupment (an affirmative defense claiming an amount the plaintiff owes the defendant), arising under the contract. The homeowner may assert it against the bank.3
Three roles recur in every § 9-404 problem. The account debtor, the homeowner, owes payment on the right. The assignor, the painter, earned the right and transferred it. The assignee, the bank, took the transfer and now wants to collect. The bank's position is derivative: it steps into a contract that already exists. That route, and the legal relationship it creates, differ from those of a third-party beneficiary, whom the original parties meant to benefit when they made the contract.4
The word assignee covers more than a lender. Article 9 reaches an assignment of accounts made as security for an obligation, and it also reaches a sale of accounts, because financing on the strength of accounts is often conducted so that the line between a security transfer and a sale blurs.5 A buyer of accounts therefore takes on the same terms as a secured lender. As the official comment puts it, when Article 9 governs, “an assignee generally takes an assignment subject to defenses and claims of an account debtor.”6
The rule follows from what an assignment is. The assignor can transfer only the right it has, so the assignee can receive no more. A Minnesota court in Delacy Investments, Inc. v. Thurman called this black-letter law and traced it to the maxim nemo dat qui non habet: no one may transfer more than he owns.7 Commercial policy points the same way. The ability to assign contract rights is an important source of business financing, so Article 9 promotes assignability, and attempts to restrict assignment are usually ineffective.8 The account debtor therefore cannot ordinarily refuse a new creditor. The shoes rule ensures that the new creditor's arrival costs the account debtor none of its defenses.
The assignee takes the contract itself, terms and all. In Delacy, an independent-contractor agreement between Re/Max and Thurman gave the assignee a right to Thurman's commissions only to the extent they exceeded his past-due financial obligations to Re/Max. The assignee's rights were subject to all terms of that agreement, and the commissions from Thurman's sales did not exceed what he already owed. The assignee collected nothing from Re/Max.9 Another court bound an assignee to an arbitration clause in the account debtor's contract with the assignor, finding support in Systran Financial Services Corp. v. Giant Cement Holding, Inc., 252 F. Supp. 2d 500 (N.D. Ohio 2003). Systran reasoned that an assignee unwilling to arbitrate collection disputes “could have contracted with [the assignor] to prevent it from entering into any agreement that contained arbitration clauses”; because it did not, it was bound.10 The assignee deals with the assignor and can bargain with it. The account debtor never chose the assignee.
An account debtor can, however, give up its defenses in advance, which is what the lead-in's opening clause contemplates.
The waiver in the oven example works for the reason it works in the standard tractor illustration. The goods are not consumer goods, and the assignee is assumed to have given value and taken in good faith without notice of the defense.11 The waiver section later in this chapter examines those conditions. For now, the shoes principle is the default, and a valid waiver is how a drafter overrides it.
Perfection does not change the default. A perfected security interest is generally effective against creditors “except as otherwise provided in the Uniform Commercial Code,” UCC § 9-201(a), and § 9-404(a)(1) provides otherwise.12 The Sixth Circuit reached the same conclusion in National City Bank, Northwest v. Columbian Mutual Life Insurance Co., 282 F.3d 407 (6th Cir. 2002). It found “no authority for the proposition that a perfected assignment to a third person takes precedence over a right of recoupment created between the original contracting parties in their contract.”13 Perfection protects the assignee against other creditors. It does not enlarge the assignee's rights against the account debtor.
With the baseline fixed, the structure of subsection (a) comes into view. Its lead-in carves out the enforceable waiver and makes everything that follows subject to subsections (b) through (e).14 Paragraph (a)(1) subjects the assignee to all terms of the agreement between the account debtor and the assignor, and to any defense or claim in recoupment arising from the transaction that gave rise to the contract.15 Paragraph (a)(2) adds any other defense or claim of the account debtor against the assignor that accrues before the account debtor receives a notification of the assignment signed by the assignor or the assignee.16 The first category carries no timing condition; the second turns on notification, which the next sections explain. An effective notification must be authenticated by the assignor or the assignee (the 2022 amendments say “sign”). It must also state that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.17
The later subsections then limit the general rule. Subsection (b) generally lets an account debtor assert a claim against an assignee only to reduce the amount the account debtor owes. A separate consumer protection law that provides otherwise preempts under subsection (c), and subsection (d) preserves the effect of the Federal Trade Commission notice for consumer account debtors.18 Later sections take up those limits, along with the special rules for omitted holder notices and for health-care-insurance receivables.