Concept
Notification as the Cutoff
Assignee subject to account debtor's terms, claims, and defenses
Notification as the Cutoff
The date on which the account debtor receives notification of the assignment sorts its complaints into two groups, and it matters to only one of them. Paragraph (a)(1) of § 9-404 reaches all terms of the agreement between the account debtor and the assignor, along with any defense or claim in recoupment arising from the transaction that gave rise to the contract.1 Paragraph (a)(2) reaches any other defense or claim of the account debtor against the assignor, but only one that accrues before the account debtor receives a notification of the assignment signed by the assignor or the assignee.2 The earlier sections took each paragraph on its own. This section sets both against one timeline, because an exam question usually asks first which paragraph a complaint falls under and only then whether the notification date matters.
The two paragraphs answer the timing question in opposite ways. Under (a)(1), a defense or claim arising from the transaction that gave rise to the contract with the assignor reaches the assignee whether it accrues before or after the account debtor is notified.3 Under (a)(2), a defense or claim that accrues after the account debtor receives notification is cut off.4 The difference follows from what each kind of complaint attaches to. An (a)(1) complaint is built into the right the assignee took, since an assignee generally takes the assignment subject to the account debtor's defenses and claims.5 An (a)(2) complaint grows out of some other dealing between the account debtor and the assignor. Once the account debtor knows the account has been assigned, a new unrelated claim is something it must pursue against the assignor, not subtract from the assignee's payment.
The widget facts from the last section mark the line. Seller had two contracts with Buyer. On May 2 Seller assigned the amount due under the second contract to Bank and delivered the widgets to Buyer that same day, and Bank then notified Buyer of the assignment. Seller failed to deliver on June 1 under the first contract, and Buyer tried to set off its damages against the payment due Bank. The setoff fails: the claim accrued on June 1, after Buyer had been notified, and it arose under a contract independent of the one assigned.6
Two changes to those facts show the line moving. Had Seller's failure to deliver under the first contract come before Buyer received Bank's notification, the claim would have accrued in time and Buyer could have asserted it against Bank. Had Buyer instead complained that Seller's performance under the assigned contract itself was defective, the complaint would arise from the transaction that gave rise to that contract. It would fall under (a)(1) and reach Bank whether the defect surfaced before or after notification.7 The house-painting example makes the same point: if the painter assigns the price to a bank, the homeowner may assert against the bank every recoupment defense arising under the contract, such as that the house was never painted, was painted improperly, was painted by an unlicensed contractor, or was sold through misrepresentations the homeowner relied on.8 In every variation the notification date stays where it was. What moves the answer is where the complaint comes from and, for unrelated complaints, when it accrued.
Because the notification date draws the line, the statute's description of notification repays close reading. The text asks whether the account debtor itself received a notification of the assignment signed by the assignor or the assignee.9 Older commentary on the section says the notification must be authenticated by the assignor or assignee,10 and the 2022 amendments use "sign" in place of "authenticate."11 To be effective, the notification must also state that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.12 The reason is functional. An assignee is a third party who joins a contract already made, unlike a third-party beneficiary, whom the contracting parties meant to benefit when they formed it.13 The account debtor has no way to know about that newcomer until someone tells it, so the statute ties the cutoff to a communication that names the assignment and says whom to pay. The assignee controls the resulting date: it can send a conforming notification the day it takes the assignment, and from the day the account debtor receives it, new unrelated claims no longer reach it.
The middle steps screen out events that sound like notification but are not. The statute describes a signed communication that reaches the account debtor, says the amount has been assigned, and directs payment to the assignee.14 The assignee's filing of a financing statement does none of those things, and neither does the account debtor's informal awareness that an assignment happened.
Step one matters most, because it prevents arguments aimed at the wrong paragraph. In the dispute between CE, an assignee seeking to recover a commission, and Re/Max, the independent-contractor agreement between Re/Max and Thurman, the assignor, limited payment to Thurman to commissions exceeding his past-due financial obligations to Re/Max. The court held that the plain language of § 9-404(a)(1) makes the rights of CE, as an assignee, subject to all terms of the agreement between the account debtor and the assignor. CE could take no greater rights than Thurman had and could not collect a commission to which Thurman himself was not entitled, so the court upheld summary judgment for Re/Max.15 The limit was a term of the agreement, and (a)(1) has no notification condition, so the court's reasoning rested on (a)(1) alone. When the complaint is a contract term or same-transaction recoupment, the date of any notice is beside the point.
Payment shows the cutoff working on a defense unrelated to the assignor's performance. An account debtor who answers the assignee's demand with 'I have paid that' is tested by the same line: the defense counts as one that accrued after notification unless the payment was made before the notification.16 Payment made before the account debtor received notification therefore stands as a defense against the assignee, and payment made afterward does not.