Concept
Right to Redeem
Including secured party’s right to take possession and dispose of collateral (§§ 9-608 through 9-624)
Right to Redeem
A secured party holds collateral only to secure repayment of a debt, so a person who pays that debt before foreclosure is complete can cut off the secured party's interest and take the collateral back.1 That is the right to redeem. Section 9-623(a) gives it to a debtor, any secondary obligor, and any other secured party or lienholder,2 and the price is fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral, together with certain expenses.3 Redemption does not depend on any misstep by the secured party, so it works differently from an attack on a defective sale. It depends on three things only: who the redeemer is, what the redeemer pays, and when the payment arrives.
The deadline follows from what a completed disposition does. A sale after default transfers to a buyer for value all of the debtor's rights in the collateral, discharges the security interest under which the sale is made, and discharges any subordinate security interest or lien.4 After those effects occur, no encumbered collateral is left for anyone to take back, and a buyer who paid for the debtor's rights could not count on the purchase if a stakeholder could unwind it later. Before that point, redemption lets the people with something to lose protect it. A debtor keeps whatever equity the goods hold, and a junior secured party or lienholder, whose interest a sale would wipe out, preserves it by paying what stands ahead of it.
Redemption also ties into the notification duty discussed earlier. A secured party that disposes of collateral must send the specified persons a reasonable authenticated notification of disposition,5 and in a consumer-goods transaction that notification must include a telephone number from which the amount needed to redeem is available.6 The amount is large, because redemption requires the full amount due plus the secured party's expenses and any agreed attorney's fees, and for that reason the right is seldom exercised.7 It still marks the point up to which every foreclosure can be reversed by payment. The three subsections below take up who may redeem, what must be tendered, and when the right ends.
Who May Redeem
Section 9-623(a) lists the persons who may redeem in this order: a debtor, any secondary obligor, and any other secured party or lienholder.8 To redeem is to free the collateral from the lien and regain absolute title by paying the amount due.9 Each group loses something different in a sale, and that loss is why each group is on the list.
The debtor holds the equity in the goods. A disposition passes the debtor's rights in the collateral to the buyer, and the cash proceeds go first to the expenses of the sale and then to the secured debt,10 so the debtor keeps nothing of value unless the price exceeds what is owed. Redemption lets the debtor keep the goods by paying the debt, without depending on what bidders offer. The word debtor here reaches an owner of collateral who is not personally liable on the debt. A person who puts up goods to secure someone else's loan has the debtor's rights, including redemption, when the secured party knows the goods belong to that person.11
A secondary obligor is a surety or other person who answers for a debt that someone else owes.12 A sale that brings less than the debt leaves a shortfall, and the secondary obligor may be asked to cover it. Redemption lets that person pay the secured debt before the sale and end the exposure at its source, so the risk no longer turns on what a bidder pays.
Other secured parties and lienholders have the most direct reason to want the right. A disposition after default discharges the security interest under which it is made and every subordinate security interest or lien,13 so a junior holder that stands by sees its interest in the collateral extinguished, and redemption is how it prevents that result. The word lienholder is broad enough to include holders of involuntary liens on the property, whose interests arose without any bargain with the debtor.14 The statute draws no line by rank, and the text withholds the right from no one who holds a security interest or lien.15
When an exam stem has an outsider offer to pay off the loan and stop a sale, check the statutory list. Is the outsider a debtor, including an owner who pledged goods for another's debt, a secondary obligor, or a holder of a security interest or lien?
The two tenders offered the same money; what differed was whether the tenderer had a stake the foreclosure would take. A sale extinguishes the second-ranking lender's interest and leaves the supplier's claim exactly where it was, because that claim runs against the debtor and not against the press. The statute gives the right to the persons on its list, and the supplier is not among them.
What Must Be Tendered
Section 9-623(b) sets the price of redemption in two parts, and a person who wants to redeem must tender both: fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral,17 and the reasonable expenses and attorney's fees described in Section 9-615(a)(1).18 Who may redeem was the first question. The second is how much the redeemer must pay, and the answer is usually far more than the amount that triggered the default.
The first part is measured by the debt the collateral secures, not by the installments that happen to be overdue. The secured party's interest exists only to back repayment, so a person who pays the whole secured debt leaves that interest with nothing to secure.19 Redemption applies that idea in the middle of a foreclosure: whoever wants the goods back must pay the debt that justified holding them. The principle matters most when the agreement contains an acceleration clause, which makes the whole unpaid balance due on default instead of one installment at a time.20 Once the debt has been accelerated, the redeemer must pay all of it.21 The acceleration clause records the parties' agreement that the lender need not keep waiting on a debtor who has already defaulted. If redemption required only the arrears, a debtor could end the foreclosure while paying less than the lender is entitled to demand, and the lender would give up the collateral while still carrying the risk it accelerated to escape.
The two tenders differ in one respect, which is how much of the secured obligation each one covers. A tender that falls short of fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral is not a redemption, however much of the overdue amount it pays.22
Bringing a loan current is a different act from redeeming. A cure restores the original payment schedule so that the debtor keeps the collateral and keeps paying in installments, while redemption pays off the secured debt. Section 9-623 demands fulfillment of all secured obligations and says nothing about reinstating a schedule. Before acceleration, one commentary says the debtor can redeem, or cure, by paying past installments, additional interest or late fees, and the secured party's expenses to date.23 After acceleration, whether a consumer debtor may simply bring the debt current is a question for local consumer statutes and not for § 9-623.24 An answer that lets a debtor reinstate a schedule should therefore name a source outside the redemption provision.
The second part makes the redeemer reimburse what the secured party spent on enforcement. Section 9-615(a)(1) describes those items as the reasonable expenses of retaking, holding, preparing for disposition, processing, and disposing, plus reasonable attorney's fees and legal expenses to the extent the agreement provides for them and no law prohibits them.25 The same items come off the top of the sale proceeds, ahead of the secured debt,26 and redemption is the alternative to a sale, so the person who stops the sale by paying bears what the sale would have charged. Each qualifier does separate work. The word reasonable keeps padded charges out of the tender. The attorney's-fee condition has two parts, because the agreement must provide for fees and no law may prohibit them. A debtor whose agreement promises fees includes them in the tender, and a debtor whose agreement is silent tenders none, however much the lender paid its lawyer.
Because the tender includes expenses that accrue while the collateral sits, a redeemer cannot read the total off a payment book, which is why the consumer-goods notification must supply a telephone number from which the redemption amount is available.27 The size of the tender also explains why the right is seldom used, since the redeemer must pay the whole debt along with the lender's costs.28 The tender must also arrive in time, a limit taken up next.
When Redemption Ends
Section 9-623(c) fixes the time for redemption by naming the events that end it. The right lasts until the secured party has collected the collateral under § 9-607, has disposed of the collateral or entered into a contract for its disposition under § 9-610, or has accepted the collateral in full or partial satisfaction of the obligation under § 9-622.30 The right ends at the first of these events, and no other fact shortens or extends it. The earlier subsections asked who may redeem and what a tender must cover. This one asks whether a complete tender arrives in time, and the answer depends on the date of the secured party's earliest closing act.
Each event ends the right because each turns the collateral into something a payment can no longer recover. Redemption works by paying the secured debt so that the lien falls away and the goods come back free.31 Once the secured party has collected payment from the account debtors on accounts, chattel paper, general intangibles, or promissory notes, the receivable has been turned into money and nothing remains to be freed.32 Once the secured party has disposed of the collateral, the sale has transferred the debtor's rights to a buyer and discharged the enforcing security interest and every subordinate interest, so a redeemer would be asking to reclaim goods that someone else now owns.33 Acceptance in satisfaction discharges the obligation to the extent the debtor consented,34 which means the secured party has already taken the goods in place of payment.
The disposition cutoff deserves the most care, because the statute closes the window at the contract stage instead of waiting for the sale to be completed. A signed contract for disposition ends the right even though the goods have not been delivered and title has not passed.35 A buyer who has signed has committed to pay and has planned around receiving the goods. If a debtor could still redeem until delivery, a last-minute tender would pull the goods out from under that buyer and leave the secured party in breach of its own contract. Bidders who see that risk bid less or stay away, and because cash proceeds go first to the expenses of the sale and then to the secured debt,36 a lower price falls on the debtor as a larger deficiency or a smaller surplus. Cutting off redemption at the contract gives the buyer a commitment it can rely on, and that reliance supports a good price.
An advertisement, a scheduled auction, or a notification of disposition therefore leaves the window open, because none of them appears among the cutoff events.37 The notification goes to the persons the statute specifies, and sending it is not a closing act.38
The retention cutoff turns on acceptance and not on a proposal. A debtor consents to a proposal to accept collateral in satisfaction by agreeing to its terms in a record authenticated after default, or by failing to object within 20 days after the secured party sends the proposal, and silence is not consent to an acceptance in partial satisfaction.39 Until the acceptance has taken effect under those rules, the third cutoff event has not occurred, and a debtor who receives a proposal may redeem instead of consenting.40
Because the cutoff is an event and not a count of days, Article 9 gives no period after a foreclosure sale in which a debtor may still redeem. That choice departs from some real estate law and from pre-Code secured transactions law, which set a fixed period after foreclosure or sale.41 Take a debtor whose $20,000 computer loan went into default and whose computer was repossessed and, after proper notice and advertising, sold this morning at a private sale for $10,000.42 A tender this afternoon of everything owed comes too late, because the sale has already ended the right. Whatever remains for that debtor concerns the sale itself, such as whether every aspect of the disposition was commercially reasonable,43 and not redemption. An exam answer that imports a statutory redemption period from mortgage foreclosure into Article 9 has the wrong rule.
The right is also protected against private agreements. A debtor or obligor cannot vary it by agreement, and the one exception lets a debtor or secondary obligor, in a transaction other than a consumer-goods transaction, waive it in an agreement entered into and authenticated after default.44 The bar on advance waiver follows from the circumstances of signing. A borrower accepts the lender's form at closing, needs the money, and has no foreclosure in view, so if a waiver clause were effective it would appear in every form and the right would exist only on paper. Courts have long refused to let a mortgage clause clog the equity of redemption, and Article 9 carries the same suspicion forward, since the default situation offers great scope for overreaching.45 The exception covers only an agreement made after default, when the debtor can see the foreclosure it is bargaining over, and it never reaches a consumer-goods transaction.
A single waiver clause therefore produces three results depending on when and by whom it is signed. It is ineffective in the original loan papers, effective if a business borrower signs it after default in a transaction that is not a consumer-goods transaction, and ineffective even after default if the transaction is a consumer-goods transaction.