Concept
Warranties in Dispositions
Including secured party’s right to take possession and dispose of collateral (§§ 9-608 through 9-624)
Warranties in Dispositions
A buyer at a secured party's sale receives more than the collateral. Under Section 9-610(d), a contract for sale, lease, license, or other disposition includes the warranties relating to title, possession, quiet enjoyment, and the like that by operation of law accompany a voluntary disposition of property of the kind subject to the contract.1 Article 9 writes no warranty text of its own. It borrows the warranties that attach to an ordinary, voluntary transfer of the same kind of property and attaches them to the foreclosure transfer.
A sale is sometimes the only route open to the secured party. Disposition is required in certain consumer-goods situations, and it is required when there is no consent, or an objection, to a proposal to accept the goods in satisfaction of the debt.2 Whenever such a sale occurs, the warranties come with it unless the secured party disclaims them.
The warranties matter because of the setting in which foreclosure sales happen. Secured parties know that sales may need to be done quickly, usually in wholesale markets, and often in markets that are plainly inefficient, such as the courthouse steps.3 A bidder in that setting has little chance to investigate whether the debtor owned the goods or whether another creditor's lien will follow them. The proceeds go to the reasonable expenses of retaking, holding, preparing, processing, and disposing of the collateral4 and to satisfaction of the obligations the security interest secures.5 A bid discounted for title risk leaves less for both, so the warranties serve the debtor's interest in a good price as well as the buyer's interest in clean title.
The title warranty does its heaviest work on liens. A disposition discharges the security interest under which it is made, and it discharges any subordinate security interest or other subordinate lien.6 A senior lien is another matter, because senior liens always survive the sale.7 The implied warranty of good title therefore gives the purchaser rights against the secured party if the debtor did not have title. It also gives significant protection to a purchaser at a sale made by a junior secured party who fails to disclose the superior security interest.8
The warranties are the default, and silence does not remove them. The secured party escapes them only by acting, and subsection (e) offers two ways to act. The first is any manner that would be effective to disclaim or modify the warranties in a voluntary disposition of property of the kind subject to the contract of disposition.9 The second is to communicate to the purchaser a record evidencing the contract for disposition and including an express disclaimer or modification of the warranties.10 The second route demands a record that evidences the sale and reaches the purchaser, so a spoken disclaimer alone does not satisfy it.
The statute also supplies the wording. A record is sufficient to disclaim warranties under subsection (e) if it indicates "There is no warranty relating to title, possession, quiet enjoyment, or the like in this disposition" or uses words of similar import.11 A secured party that places that sentence, or a faithful paraphrase, in the record of the sale it hands the buyer has done what subsection (e) asks.
Buyers at foreclosure sales therefore need to read the paperwork. Disclaimers of this kind are very common, and a purchaser who accepts one must look into the title issues itself, paying particular attention to senior liens, which always survive the sale.12
The warranties named in subsection (d) concern title, possession, and quiet enjoyment, and the statutory disclaimer sentence uses the same words. Neither speaks to the condition of the goods. A buyer's complaint about quality therefore does not come from the title warranties, and the title disclaimer does not by its terms address it. Any quality claim must rest on whatever law attaches warranties to a voluntary disposition of that kind of property.
Price carries one further consequence when the buyer is the secured party, a person related to it, or a secondary obligor. If a sale to one of them brings proceeds significantly below the range that a sale complying with Article 9 to an outsider would have brought, the surplus or deficiency is calculated from what a compliant sale to an outsider would have brought. The debtor or obligor bears the burden of establishing that the proceeds were significantly below that range.13 The next section takes up the secured party as purchaser.