Concept
Expenses and Application of Proceeds
Including secured party’s collection rights (§ 9-607)
Expenses and Application of Proceeds
A secured party that collects from the people who owe the debtor ends up holding money that is not all its own. Article 9 regulates that money in three steps. The secured party first subtracts its reasonable costs of collecting, then applies what remains in a fixed order, and finally accounts to the debtor for any surplus or looks to the debtor for any shortfall.
Collection is one route among several. When the collateral is an obligation owed to the debtor, such as an account, a note, or a deposit account, the secured party may collect it directly from the person who owes it.1 It need not do so, because it may instead dispose of the collateral or retain it.2 Once it chooses to collect, § 9-607 lets it deduct reasonable expenses of collection and enforcement from what it receives,3 and § 9-608 sets the order of payment and decides who keeps any surplus and who answers for any deficiency.4
These rules are necessary because collecting does not make the money the secured party’s own. Its claim reaches the collections only to the extent of the secured debt and the cost of collecting it. Value above that belongs to the debtor, and other creditors may hold interests in the same collateral. Neither the debtor nor those creditors can see the secured party’s books, and a collector free to inflate its expenses or pay itself first could leave everyone else with nothing. Article 9 therefore fixes the arithmetic in advance.
The same arithmetic ties back to the recourse discussion above. Where a secured party may look back to the debtor for a shortfall, these rules measure the shortfall. Where the transaction is a true sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, the buyer collects for itself, and the seller has no surplus to claim and no deficiency to pay.5 The subsections that follow trace the money in the order it moves: what comes off the top, who is paid next, and who keeps the rest.
Deducting Collection Expenses
Collecting costs money, and § 9-607 says who bears the cost. A secured party may deduct from its collections the reasonable expenses of collection and enforcement, including the reasonable attorney’s fees and legal expenses it incurred.6 The right operates on money already in hand. The secured party collects first, and the expense comes out of the collected funds before anything is applied to the debt. A lender that mails notifications, hires a lawyer to sue a customer who will not pay, and pays the filing fee has spent money that the statute lets it charge against what those efforts brought in.
The reason lies in who benefits. Every dollar collected reduces what the debtor still owes, so the debtor gains from the lawyer’s demand letters and lawsuits as much as the lender does, and the cost of producing the money fairly comes out of the money produced. A rule that made the lender bear its own collection costs would leave it with less than it collected on the very accounts that secure its loan, and a lender deciding whether to chase a slow customer would count that cost against the chase.
The word that decides most problems is reasonable. The deduction rests on the secured party’s own bills, and the people affected by those bills cannot see them or check the work. Every dollar deducted is a dollar that neither reduces the debt nor returns to the debtor as surplus. A lender allowed to deduct whatever it spent would have no reason to economize, so the statute ties the deduction to reasonableness. The text sets three conditions: the expense must be one of collection and enforcement, it must be reasonable, and legal fees and expenses must be ones the secured party itself incurred.7 The adjective reaches attorney’s fees too, so a lawyer’s bill earns no special deference, and a charge larger than the work reasonably called for is deductible only up to the reasonable amount.
Paying an outside firm for work done in connection with the accounts does not by itself make the charge deductible. The question is whether the work was reasonably needed to collect.
An expense that fails the test does not come out of the fund, so its amount remains in the money applied to the secured debt and, if anything is left over, returned to the debtor. The order of that application is the subject of the next subsection.
Order of Application
Deducting reasonable expenses is the first rung of a longer ladder. Section 9-608(a) ranks every claim on the collected fund: the secured party first pays expenses, then pays itself, then pays any subordinate secured parties who have given the required notice, and finally gives anything left over to the debtor.9 The commentary describes the junior rung more precisely. The holder of a junior security interest in the same collateral is paid from the remaining proceeds only if it has made a written demand and, when asked, furnishes reasonable proof of its security interest.10 (The Code’s word for the demand is authenticated.) The statute fills four rungs, in this order:
- Reasonable expenses of collection and enforcement, including reasonable attorney’s fees and legal expenses.
- The obligation secured by the interest under which the secured party is collecting.
- Subordinate security interests whose holders made written demand and, if asked, furnished reasonable proof.
- Whatever remains, which goes to the debtor.
Each rung ranks where it does for a reason. Expenses come first because they created the fund: without the notifications, demands, and lawsuits there would be nothing to distribute. The collecting party comes second because the effort enforced its interest, and its claim is what the effort was meant to satisfy. Subordinate holders come third because their claims rank behind the collecting party’s, so they can be paid only from what its claim leaves. The debtor comes last because only value above every claim is the debtor’s own.
A senior interest does not appear on the ladder at all. The commentary reasons that senior interests receive no distribution because their claims in the collateral are unaffected by the sale.11 Whether a senior holder may nonetheless claim the money itself is a priority question, which the next section addresses.
The third rung carries a condition that the first two do not. The collecting party can see its own expenses and its own claim, but it cannot know every lender with an interest behind it, so the ladder puts the burden of coming forward on the junior holder. A junior holder that has made written demand, and that furnishes reasonable proof of its interest when asked, is paid from what remains. One that has done neither is not.12 What it would have received falls to the next claimant in line, ordinarily the debtor.13
The ranking does its real work when the fund runs short.
These are the commentary’s figures, which it works through a resale of repossessed collateral. The ladder is the same one § 9-608(a) applies to collections.14
The ladder presupposes a secured loan. A buyer that owns the accounts outright collects for itself and owes the seller no surplus unless the agreement says otherwise.15 The next subsection develops that contrast.
Noncash proceeds resist the ladder because a note or a piece of equipment taken in settlement of an account cannot be divided among the rungs the way money can. Under § 9-608(a), a secured party that collects in that form need not apply the proceeds to its debt or pay them to another claimant unless failing to do so would be commercially unreasonable. When it does apply or pay them over, it must do so in a commercially reasonable manner.
The parties cannot bargain away the debtor’s claim to the remainder. Article 9 restricts the parties’ ability to alter some of its enforcement provisions,16 and the secured party’s duty to account to the debtor for a surplus in a secured loan is among the provisions it protects. A debtor at closing has no leverage to resist a form clause, so if the duty could be waived in advance, every lender would add the waiver and the debtor’s claim to the remainder would vanish in practice. The collector also controls the fund and the only record of what was spent, so a clause letting it keep everything above its debt would turn the debtor’s equity in the collateral into a gift to the lender.
An exam stem that gives a collected total, a debt, and a junior lienholder invites the shortcut of paying the junior holder because its lien exists. What decides the problem is whether the holder demanded in time and whether the fund is large enough to reach the third rung. A stem that adds a senior lender calls for the opposite treatment: the senior holder stays out of the arithmetic.
Surplus and Deficiency
Once the ladder has been climbed, collections have either exceeded what was owed, fallen short, or matched it exactly. The first leaves a surplus, the second a deficiency, and the third neither. Who receives the surplus and who answers for the deficiency depend on the kind of transaction that produced the collateral. In a secured loan, the secured party gives anything left over to the debtor, and a shortfall remains the debtor’s liability.19 Section 9-608(b) states the exception: “If the underlying transaction is a sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, the debtor is not entitled to any surplus, and the obligor is not liable for any deficiency.”20 The organizing question is whether the financer lent money against the receivables or bought them.
The loan rule follows from what collateral does in a loan: it stands behind a debt and nothing more. Collections beyond the debt, with reasonable expenses already deducted, belong to the debtor because the lender has been made whole. When collections fall short, the debt is not fully paid, and what remains of it is still owed. A surplus and a deficiency are two results of one calculation. The secured party subtracts expenses, then the secured debt, then any junior holder that demanded in time, and a positive remainder goes to the debtor while a negative one stays on the debtor.
One dealer and one bank show how the form of the deal changes the answer. A dealer holds $50,000 of chattel paper and wants money against it. If the dealer signs a note for a $50,000 loan and a security agreement covering the paper, the deal is a secured loan: collections above the debt, after expenses, go to the dealer, and collections below it leave the dealer owing the difference. If the dealer instead sells the paper to the bank for a fixed $45,000, the bank probably has no right to a deficiency but is entitled to any surplus above the $45,000, because it bargained for both the risk and the benefit.21
The sale rule rests on ownership. After an outright sale, the buyer and not the seller owns the accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, so the seller has no leftover stake in them to account for and no unpaid debt to answer for.22 The price already measured the bargain: the buyer paid it knowing the paper might bring in more or less, and the seller was paid when the sale closed. Giving the seller a share of any gain would let it keep both the price and the benefit, and charging it for any loss would turn a purchase into a loan. The parties may displace the default, because the rule yields when the agreement provides for payment of a surplus or for a deficiency claim.23
Because the rule turns on the kind of transaction, the label the parties chose does not settle which side of the line a deal falls on. In this setting a sale presumably means some form of nonrecourse transfer.24 Where the assignee has no right of recourse or charge back if the account or chattel paper proves uncollectible, it assumes the credit risk completely, and the debtor owes no deficiency unless the security agreement so provides.25 An assignee that keeps a right to hand unpaid items back leaves the transferor bearing the shortfall, as a loan would, so the fact to look for is recourse and not the word purchase in the paperwork.
The two halves of the loan rule are not equally fixed. The secured party’s duty to account to the debtor for a surplus in a loan cannot be altered by agreement.26 Whether the financer has recourse for a shortfall depends on the agreement between the secured creditor and its debtor and, absent specific terms, on the form of the transaction.27 The difference follows from who gains. A clause that confines the lender to the collateral gives the debtor something, and the lender is free to accept that bargain. A clause giving the lender every collection above its debt strips the debtor’s equity before any default occurs, which is why the surplus duty is protected.
A large deficiency also invites the question whether the secured party handled the collateral reasonably. For a disposition, the commentary says a low price is not itself sufficient to establish a violation of Part 6, but it signals that a court should scrutinize carefully all aspects of the disposition to ensure that each was commercially reasonable.28
An exam stem in which a bank collects more than it is owed invites the answer that the bank must pay the excess to the dealer, and a stem about a shortfall invites the answer that the dealer owes the difference. Each answer is right only for a secured loan, so the first task is to read the stem for the form of the deal: a note with a security agreement, or a fixed-price purchase with no right to hand items back. In a loan the surplus is whatever remains after the whole ladder, so a junior holder that demanded in time is paid before the debtor sees anything.