Concept
Commercially Reasonable Collection
Including secured party’s collection rights (§ 9-607)
Commercially Reasonable Collection
Section 9-607(c) requires a secured party to proceed in a commercially reasonable manner when two conditions are both met. First, the secured party undertakes to collect from or enforce an obligation of an account debtor or other person obligated on collateral. Second, it is entitled to charge back uncollected collateral or otherwise to full or limited recourse against the debtor or a secondary obligor.1 The statute joins the conditions with and, so a secured party that meets only one owes no duty under this subsection. Charge-back is the right to hand an uncollected account back to the debtor and charge the debtor for it. A secondary obligor is a person, such as a guarantor, who has agreed to answer for the debtor's obligation if the debtor does not pay.
Two secured parties show how the conditions sort cases. Bank takes a security interest in Debtor's accounts. After default it notifies Debtor's customers and sues the slow ones. Debtor remains liable for any shortfall, and Debtor's owner has guaranteed the loan. Bank has undertaken to collect and has recourse against both the debtor and a secondary obligor, so it must collect in a commercially reasonable manner. Factor, by contrast, has bought Debtor's accounts outright and has no recourse against Debtor. Factor may press customers just as hard as Bank does. It meets the first condition and fails the second, so § 9-607(c) imposes no duty on it.
The pairing tracks two questions: what the secured party did, and who bears the loss if it did it badly. Once a secured party undertakes to collect, its choices about whom to press, whom to sue, and what to accept shape how much comes in. Recourse or charge-back means a shortfall falls on the debtor or a secondary obligor, not on the secured party. The standard of commercial reasonableness gives those who bear the shortfall a yardstick for the secured party's choices. A secured party with no recourse and no charge-back right absorbs any shortfall itself, so its own interest already disciplines those choices.
Earlier discussion of limits on agreed rights placed this duty among the Part 6 duties that a security agreement cannot waive before default, so a lender cannot remove it with a clause in its form. The subsections that follow take the duty in turn: what it means to undertake to collect, how recourse and charge-back trigger the duty, how the duty applies to buyers of receivables, and how a court measures reasonableness.