Concept
Retaining Collateral Instead
Including secured party’s right to take possession and dispose of collateral (§§ 9-608 through 9-624)
Retaining Collateral Instead
After repossession, a secured party can sell the collateral and apply the proceeds to the debt, or it can propose to keep the collateral in satisfaction of all or part of the debt.1 The second choice, called strict foreclosure, skips the auction: the creditor takes the goods, and the debt falls by the amount the debtor agrees to.2 Section 9-620 governs the procedure, and a secured party need not hold the collateral when it makes the proposal.3
Creditors often prefer retention. A debtor with few other assets may never pay a deficiency, so a sale and a suit would yield little. Retention also spares the creditor the cost of a formal notice and sale, and it avoids any challenge to the notice or the conduct of the sale.4 The creditor may resell afterward wherever and however it likes, so a creditor who expects a better price in several months can wait without facing the claim that its delay was unreasonable.5 The drafters wrote the section to encourage strict foreclosure, in the belief that it often produces better results for everyone concerned than a disposition does.6
A sale, by contrast, draws scrutiny of the price, even when the secured party is the buyer. Suppose the secured party, a person related to it, or a secondary obligor buys at the disposition, and the proceeds fall significantly below the range that an Article 9 sale to an outsider would have brought. The surplus or deficiency is then calculated at the amount the outsider sale would have produced.7 The debtor must prove that the proceeds fell significantly below that range.8 In a consumer-goods transaction, the secured party must also send the debtor and any consumer obligor a notice after the disposition explaining how it calculated the surplus or deficiency.9 Retention sets no price to attack. It rests on the debtor's consent, and the statute concentrates its safeguards there.
The creditor's convenience costs the debtor something. When the secured party keeps the goods in satisfaction of the debt and the debtor does not object, the secured party owes no accounting and has no right to a deficiency judgment.10 The debtor gives up any surplus and remains liable for a deficiency only after a partial retention.11 A debtor who owes $1,000 on goods worth $2,000 therefore fares better at a sale, while a debtor whose goods are worth less than the debt may welcome a full satisfaction that leaves nothing to collect.
The statute balances the creditor's advantage with three safeguards: the debtor must consent, other interested persons may object, and consumers receive further limits. When any safeguard holds, the secured party cannot retain and must dispose of the collateral instead.12 A secured party also cannot simply keep the goods without a sale and without taking the proper steps.13 The subsections below take the safeguards in that order.
Consent and Objection
A secured party may accept collateral in full or partial satisfaction only if the debtor consents and the secured party receives no notification of objection within the 20-day period that section 9-620(d) sets.14 The acceptance must also clear the consumer-goods rules, and it fails if the secured party must dispose of the collateral instead.15 The secured party contributes a step of its own: it must consent to the acceptance in an authenticated record or send the debtor a proposal.16 Holding the goods is not accepting them.
The debtor's consent turns on how much of the debt the acceptance cancels. For a partial satisfaction, the debtor consents only by agreeing to the terms in a record authenticated after default, and silence never counts.17 For a full satisfaction, the same record route stays open, and a second route appears. The secured party sends the debtor, after default, a proposal to accept the collateral in full satisfaction, and the proposal must be unconditional or conditioned only on preserving collateral that the secured party does not possess. If the debtor sends no authenticated objection that the secured party receives within 20 days after the proposal is sent, the debtor has consented.18 Any other condition, such as a demand that the debtor first pay the creditor's collection costs, removes the proposal from the silence route.19 The 2022 amendments substitute signing for authenticating without changing what the record must do.20
Silence works only for full satisfaction because only a full satisfaction ends the debt without leaving the debtor liable for more. A full retention leaves neither surplus nor deficiency, while a partial retention leaves the debtor liable for the unpaid balance.21 A creditor owed $10,000 could take collateral worth $10,000, credit only $1,000, resell the goods wherever and however it likes, and still hold the debtor for $9,000.22 A signed record that states the credit makes the debtor see that number before it binds. Consent also comes after default, because the debtor cannot waive the retention rules in the loan papers.23
The same silence produces opposite results because the first proposal would leave the contractor owing $9,000 after losing the machine, while the second wipes out the printer's whole debt.
The debtor is not the only person the acceptance affects, so the proposal must reach others too. The secured party must send it to the debtor and to the following persons:24
- any person that notified the secured party that it claims an interest in the collateral;
- any other secured party or lienholder that perfected by filing at least ten days before the debtor consented; and
- any secondary obligor, but only when the proposal is for partial satisfaction.
Secondary obligors enter only for a partial satisfaction because a full satisfaction ends the entire debt, while a partial satisfaction leaves a balance that a guarantor may have to pay.
Any of these parties can object, and a timely objection ends the retention: the secured party must sell or otherwise dispose of the collateral.25 Another interested person may object even after the debtor has consented, so the objection right does more than repeat the consent rule.26 The debtor's own objection defeats the deemed consent that silence would otherwise supply.27
The veto matters most to subordinate holders. A retention discharges the retaining creditor's interest and every subordinate interest and lien without paying anyone.28 Senior holders need no such veto, because a retention leaves their interests in place and the secured party must pay them to keep the collateral.29
Consumer Limits
When the collateral is consumer goods, section 9-620 stacks three limits on the general rules. One turns on where the goods are when the debtor consents, one on how much of the price the debtor has paid, and one on whether the creditor may keep the goods for less than the whole debt.31 Each limit protects the consumer's stake in the goods. A retention gives up any surplus, so a consumer whose goods are worth more than the debt loses the difference without a sale.32
The first limit concerns possession. For consumer goods, the debtor must not be in possession when the debtor consents or is deemed to have consented.33 Silence can supply consent to an unconditional full-satisfaction proposal after 20 days, so a secured party that wants silence to count must first get the goods out of the debtor's hands.34 It may use self-help if the debtor gives the goods up voluntarily. If the debtor objects, the secured party must bring a replevin action, and repossessing over the objection can expose it to liability for conversion.35 The UCC leaves breach of the peace undefined, and courts generally let a creditor recover the collateral unless the debtor objects or protests.36
The two companies sent identical proposals and received identical silence, and the location of the machine decided the outcome.
The second limit looks at what the debtor has paid. Once the debtor has paid 60 percent of the cash price in a purchase-money case, or 60 percent of the principal of the secured obligation, the secured party must sell the collateral within 90 days unless it and the debtor agree otherwise.37 The test turns on payments, not on a valuation of the goods. The debtor may waive the right to require disposition, but only by an authenticated agreement made after default.38 In the 60 percent case, the secured party may likewise obtain a waiver of its own duty to sell, but only after default.39 A clause in the original loan papers accomplishes nothing, because the debtor cannot waive the retention rules in advance.40
The percentage paid was the same in both cases, and the character of the collateral separates the results.
The third limit bars partial satisfaction. In a consumer transaction, the secured party may not accept collateral in partial satisfaction of the debt, so a retention must discharge the whole obligation.41 A partial retention leaves the debtor liable for the unpaid balance.42 Outside consumer deals, the statute asks for the debtor's signed agreement after default and lets a business debtor accept the balance it still owes.43 For a consumer it removes the option, so a signed agreement cannot rescue a partial acceptance. A full retention leaves no surplus or deficiency, so a consumer who loses the goods that way owes nothing more.44
All three limits attach to consumer goods, and a consumer transaction here means one whose collateral is consumer goods.45 A problem that reports a high percentage paid on business equipment therefore tests that classification and does not trigger a mandatory sale. A retention that clears all three limits must still follow sections 9-620 and 9-621: an agreement after default, the required notices, and no timely objection.46
Effect of Retention
An accepted retention does four things under section 9-622. It discharges the obligation to the extent the debtor consented, and it transfers to the secured party all of the debtor's rights in the collateral. It ends the security interest the secured party was enforcing, and it ends every subordinate security interest and lien.48 The secured party takes the collateral subject to any senior interest.49 A disposition does much the same: the transferee for value takes all of the debtor's rights, and the sale discharges the enforcing interest and the subordinate interests.50 The difference lies in the money. A sale yields cash proceeds that the secured party applies in a fixed order,51 while a retention yields no cash and shrinks the debt by an agreed credit.
The credit the debtor consented to sets the size of the discharge.52 No sale reveals what the goods would have brought, so the debtor's agreement fixes the credit. A full retention discharges the entire debt, and the secured party owes no accounting and cannot seek a deficiency judgment.53 A partial retention reduces the debt by the agreed credit and leaves the debtor liable for the deficiency.54
The secured party steps into the debtor's place as owner, and its own security interest ends because it no longer needs a lien on goods it owns.55 Any balance left by a partial retention remains a debt of the obligor, though the retained goods no longer secure it. Subordinate holders lose their liens without payment. A retention produces no proceeds to share, so their protection arrives earlier, in the right to receive the proposal and to object.56
Senior interests survive. An acceptance does not terminate a prior, senior security interest, and a secured party that wants the collateral free of it must pay the senior holder.57
Each of these effects depends on an acceptance that actually occurred. The debtor must have consented, and the secured party must have consented in an authenticated record or sent a proposal.58 Without both, the secured party has accepted nothing, and none of these results follows.