Concept
Consumer-Goods Duty to File
Termination statement (§ 9-513)
Consumer-Goods Duty to File
When a financing statement covers consumer goods, the secured party must act to clear it from the record without being asked. Section 9-513(a) provides that a secured party "shall cause the secured party of record for a financing statement to file a termination statement for the financing statement" if the financing statement covers consumer goods and a further condition is met.1 The verb is mandatory, and nothing in the sentence makes the duty depend on a request from the debtor.
Two questions therefore decide whether the duty exists. The first is one of scope: does the financing statement cover consumer goods? If it does not, subsection (a) does not apply. The second is whether a listed condition has been met. The conditions are joined by "or," so each is an independent ground for the duty.
The ground examined in this chapter is payoff. The duty arises when there is no obligation secured by the collateral covered by the financing statement and no commitment to make an advance, incur an obligation, or otherwise give value.2 Both halves must hold. A paid-off balance is not enough if the secured party is still bound to extend credit or give value, because the record would then still describe a live arrangement. A second alternative, introduced by the "or" at the end of that clause, supplies a different ground for the same duty. The sections that follow take up the payoff ground in two parts, first the absence of a secured obligation and then the absence of any commitment to advance, and then turn to deadlines.
A hypothetical shows how the pieces fit together. Dana buys a refrigerator on credit from Hartwell Appliance, and Hartwell files a financing statement covering the refrigerator as consumer goods. Dana makes the last installment, and Hartwell has promised no further credit. No obligation remains secured and no commitment to give value is outstanding, so the payoff condition is met. Hartwell must see to it that a termination statement is filed. Dana does not have to ask, and she may not know the public record exists.
The structure of the duty makes practical sense. The secured party chose to put the notice on the record, and it knows when the last payment arrives and whether it has promised more credit. A household that has finished paying is poorly placed to notice that anything remains to be cleaned up. Placing the task on the party that created the entry and holds the information puts it where it is most likely to be done. Later in the chapter, the treatment of collateral other than consumer goods shows how the rule changes once the debtor is expected to make a demand.
The text also separates two roles. The secured party owes the duty, but its object is to cause the secured party of record to file. When the person named on the record is not the same as the person bound by the duty, the bound party cannot excuse itself by pointing to someone else's name on the record. It must make sure the filing happens.