Concept
Effect on Other Interests
Including secured party’s collection rights (§ 9-607)
Effect on Other Interests
Collection turns the debtor's rights to payment into money, and that money has more than one claimant. Section 9-607(a)(2) lets a collecting secured party take any proceeds to which it is entitled under Section 9-315, and the phrase entitled under carries the weight: the collecting party's right to the money depends on who else holds an interest in the same collateral.1 The debtor may have granted security interests in the same accounts to several lenders. The debtor owns whatever value remains above the secured debt. The debtor may also want the collateral back before anyone converts it to cash. Collection can preserve or cut off each of these claims.
The earlier subsections followed the money from the collecting party's side: what it may deduct, whom it must pay and in what order, and who receives a surplus or answers for a deficiency. This section looks at the people standing around that process. Other lienholders come first. A lien that ranks ahead of the interest being enforced keeps its priority through the enforcement,2 and the senior holder's interest attaches to the proceeds the collection produces.3 Whether the senior holder or the collecting party finally keeps that money turns on the priority rules for proceeds, not on the collection provisions.4 The debtor and others who may redeem come second. A redemption right lasts only while collateral remains to be recovered, and collection ends it.
Senior and Junior Liens
A junior lender that collects from an account debtor does not rise above a senior lender. The collecting party acts under § 9-607(a), which lets it notify an account debtor to pay it and take any proceeds to which it is entitled under § 9-315.5 Those powers realize the collecting party's own lien, and they give it no authority to rearrange the other liens on the same accounts. The priority of a lien senior to the one being enforced is therefore unaffected by the enforcement, and the senior holder's interest attaches to the proceeds of the collection.6 Priority would mean little otherwise, because a senior lender lends in reliance on its rank. The point is easy to lose when the collector is junior, since the junior lender is the one holding the money. Holding money says nothing about entitlement to it, and a collection raises two separate questions: what happens to the account debtor, and what happens to the competing lenders.
The collection does change the account itself. When an account debtor pays a secured party that has notified it, the account debtor is discharged on its obligation to the debtor, and the discharge extinguishes the account.7 A second secured party who later tried to collect the same account from the same payor would meet a defense, because the payor has already paid what it owed.8 The discharge protects a stranger to the financing who owes a single obligation. It also tells the competing lenders where to look. With the account extinguished, no one remains for them to collect from, so their claims move to the money the collecting lender received.
Three lenders show each effect in order. SP-1 holds a first-priority security interest in A's accounts securing a $10,000 debt, SP-2 holds a second-priority interest securing $7,000, and SP-3 holds a third-priority interest securing $5,000.9 SP-2 notifies X, an account debtor on one of the accounts, to pay SP-2, and X pays.10 SP-2's enforcement leaves SP-1's first-priority interest in A's accounts where it was. X is discharged, so a later demand on X by SP-1 or SP-3 would meet a viable defense. SP-1 keeps its security interest in the proceeds of the collection, which attaches to the money SP-2 received as identifiable proceeds.11 Whether SP-2 may keep that money depends on whether SP-2 had first priority in the proceeds under the proceeds priority rules. Collecting first does not supply that priority, and without it SP-2 cannot keep the money against SP-1.12
Two questions run together in problems like this one, and they have different answers. X's discharge answers whether X still owes anyone, and X does not. The proceeds rules answer who is entitled to the money X paid, and they compare the lenders' priorities in the proceeds without regard to who collected. A student who reasons that X's discharge lets SP-2 keep the money has borrowed the first answer for the second question. One who reasons that SP-1's rank lets it demand payment again from X has made the opposite mistake. The two answers fit together through a limit on every secured party: it may proceed against both the original collateral and its proceeds, but it may have only one satisfaction.13 Once X's payment has extinguished the account, the proceeds are the only form in which SP-1's collateral survives, so SP-1's claim runs against the money SP-2 holds and no longer against X.
The proceeds rules and the order of application operate at different points. The order tells a collecting party how to distribute money it is entitled to hold: reasonable collection expenses first, its own secured obligation second, and subordinate holders third, but only those that made an authenticated demand before the distribution was complete.14 SP-3 ranks behind SP-2, so SP-3 shares in SP-2's collection only if it made such a demand, and then only from what remains after SP-2's expenses and its own $7,000 claim. A senior holder does not appear on that ladder, because its priority survives the enforcement and it claims through the proceeds instead. Direction therefore matters. When a junior lender collects, the senior holder reaches the money through its priority in the proceeds. When a senior lender collects, a junior holder reaches the money only through a demand.
A stem in which a second-priority lender collects from a customer invites two opposite errors. One says the junior lender collected, so it keeps the money. The other says the senior lender may now sue the customer for the account. Each skips a step. The customer's payment discharged the account, which closes the second route, and the senior lender's interest in the proceeds blocks the first conclusion. A sound answer names the proceeds priority rules and compares the lenders' ranks in the money, instead of stopping at the fact that the customer paid.
Debtor's Redemption Right
Section 9-623(a) lets a debtor, any secondary obligor, and any other secured party or lienholder redeem collateral after default.17 Redemption, a word the Code uses without defining, means freeing property from a lien and regaining absolute title by paying the amount the property secures.18 The right exists because a security interest is only a device for securing a debt. A lender who has been paid in full has no reason to hold the collateral, so default alone does not take away the chance to pay what is owed and keep the property. The previous subsection showed that one lender's collection leaves the other lienholders' priorities intact. Collection does something different to the person who wants the collateral back: it ends the right.
Each person on the statute's list has something to lose if the secured party enforces. The debtor owns whatever the collateral is worth above the debt. A secondary obligor, such as a guarantor who has promised to pay if the debtor does not, answers for any shortfall that a poor enforcement leaves behind. A junior lienholder risks its interest, because a secured party's disposition after default discharges subordinate security interests and liens.19 Paying off the claim that drives the enforcement lets each of them protect what it holds, and the statute lets each do so on the same terms.
To redeem, a person must tender fulfillment of all the obligations the collateral secures, plus the secured party's reasonable expenses and attorney's fees. If the secured party has accelerated the debt, the tender must cover the entire balance.20 A tender is an offer of full performance, and acceleration is the lender's declaration, made on default, that the whole unpaid balance is due now. Each part of the requirement protects the lender. The lien secures the entire debt, so a lender forced to release the collateral while part of the debt remained unpaid would lose the very security that default has already put at risk. A debtor who could redeem by paying only the missed installments would also force the lender to resume financing someone who has just shown that repayment is in doubt. The expenses and fees belong in the tender because the default caused the lender to incur them, and they are the same kind of charge that comes off first when collections are applied. A tender that omits them is short, and a short tender does not redeem.
Redemption may occur at any time before the secured party has collected collateral, such as accounts from account debtors, under § 9-607.21 Collection ends the right because of what the collection powers do. When a secured party notifies an account debtor and the account debtor pays, a right to payment becomes money applied to the debt, and when the secured party takes proceeds it is entitled to, the value has likewise moved into the lender's hands.22 The accounts the debtor would redeem have been paid, so nothing remains to hand back. The cut-off arrives when the secured party has actually collected, which is a later moment than the one at which the right to collect arises. A lender that holds collection rights but has collected nothing has not yet ended the debtor's chance to redeem. A disposition of the collateral or a contract to dispose of it also ends the right, as does acceptance of the collateral in full or partial satisfaction of the debt.23
A debtor or secondary obligor can give up the right in advance only within narrow limits. In a transaction other than one involving consumer goods, a waiver is effective only if made in an agreement entered into and authenticated after default, so a clause in the closing papers has no effect.24 The right is therefore intact on the day of default unless the debtor has made a fresh waiver after that date.
A stem that stresses a default and a stack of notification letters invites the conclusion that redemption is already lost. That conclusion is premature until the stem reports that an account debtor has paid. A stem that reports payments and the application of the money to the loan supplies the cut-off, and the useful question then becomes who receives any surplus and who answers for any deficiency. Ask first whether anyone has actually paid the lender.