Concept
Collateral Other Than Consumer Goods
Termination statement (§ 9-513)
Collateral Other Than Consumer Goods
Section 9-513(c) governs every financing statement that subsection (a) does not reach, which means any collateral other than consumer goods, and it starts the clock in a different place. Within 20 days after a secured party receives a signed demand from a debtor, the secured party must cause the secured party of record either to send the debtor a termination statement or to file it in the filing office, if a condition the subsection lists exists.1 The duty runs from the demand. The debtor must ask in a signed demand, and the 20 days begin when the secured party receives it.
The consumer-goods rule works the other way. When a financing statement covers consumer goods and the debt is paid off with no commitment left to give value, the secured party must cause a termination statement to be filed, and it must do so without waiting to be asked.2 The duty is to file, not merely to hand the debtor a form.3 For other collateral, sending the termination statement to the debtor satisfies the duty, but only after a signed demand has started the 20 days.4
Both rules answer one question: what ends a filing once the debt behind it is gone. Filing is how most security interests are perfected,5 which is why the law sets deadlines for ending a filing after the debt is paid. The rules differ in who must set the process in motion: the secured party for consumer goods, and the debtor for everything else. The contrast, side by side:
| Consumer goods | Other collateral | |
|---|---|---|
| What starts the duty | Payoff of the debt, with no commitment left to give value; no request needed | A signed demand from the debtor, if a listed condition exists |
| What the secured party must do | Cause a termination statement to be filed | Send the termination statement to the debtor or file it |
| Deadline | One month after payoff, or 20 days after a signed demand if that date is earlier | 20 days after receiving the signed demand |
The two subsections below set the consumer-goods deadlines against this demand rule: first the one-month default, then the 20-day period that a signed demand can substitute for it. The conditions that trigger the demand rule, including the cases of sold receivables and consignments, are developed in the sections on other collateral later in the chapter.
One-Month Deadline
For consumer goods, the default deadline is one month. Absent a demand, the secured party must cause the termination statement to be filed within one month after there is no obligation secured by the collateral covered by the financing statement and no commitment to make an advance, incur an obligation, or otherwise give value.7 The duty it times is the one in subsection (a), which applies when the financing statement covers consumer goods and the payoff condition is met.8 That duty arises without any request, so no demand is needed to start the month, and the period governs the ordinary case in which the debtor says nothing.9
The month begins only when both halves of the payoff condition are true: no secured obligation remains, and no commitment to give value remains.10 The debtor's last payment ends the first half. It starts the month only if the secured party has promised nothing further. If a commitment outlasts the last payment, the month begins on the day the commitment ends. The statute measures from the moment the condition exists, so a secured party that is slow to notice the payoff gains no time.
Two questions, asked in order, resolve any timing problem under the default rule. Are both halves of the condition satisfied? And on what date were they first both satisfied? The month runs from that date. A debtor who wants the record cleared sooner has one tool, the signed demand, and the next subsection explains what it does.
The one-month period belongs to the consumer-goods duty alone. Suppose a financing statement covers a contractor's backhoe, the loan is paid, and no commitment remains. The payoff does not start a one-month deadline, because the secured party's duty runs from the debtor's signed demand.11
Twenty-Day Demand Deadline
A signed demand from the debtor adds a second deadline to the consumer-goods duty. The secured party must cause the termination statement to be filed within one month after the payoff condition is met or, if earlier, within 20 days after it receives a signed demand from the debtor.13
The if-earlier wording ties the two periods together. Each produces a candidate date, and the secured party must meet the earlier one. The demand therefore changes timing and nothing else: the consumer-goods duty already exists once the payoff condition is met, so the demand speeds up a duty the secured party already owes.14 A debtor who demands is never worse off than one who stays silent, and a demand that arrives too late leaves the one-month date where it was.
Two details of the text matter. The 20 days run from the day the secured party receives the demand, not from the day the debtor sends it. And the demand must be signed.15 A demand also does not create the duty. The conditions of subsection (a) still decide whether the secured party owes a filing at all.16
The comparison can come out the other way. Suppose the same family pays on March 1 but its signed demand does not reach the lender until March 25.
Whether a demand helps depends on how soon after payoff it arrives. A month runs about 30 or 31 days and the demand period is 20, so a demand received within roughly the first ten days after payoff produces the earlier date, while a later demand leaves the month in control. A secured party that lets the earlier date pass has missed its deadline even though the month has not yet run. The consequences are taken up later in this chapter.