Concept
When the Secured Party Does Not File
Termination statement (§ 9-513)
When the Secured Party Does Not File
A consumer pays off the loan secured by her piano. No obligation remains secured by the piano, and the lender has no commitment to advance more. Section 9-513(a) now says that the secured party "shall cause" the secured party of record to file a termination statement, because the financing statement covers consumer goods and no secured obligation or commitment to give value survives.1 Suppose the one-month period runs out and no termination statement appears. The same thing can happen with other collateral, where a debtor's demand can go unanswered past the twenty days. The earlier sections fixed when the duty arises and how long the secured party has to perform it. They did not say what follows when the secured party does nothing.
A missed deadline leaves the record where it was. The financing statement stays of record until a termination statement is filed, and lateness does not substitute for the filing. It goes on announcing a claim the secured party no longer has. A searcher sees collateral that looks pledged, the debtor's title stays clouded, and a lender asked to finance the same goods has reason to hesitate or to charge more. The debtor bears all of this. The secured party created the entry and alone owes the duty to clear it, yet it bears nothing until the law attaches a cost to its inaction.
Article 9 responds in two ways, and each answers a different harm. One repairs the record: a debtor whose secured party has defaulted on a required termination statement can act for itself, and a filing made on the debtor's authority can be effective when the secured party failed to perform. The other compensates the loss: a secured party that ignored the duty can be made to pay for the damage the stale filing caused, and a penalty may attach as well. The two remedies run independently. A debtor who wants a clean record need not win a damages claim first, and a debtor who has cleared the record on its own may still have losses to recover. The section on consequences of noncompliance takes up damages and the penalty first, then the debtor's own filing.