Concept
Limits on Asserting Claims
Assignee subject to account debtor's terms, claims, and defenses
Limits on Asserting Claims
Section 9-404(a) does not hand the account debtor everything it has against the assignor. Its opening words qualify the rule twice. The assignee's rights are subject to the listed defenses and claims "unless an account debtor has made an enforceable agreement not to assert defenses or claims," and the whole rule operates "subject to subsections (b) through (e)."1 The first qualification is the waiver of defenses, which gets its own section next. The second sends the reader to four further subsections, and those subsections are the limits this section introduces.
The point matters for how you apply the baseline. The image of the assignee standing in the assignor's shoes is a starting description, not a finished answer. A court asked what an account debtor may assert against an assignee cannot stop at subsection (a); it must check whether the account debtor has agreed not to assert defenses or claims, and whether one of subsections (b) through (e) cuts back what the account debtor may do.2
The sections that follow take the qualifications in turn. They first show how a claim operates against the amount the account debtor owes. They then cover the exceptions: waiver of defenses, consumer account debtors, omitted holder notices, and health-care-insurance receivables.