Concept
Cumulative Remedies
Including secured party’s collection rights (§ 9-607)
Cumulative Remedies
A secured party that tries one post-default route does not give up the others. Section 9-601(c) provides that the rights under subsections (a) and (b) “are cumulative and may be exercised simultaneously.”1 Cumulative means that the rights add to one another instead of displacing one another; simultaneously means that the secured party need not finish one before it begins the next. The cumulation reaches both sides of the default: the secured party's rights under the agreement and under Part 6, and the debtor's and obligor's rights after default under those same two sources.2 A secured party that elects one course is therefore not barred from taking another.3
Simultaneous pursuit is the point of the rule. A secured party might repossess the goods and, at the same time, commence an action on the debt.4 Neither step commits the lender to the other, so it can protect the collateral and press its claim without first guessing which route will pay.
A judgment on the debt shows the same freedom from the other direction. A secured party that obtains a judgment for the amount owed may collect it by any legal means, such as execution on other property of the debtor or garnishment of a debt a third person owes the debtor, and that collection does not prevent it from realizing on the collateral under Article 9's default procedures.5
The permission to run every route at once has a single limit. The secured party is owed one obligation, and each route is only a way of collecting it, so every dollar realized by any route reduces what remains owing. The Code's treatment of proceeds marks the same ceiling: a secured party generally may proceed against both the original collateral and any proceeds, but it may have only one satisfaction.6 A sale that falls short leaves the debtor liable for the deficiency,7 while a sale that covers the debt leaves nothing for any other route to collect.
Consumer transactions carry one caveat that comes from outside Article 9. Some states restrict by statute a creditor's right to repossess or sell consumer goods and then collect a deficiency, and in some of them, usually when the debt falls below a stated amount, the creditor must choose between suing on the whole debt and repossessing and reselling the goods without any claim to a deficiency. Where such a statute conflicts with the Code, the statute governs, and a creditor that takes the goods gives up the right to pursue the consumer personally for the shortfall. The caveat matters only when the facts supply such a statute.
An exam stem in which a lender repossesses a debtor's car and also sues on the note invites the objection that the lender has already chosen its remedy. Under § 9-601(c) the objection fails, because the Code does not make the secured party elect. The analysis changes in only two ways: the stem supplies a state consumer statute that requires an election, or the amounts already realized have paid the debt in full.