Concept
Consumer and Health-Care Exceptions
Modification of the assigned contract
Consumer and Health-Care Exceptions
Section 9-405(a) states its own limits in its last sentence: the good-faith modification rule "is subject to subsections (b) through (d)."1 Subsection (b), covered above, divides a single contract by timing, so one contract can hold terms still open to modification and terms already closed. Subsections (c) and (d) cut along different lines. They ask who the account debtor is and what kind of receivable was assigned, and either answer can change which rule applies before the good-faith and timing questions are reached.
The two exceptions work differently, and the difference matters. Subsection (c) defers to other law. When a statute or rule outside Article 9 sets a different rule for an account debtor who is an individual and who incurred the obligation primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, that law governs, and § 9-405 gives way to it. Subsection (d) removes a whole class of assignment. Section 9-405 does not apply to an assignment of a health-care-insurance receivable, so the modification rule supplies no answer, and the question must be resolved from other sources.
Consider two receivables in the same assigned pool. A homeowner owes the first for furniture bought for the family's use. The second is a health-care-insurance receivable. An agreement to change the terms of either one does not call first for a good-faith inquiry. It calls for two prior questions: who owes the payment, and what is the payment for? The homeowner is an individual who incurred the debt for household purposes, so you must look for other law that sets a different rule. The insurance receivable falls outside § 9-405 entirely.
A fact pattern that looks like an ordinary modification problem may therefore sit outside the general rule, and spotting that at the outset is the first step in the analysis. The consumer provision comes first, because it requires you to read the account debtor's status closely and then identify which body of law takes over.