Concept
Collection From Account Debtors
Including secured party’s collection rights (§ 9-607)
Collection From Account Debtors
Repossession works on goods and fails on a right to be paid. A lender whose collateral is a delivery van can send someone to drive it away. A lender whose collateral is an account has nothing to pick up, because the collateral is another person’s obligation to pay the debtor, and any paper that records the obligation is only evidence of it.1 Article 9 therefore lets the secured party collect from the person who owes the money. Section 9-607(a) opens with a timing condition: “If so agreed, and in any event after default,” the secured party may exercise the powers the subsection lists.2 Those powers include notifying the obligor to pay the secured party, taking proceeds, and enforcing the obligor’s duty in the debtor’s place.3
Each power is aimed at a particular person, so the cast needs naming. The debtor granted the security interest, and the secured party is the lender. The account debtor owes the debtor on an account, on chattel paper, or on a general intangible, and it never joined the loan.4 The statute also reaches other persons obligated on collateral, such as the maker of a note the debtor holds or the bank that holds the debtor’s deposit account.5
Before any default, the arrangement usually runs the other way: the debtor keeps collecting from its customers and sends the lender separate payments.6 Default makes that arrangement dangerous, because a debtor who can still collect can also spend what it collects. Section 9-607 lets the secured party step into the debtor’s place as collector. Collection is a choice and not an obligation; the secured party may instead conduct a disposition or a retention of the collateral.7 A disposition invites its own scrutiny. A low price does not by itself show a violation, but it tells a court to examine every aspect of the sale for commercial reasonableness.8 The subsections below follow the powers of § 9-607 in order: when they arise, notification, proceeds, enforcement against the obligor, deposit accounts, and nonjudicial enforcement of a mortgage.
When Collection Rights Arise
Section 9-607(a) offers two routes to the collection powers: the parties’ agreement and, “in any event,” default.9 Default is the baseline, and agreement is the bargained-for exception that brings the rights forward. Article 9 lets the secured party contact account debtors only after default, unless the parties agree that it may do so sooner. A lender whose security agreement is silent about collection, and whose debtor is paying on schedule, therefore may not yet tell the debtor’s customers to pay it.10
Each route answers a different concern. Before trouble appears, a business that sells on credit lives on its receivables, and the parties may let it go on collecting them without telling customers that the accounts were assigned.11 After default, the lender’s source of repayment drains away through the debtor’s own hands unless the lender can redirect the payments, so the statute grants that power without any earlier bargain. A lender unwilling to wait can bargain for earlier control. If the security agreement so provides, the lender may inform account debtors before default that their accounts were used as collateral or sold, and may require them to pay it directly even though no default has occurred.12
Receivables financing comes in two patterns, and the names matter. In notification financing, the agreement lets the lender notify the account debtors of the assignment and collect from them directly. In non-notification financing, the debtor keeps collecting its own accounts, and the account debtors never receive notice that the accounts were assigned.13 The timing condition does its work in the second pattern. There the lender’s right to obtain payment directly depends on a prior default; upon default, § 9-607 gives the lender the right to notify the account debtor, and § 9-406 then obliges the account debtor to pay the lender. The account debtor, for its part, must make sure that paying the lender discharges what it owes the debtor.14
A standard illustration shows the second pattern in motion. A seller assigns its accounts to a lender on a non-notification basis, and the seller goes on collecting from its customers. When the seller defaults, the lender may notify the customers to pay it, and it may do so whether or not the seller had been making its own collections.15 From then on, a customer may discharge its debt only by paying the lender as assignee.16 The illustration depends on the default. Without it, the same lender holds the accounts as collateral and has no power to redirect the customers.
A financer that buys accounts, chattel paper, promissory notes, or payment intangibles outright stands apart from both routes. After an outright sale, the buyer, not the seller, owns the assets,17 and an owner has no need to wait for anyone’s default in order to collect what it owns. The form of the deal fixes the financer’s position. A bank that lends against a dealer’s chattel paper has made a secured loan and must rely on agreement or default. A bank that buys the same paper for a fixed sum, say $45,000, has bargained for both the risk and the benefit: it probably has no right to a deficiency, yet it is entitled to any surplus above the $45,000.18 The later discussion of buyers of receivables returns to this contrast.
Two exam stems commonly mislead on timing. One stresses that the debtor is current and invites the conclusion that the lender cannot collect, which is wrong whenever the security agreement authorized earlier notice. The other describes a financer that bought the debtor’s accounts and invites a search for a default, which is beside the point because an owner collects without one.
Notifying the Account Debtor
Once its collection rights have arisen, a secured party may notify an account debtor or other person obligated on the collateral to pay it or to perform for its benefit.21 The notification redirects the money, and it takes a letter, not a lawsuit. The power exists whether or not the debtor had been making its own collections,22 and it matters most in non-notification financing, where customers have paid the debtor all along and may not know their accounts were assigned.23
Section 9-406(a) supplies the counterpart rule for the account debtor. An account debtor may discharge its obligation by paying the assignor, but only until it receives appropriate notification that the amount due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee. After it receives that notification, it may discharge the debt only by paying the assignee, which in a secured financing is the secured party.24 The rule governs accounts, chattel paper, and payment intangibles, and either the assignor or the assignee may authenticate the notification.25
The account debtor is a stranger to the financing. It took goods or services from the debtor and promised to pay the debtor; it signed nothing with the lender. If it had to track the lender’s rights without being told, it would risk paying the debtor and then hearing the lender demand the same money. So it may safely pay the party it has always paid until it is notified, and once an effective notification arrives, the risk of paying the wrong party falls on it. Because the risk shifts at the moment of notice, the notice must be reliable enough to deserve that effect. A notification is effective only if it does all three of the following:26
- It reasonably identifies the accounts, chattel paper, instruments, or payment intangibles in which the secured party has an interest or that have been assigned to it.
- It requires the account debtor to pay the secured party the entire obligation the account debtor owes the debtor.
- It reaches the account debtor through an authenticated record that states that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.27
Each requirement protects the account debtor. An authenticated record gives it something to read and keep, so it is never asked to redirect payments on the strength of an unrecorded call. Identification matters because a customer may owe the debtor on several contracts while the lender holds an interest in only some of them. The full-payment requirement keeps one obligation from being divided between two payees, so a notice that demands less than the whole obligation does not satisfy it. The notice demands the whole obligation even when the lender’s loan is smaller, because the lender applies what it collects to expenses and to its own debt and returns any surplus to the debtor.28
The secured party must also furnish the account debtor with reasonable proof of its right to payment. If it fails to do so, the account debtor may discharge its obligation by paying the debtor.29 The rule guards against false or mistaken demands, since anyone can write a letter claiming an assignment. If an account debtor ignores an effective notification and does not pay, the secured party may sue it directly,30 and the enforcement subsection below takes up that suit.
The phrase “other person obligated on collateral” reaches beyond the account debtor. The power to notify extends to the obligor on an instrument, such as the maker of a promissory note taken as collateral.31 The discharge rule of § 9-406(a), however, is written for accounts, chattel paper, and payment intangibles, and the obligation of the issuer of a negotiable instrument to pay the person entitled to enforce it falls under Article 3 instead.32 A contract term forbidding assignment does not block the notification. Generally, such a term in an agreement between an account debtor and an assignor, or in a promissory note, is “ineffective” under § 9-406(d), and the assignment does not constitute a default under the agreement.33
A notification keeps redirecting payments after the loan is repaid unless someone withdraws it, so Article 9 gives the secured party a duty to do so. If the debtor later satisfies its obligation to the secured party, the secured party must notify the account debtor of that fact and tell it to stop paying the secured party. A secured party that fails to give this notice is liable to the debtor for any actual loss plus $500 in statutory damages.34 Without the duty, the loan would be repaid while the customers kept sending money to a lender with no claim to it. The duty speaks of the debtor’s satisfying its obligation to the secured party, which is the language of a loan and not of an outright sale.
A stem that has a customer pay the debtor and then asks whether the lender may collect again is testing dates: which came first, the payment or an effective notification? Facts that add a telephone call, a demand for part of the balance, or a letter that fails to say which accounts it covers all defeat the notification, and the customer’s payment to the debtor then discharges the debt even though the lender thought it had given notice.
Taking Proceeds
Notification redirects money the account debtor still owes. The second collection power reaches value the debtor has already received for the collateral. Section 9-607(a)(2) lets the secured party take any proceeds to which it is entitled under Section 9-315.38 The cross-reference settles the division of labor: § 9-607 supplies the means, and § 9-315 decides whether a particular dollar or check can be taken.
Proceeds means whatever is acquired upon the sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of collateral; later clauses of the definition expand it and resolve ambiguities in the former rule.39 Cash proceeds include money, checks, and deposit accounts. In the standard illustration, a dealer’s inventory of cars is subject to a perfected security interest, and the dealer sells a car to a buyer in the ordinary course of business. The buyer pays with a trade-in car and a check or cash, and the balance is payable under a security agreement, a promissory note, or a bare promise to pay. The trade-in car, the check, the cash, the chattel paper, the instrument, and the account are all proceeds of the inventory.40
The entitlement comes from § 9-315(a)(2): the security interest attaches to any identifiable proceeds of collateral.41 The rule matters because a debtor who finances inventory is in the business of turning collateral into cash. If the lender’s claim ended with the goods, the debtor could defeat every remedy by completing the sale before the lender acted. Attachment to proceeds lets the lien follow the value into its new form. The word identifiable keeps the claim from spreading over the debtor’s whole estate: funds that cannot be traced to the collateral are not proceeds the lender may take, and § 9-315(b) governs when commingled proceeds still count as identifiable.42 The lender may proceed against both the proceeds and the original collateral, but it may have only one satisfaction of its debt.43
Whether a secured party may keep what it takes, as against a competing claimant, is a question of priority. The later discussion of senior and junior liens addresses it. A stem that says only that the debtor received money for collateral invites a quick yes, but the lender may take the money only if it is identifiable proceeds, and a debtor’s cash does not become the lender’s merely because the debtor defaulted.
Enforcing Account Debtor Obligations
Section 9-607(a)(3) lets a secured party enforce the obligations of an account debtor or other person obligated on collateral and exercise the debtor’s rights against that obligor, both as to the obligation to pay or perform and as to any property that secures it.46 The power finishes what notification starts. A letter redirects an obedient customer but cannot compel one who ignores it, and a right to be paid is worth only what its holder can do to make the obligor perform. When an account debtor who has received an effective notification still does not pay, the secured party may sue it directly.47
The source of the power is the debtor’s position, and that fixes how far it goes. The secured party steps into the debtor’s shoes and has whatever rights the debtor had against the account debtor.48 The design protects the account debtor, which dealt with the debtor, took delivery, and promised to pay, and which may not even know that its account was assigned. If assignment gave the lender stronger rights than the debtor held, a transaction among other people would enlarge what the account debtor owes. Giving the lender only the debtor’s rights leaves the account debtor where it started, owing what it owed and keeping the defenses it had. In the lawsuit, the account debtor has whatever defenses it had against the debtor.49
The second reach of subsection (a)(3), the debtor’s rights in property that secures the obligor’s promise, addresses a different asset standing behind the obligation. Without it, a lender able to collect only the money promise would leave the lien that backs the promise in the hands of a defaulting debtor with little reason to enforce it for the lender’s benefit. The standard illustration makes the point: after the debtor defaults, the lender may tell the account debtor to pay it, and if the account debtor does not, the lender may enforce the security interest the account debtor gave the debtor and repossess the property.50
Exactly which defenses and claims an account debtor may assert after notification, and how far, is the hard question. Sections 9-404 and 9-406 answer it, with a body of uneven case law, and it lies beyond this section.51 A stem in which a lender sues a customer who complains about the goods invites the assumption that the lender’s position is stronger than the seller’s, since the lender holds a default and a notification. The statute gives the lender the seller’s rights, and the seller’s rights were always subject to whatever the customer could say about the deal.
Section 9-607(e) states what the section leaves open: it does not determine whether an account debtor, bank, or other person obligated on collateral owes a duty to a secured party.52 The grants in subsection (a) tell the secured party what it may do, and none of them creates or defines an obligor’s duty. Whether the obligor owes anything, and what it can say in response to a demand, depends on the terms of the contract or right assigned, the other rules of Article 9, including §§ 9-401 through 9-409, and the other law governing assignment of that type of obligation.53 A stem that reasons from the lender’s power to sue straight to the obligor’s duty to pay has skipped the step that matters: what the obligor owed the debtor in the first place.
Deposit Account Collection
Two further powers in § 9-607(a) address the balance in the debtor’s own bank account, collateral that notification and suit serve poorly. If the secured party’s security interest in a deposit account is perfected by control under § 9-104(a)(1), it may apply the balance to the secured obligation.56 If its interest is perfected by control under § 9-104(a)(2) or (3), it may instead instruct the bank to pay the balance to it or for its benefit.57 A deposit account is Article 9’s name for a bank account, and control is the status that lets the secured party direct the funds without anything further from the debtor.
The three methods of control differ in who holds the money. Under § 9-104(a)(1), the secured party is the depositary bank itself, so the money is already on its books and it can apply the balance to the debt. Under § 9-104(a)(2), a record authenticated by the debtor, the secured party, and the depositary bank says that the bank will follow the secured party’s directions about the funds without further consent from the debtor. Under § 9-104(a)(3), the secured party has become the bank’s customer on the account.58 In the last two settings someone else holds the funds, so the secured party’s power is to instruct the bank, and the control arrangement gives the instruction its force. Either way the practical remedy is simple: the secured party takes the money in the deposit account and applies it to the debt.59 None of the three methods requires that the debtor be excluded from the funds,60 so the debtor may keep using the account until the secured party acts.
The vocabulary needs care, because Article 9 uses two similar words for two different assets. An account is money a third party owes the debtor, and the third party is the account debtor the earlier subsections showed a secured party notifying and enforcing against. A deposit account is the debtor’s bank account. The two classifications are perfected differently and foreclosed upon differently.61 The contractors who owed David for appliances owed him accounts, while the balance in David’s operating account is a deposit account.
Control matters because a bank balance can disappear in an instant. A payee who receives funds from the debtor’s deposit account takes them free of the lender’s security interest unless the payee acted in collusion with the debtor, even if the payee gave no value.62 A lender that had to sue, win a judgment, and levy before touching the account would usually arrive after the debtor had emptied it. Control gives the secured party its own way to reach the money, without a court and without the debtor’s cooperation.
Without control, neither power exists. When the security interest in a deposit account is unperfected, or is perfected in some way other than control, the secured party’s ability to collect against the bank holding the account is determined by other law.63 Control is built from the lender’s own position as the bank, as a party to the bank’s agreement, or as the bank’s customer. A lender with none of those positions is a stranger to the bank.
Missing control removes only this direct route to the bank. The lender’s rights against the debtor remain, so it may still reduce its claim to judgment and pursue the debtor by any available judicial procedure.64 Two stem patterns call for sorting. One describes a lender holding accounts and then mentions a bank balance; money owed by customers is collected by notification, while the balance is a deposit account reached through control. The other describes a lender with a control arrangement and asks which power it holds; a lender that is the depositary bank applies the balance, and a lender that holds control through a control record or customer status instructs the bank.
Nonjudicial Mortgage Enforcement
Section 9-607(b) addresses one narrow kind of collateral, a right to payment backed by a mortgage. The debtor in this setting is a mortgagee, a lender whose loan is secured by a mortgage on someone else’s land, and it has pledged that loan to a lender of its own. The mortgagor owes the debtor and is therefore a person obligated on collateral, with the land standing behind the promise. That is the second reach of subsection (a)(3), the debtor’s rights in property that secures the obligor’s promise.67 If necessary to enable the secured party to exercise the debtor’s right to enforce the mortgage nonjudicially, the secured party may record two items in the office where the mortgage is recorded.68 Nonjudicial enforcement means foreclosure through an out-of-court procedure, where the applicable mortgage law provides one, and not through a lawsuit.69
The statute names the two items. The first is a copy of the security agreement that creates or provides for the security interest in the obligation the mortgage secures. The second is a sworn affidavit stating that a default has occurred on the obligation secured by the mortgage and that the secured party is entitled to enforce the mortgage nonjudicially.70
The two documents answer a problem of record. A secured party that holds only a security interest in the obligation the mortgage secures is not the mortgagee of record, so it may need to record documents that evidence its right to conduct the foreclosure.71 The copy of the security agreement shows by what right it acts in the mortgagee’s place. The affidavit supplies two sworn facts, default on the mortgage obligation and entitlement to enforce without a court. Because the affidavit is sworn, the secured party puts its own credibility behind both statements. The statute authorizes recording where recording is needed to make enforcement possible, and local mortgage law decides whether nonjudicial foreclosure is available at all.
Two different defaults are at work, and the exam tests whether you can keep them apart. The default that opens the collection powers of § 9-607(a) is the debtor’s default to its own lender. The default that the affidavit must swear to is a default on the mortgage obligation, which is the mortgagor’s default to the debtor. The secured party exercises the debtor’s rights and no greater ones, and under mortgage law the mortgagor must generally be in default before the mortgagee may foreclose.72 A secured party therefore cannot foreclose on a current mortgage, however badly its own debtor has behaved.
A stem that puts the secured party’s debtor in default and then jumps straight to a foreclosure sale of the land invites the answer that the secured party may sell. The facts to check are whether the mortgage itself is in default and whether local law allows the out-of-court sale.