Concept
Duties While in Possession
Including secured party’s collection rights (§ 9-607)
Duties While in Possession
A secured party that already holds the collateral when the debtor defaults takes on a defined set of custodial rights and duties. Section 9-601(b) provides that a secured party in possession of collateral, or in control of collateral under Section 9-104, 9-105, 9-106, or 9-107, has the rights and duties provided in Section 9-207.1 Possession is physical custody, as when a lender repossesses a delivery van. Control is the counterpart for collateral such as a deposit account, where there is nothing to pick up. The Code defines control separately for each type of collateral that can be controlled, and it does not require that the debtor be excluded from access.2 Section 9-601(b) adds no rules of its own. It imports § 9-207, and the rest of this unit summarizes what that section demands of a creditor holding collateral after default.
Before default, a secured party with possession is a kind of bailee (pledgee): a custodian who keeps another's property for a limited purpose and must look after it.3 Section 9-207 supplies the duty and the matching rights for that role. Its money rule shows whose interest the custodian is protecting. Cash received from the collateral must either reduce the secured debt or go back to the debtor, so the debtor keeps a stake in how the collateral is handled.4
The central duty is reasonable care in the custody and preservation of the collateral.5 The rest of § 9-207 consists of rights and obligations that surround that duty:6
- The secured party may charge reasonable expenses of caring for the collateral to the debtor and secure them with the collateral.
- It must keep the collateral identified, although it may commingle fungible collateral.
- It may use or operate the collateral to preserve it and its value, or as a court permits or, in a nonconsumer transaction, as the debtor agrees.
- It may hold proceeds other than money or funds as additional security.
- It must apply proceeds that are money or funds to reduce the secured obligation, or remit them to the debtor.
- It may create a security interest in the collateral.
The rights follow from the duty. A custodian who must spend money to protect someone else's property needs a way to recover it, and § 9-207 lets the secured party charge reasonable expenses to the debtor and secure the charge with the collateral itself. Proceeds that are not money or funds can be held as additional security. Money or funds cannot sit in the secured party's hands, because they must be applied to the debt or sent back to the debtor.
The debtor's consent can also end the holding. When a secured party proposes to accept the collateral in satisfaction of the debt, the debtor consents by agreeing to the terms in a record authenticated after default, or by failing to object within 20 days after the secured party sends the proposal. Silence does not count as consent to acceptance in partial satisfaction. A secured party that wants a partial strict foreclosure needs the debtor's agreement in a record authenticated after default.7
Section 9-207(d) treats a buyer of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, and a consignor, differently from a lender holding a pledge. The obligations summarized above do not apply to them, with one exception: a buyer or consignor entitled to recourse against the debtor or a secondary obligor on account of uncollected collateral must take reasonable care of the collateral in its possession.8 A buyer owns what it buys, so ordinarily the buyer alone bears the loss from mishandling it. Recourse changes that, because an uncollected item can come back to the seller, and the seller's position then depends on how well the buyer kept it.