Concept
Notification in Practice
Discharge of the account debtor and effect of notification
Notification in Practice
Section 9-406(a) makes one event decisive. Until the account debtor receives a notification of the assignment, payment to the assignor discharges its obligation; after receipt, only payment to the assignee does.1 When that notification goes out depends on how the financing was built. In notification financing, the security agreement lets the secured creditor collect from the account debtors even before the debtor defaults. In non-notification financing, the debtor keeps collecting, and the creditor's right to direct payment depends on a later default.2
Notification financing is the simpler structure. The secured creditor merely notifies each account debtor and directs it to pay the creditor, and from then on the creditor collects directly.3 At default there is little left for §§ 9-607 and 9-608 to do, because collection is already under way.4 Each account debtor's protected period under § 9-406(a) closes when its notification arrives, so only payment to the assignee discharges it afterward. The notification also tells each customer about the financing, since it states that the amount due has been assigned.5
Non-notification financing keeps the financing out of the customer relationship. The assignor continues to collect from its own account debtors, and Article 9 permits it to do so.6 The first half of § 9-406(a) makes the arrangement work: until a notification arrives, payments to the assignor are valid and discharge the account debtors.7 The assignee pays for the quiet. Every payment made to the assignor before notification discharges the account debtor who made it, so the assignee cannot demand that money a second time from the customer.
Default by the assignor brings the assignee's collection right into play. Upon default, the secured party may notify account debtors to pay it, whether or not the assignor was collecting before.8 The two sections divide the work: § 9-607 gives the secured party the right to send the notice, and § 9-406(a) obliges the account debtor to pay the secured party once the notice arrives.9 The standard illustration runs as follows. A seller sells goods on open account to various buyers and assigns the accounts to a lender on a non-notification basis. The seller defaults, the lender notifies each buyer to pay it, and each buyer must thereafter pay the lender as assignee under § 9-406(a).10 The seller's default entitles the lender to collect, but the notification is what changes each buyer's position.
The line falls at receipt because an account debtor sees only what reaches it. A default between assignor and assignee happens inside their relationship, and an account debtor that had to guess whether it had occurred would pay at its own peril. A received notification gives the account debtor a dated event on which to rely. The assignee, for its part, chooses when to send it: early notice secures the cash, and delay preserves the quiet but leaves collections in the assignor's hands in the meantime.
For the account debtor, the practical question is whether paying the secured creditor will discharge what it owes the debtor, since a payment to the wrong party can leave it paying twice.11 Section 9-406(a) answers that question for a notification that meets the requirements covered earlier in this chapter. Whatever other rights the account debtor holds against the secured party depend on the contract or right assigned, the rules of Article 9, and the other law that governs assignment of that type of obligation.12 If collections fall short of the secured debt, the debtor may or may not remain liable for the deficiency; that question belongs to enforcement and stays outside this unit.13
Sold Payment Intangibles
A notification can be signed, received, and complete in content and still fail to bind the account debtor. Section 9-406(b)(2) makes a notification ineffective under subsection (a) to the extent that an agreement between the account debtor and a seller of a payment intangible limits the account debtor's duty to pay a person other than the seller, and the limitation is effective under law other than Article 9.16 A lender's right to repayment under an unevidenced loan is the standard example of such a right. Because the notification is ineffective in this setting, the first sentence of § 9-406(a) stays in force, and the account debtor may go on paying the seller and be discharged.17 All of the carve-out's conditions must be present, so the best way to apply it is as a sequence of questions, asked after the notification has already met the requirements covered earlier in this chapter.
Subsection (e) explains why the third step matters. Subsection (d), the general override of contract terms that restrict assignment and the subject of the later discussion of anti-assignment terms, does not apply to the sale of a payment intangible or promissory note, other than a sale pursuant to a disposition under § 9-610 or an acceptance of collateral under § 9-620.18 For an ordinary sale of a payment intangible, Article 9 therefore does not itself decide whether a restriction on paying anyone but the seller holds; other law does. Where other law enforces the restriction, the account debtor has made an enforceable promise to deal only with the seller, and subsection (b)(2) keeps the discharge rule from undercutting that promise. Without it, the buyer's signed notification would end the account debtor's safe harbor and force a choice between paying the buyer in breach of the promise and paying the seller at the risk of paying twice. With it, the notification does not take hold, and the account debtor may keep paying the seller. The words to the extent make the ineffectiveness proportional: a limitation that reaches only part of what the account debtor owes disables the notification only for that part.19
The same restriction attached to a different receivable gets no help from this carve-out. A manufacturer's right to be paid for goods delivered on credit is an account, and § 9-406(b)(2) speaks only of a seller of a payment intangible; subsection (e) likewise reaches only sales of payment intangibles and promissory notes. The customer who owes an account therefore cannot invoke the carve-out, and after it receives an effective notification, it discharges its obligation only by paying the assignee.20 That is why the first step of the checklist asks about the type of right and the type of transfer before anything else.
Subsection (e) leaves one kind of sale under the general override. A secured party that took a payment intangible as collateral may, after default, dispose of it under § 9-610 or accept it in satisfaction under § 9-620. When the payment intangible passes by either route, subsection (d) applies, and a restriction on paying anyone but the original seller does not stop the assignment.21 An acceptance under § 9-620 requires the debtor's consent: the debtor agrees to the terms in a record authenticated after default, or the secured party sends a proposal and receives no objection within 20 days. Silence never counts as consent to an acceptance in partial satisfaction, which needs the debtor's agreement in a record authenticated after default.22 The carve-out also speaks of a seller. An assignment that only secures a loan is not a sale, so on its wording the carve-out does not reach it.23
Two shortcuts produce wrong answers. The first treats any clause limiting payment to the assignor as a defense to a notification, though the clause defeats nothing unless the right is a sold payment intangible. The second treats a sale of a payment intangible as the whole test, though the carve-out also requires that law other than Article 9 give the limitation effect; where that law does not, the limitation is not effective and the notification binds the account debtor.24
Partial-Payment Notices
Section 9-406(b)(3) makes a notification ineffective on a third ground, which turns on how much the notification demands. At the account debtor's option, a notification is ineffective if it tells the account debtor to pay the assignee less than the full amount of any installment or other periodic payment.27 The first two grounds in § 9-406(b), a failure to identify the rights reasonably and a limitation on a sold payment intangible, disable a notification once their conditions are met. This ground depends on a choice, and the statute gives the choice to the account debtor. A signed notification that directs only part of each installment to the assignee therefore reaches an account debtor that may disregard it, and when the account debtor does, the first sentence of § 9-406(a) keeps its discharge by paying the assignor.28
The rule has two parts, an option and a bar on waiving it, and each has its own reason. The practical point of the option is bookkeeping. If a partial notice bound the account debtor, a $1,000 installment would have to be divided among the assignor and one or more assignees, each share computed and paid separately, month after month, under a division the account debtor did not make and cannot verify. The option lets the account debtor pay the whole installment to the assignor and leave the sorting to the parties who made the division. Because the option belongs to the account debtor, an assignee cannot compel a split, while an account debtor willing to carry the work may choose to honor the notice as written.
Three clauses, each introduced by even if, confirm that the option applies however the partial demand arose:
- The notification demands less than the full installment because only a portion of the account, chattel paper, or payment intangible has been assigned to that assignee.29
- The notification demands less than the full installment because a portion has been assigned to another assignee, so the account debtor may hold two partial notices for the same installment.30
- The notification demands less than the full installment, and the account debtor knows that the assignment to that assignee is limited.31
The third clause answers the argument most likely to occur to a student. An account debtor that knows the assignee holds only forty percent might seem to have no reason to resist a demand for forty percent, since the demand is accurate. Accuracy, however, does not reduce the work: the installment must still be split, the payments sent, and the records kept. Knowledge shows the account debtor that the demand is honest and leaves it just as costly to carry out, which is why the option survives that knowledge.
On an exam, put one question to any signed notification: does it direct the account debtor to pay the assignee less than the full amount of an installment or other periodic payment? The way the right happens to be divided among assignors and assignees does not change that question, and the amount demanded settles the answer.
The second result is the ordinary rule of § 9-406(a): after receipt of an effective notification, the account debtor may discharge its obligation only by paying the assignee.32 The tempting shortcut is to ask whether the assignment was partial and to treat a yes as decisive. The three clauses explain why partial ownership is common in these facts, but the statutory trigger is the demand in the notification, so the analysis starts by reading what the notification actually tells the account debtor to pay.
The option is protected against advance surrender. Section 9-406(g) denies the account debtor the power to waive or vary that option, subject to exceptions in subsections (h) and (l) that this unit leaves aside.33 The bar matters most where bargaining is weakest. An account debtor's contract is often the seller's own form, and if the option could be waived, the form could remove it as one more line of boilerplate, leaving the account debtor with the very bookkeeping burden the option avoids. Because the statute bars varying the option as well as waiving it, a clause that narrows or conditions the option fails just as a clause that eliminates it. Compare the sold payment intangible: there an agreement between the account debtor and the seller can create the protection, if other law gives it effect, while here no agreement can take the protection away.34