Concept
Real Property and Fixtures
Including secured party’s right to take possession and dispose of collateral (§§ 9-608 through 9-624)
Real Property and Fixtures
Foreclosing on land and disposing of goods under Article 9 run on different tracks, and a lender whose collateral touches both must decide which track to use. A mortgagor keeps possession of the real property until it is actually sold, and the statutes governing the sale usually impose detailed requirements that must be strictly followed.1 Article 9 gives the secured party far more room. A commercially reasonable disposition may be public or private, by one or more contracts, as a unit or in parcels, and at any time and place and on any terms.2
Because the two systems differ so sharply, Article 9 leaves the real estate side to real property law. It excludes a number of transactions from its coverage,3 among them the creation or transfer of an interest in or lien on real property, which takes in real estate mortgages and land sale contracts.4 Collateral that is personal property or fixtures stays inside Article 9, though, and where the two bodies of law meet, Article 9 supplies several provisions of its own on real-estate-related issues.5 Three of them are the subject of this unit: the choice a lender has when one agreement covers both land and goods, the rules for enforcing against fixtures and removing them, and the duty to repair what removal breaks. The fixture rules also turn on priority, which the treatise develops in its own sections on deposit accounts, investment property, and buyers of goods.6
Mixed Collateral
A lender financing a business often takes one security agreement covering both the land and the goods on it, such as a factory building and the machinery inside. When the debtor defaults, Section 9-604(a) lets the secured party choose between two routes.7
- It may proceed under Part 6 as to the personal property, without prejudicing any rights with respect to the real property.8
- It may proceed as to both the personal property and the real property in accordance with the rights with respect to the real property, in which case the other provisions of Part 6 do not apply.9
The first route keeps the two bodies of law apart. The secured party repossesses and sells the machinery under Part 6, and its rights against the land stay where they were.10 That language protects a one-loan lender against the risk that acting on the goods will cost it something on the land. The protection runs in one direction only. Whether enforcing against the real estate prejudices rights against the personal property is decided by the rules governing enforcement against real estate, so a lender that starts with the land should check those rules before assuming Part 6 remains open for the machinery.11
Nothing in the first route relaxes Part 6 for the machinery itself. Every aspect of the sale must be commercially reasonable, although the debtor and obligor may agree to standards for measuring reasonableness so long as those standards are not manifestly unreasonable.12 The secured party must also send a reasonable authenticated notification of disposition to the specified persons.13 Machinery is not consumer goods, so those persons include not only the debtor and secondary obligors but also anyone who has told the secured party of a claim in the goods and any other secured party that filed a financing statement at least ten days before the notice is sent.14 The cash proceeds then go first to the reasonable expenses of retaking, holding, preparing for disposition, processing, and disposing, plus reasonable attorney's fees and legal expenses to the extent the agreement provides and law does not prohibit,15 and next to satisfying the obligation secured by the security interest under which the sale was made.16 Because one debt stands behind both kinds of collateral, whatever the sale pays down is no longer owed when the lender turns to the land.
The second route commits both kinds of collateral to real property law, and the price is the loss of the Part 6 provisions developed in the earlier sections.17 The duty to send a notification, the requirement that every aspect of the sale be commercially reasonable, the order for applying proceeds, and the right of a debtor, secondary obligor, or other secured party or lienholder to redeem all live in Part 6, so none of them governs an enforcement carried out under real property rights.18 What replaces them is foreclosure law. In most states the debtor can redeem after the sale, sometimes for as long as a year, and that extended period often keeps the mortgage holder from getting a fair price. Some states bar deficiency judgments on farmland or residential property, and California and Arizona bar them after foreclosure on residential real estate. Purchasers at foreclosure sales get little protection beyond the return of their money after an improper sale or redemption.19 A lender that elects this route gets one proceeding over one default, but it must follow the real property statute to the letter and accept a regime built on different terms.
Bar-exam stems on this section tend to report that a lender sold land and equipment together, or equipment alone, and then ask whether a missing Article 9 notification matters.
The two lenders held the same agreement and made the same omission, yet the results were opposite. The fact that decides is whether the lender proceeded as to both kinds of property under the real property rights, because the Part 6 exemption attaches only to that election.20
Which route to take depends on where the value sits and on what each regime demands. When most of the value is in the land and the goods are modest or tied to the building, one real property proceeding avoids splitting a single default into two enforcement actions. When the machinery is valuable in its own right, the first route lets the lender sell it with Article 9's latitude over method, time, and place while keeping its claim on the land intact.21 Either way, the lender should choose deliberately, because the route decides which duties follow.
Fixtures and Removal
Goods that are or become fixtures sit where personal property law and real property law meet, and Section 9-604(b) lets the secured party choose which body of law will enforce its interest. It may proceed under Part 6, or it may proceed in accordance with the rights with respect to real property, in which case the other provisions of Part 6 do not apply.23 The structure matches the mixed-collateral choice, and for the same reason. The debtor's default engages two enforcement systems at once, and the secured party picks the one that suits the asset.
The Part 6 route carries the package developed in the earlier sections: the rules on possession, a disposition in which every aspect is commercially reasonable, a reasonable authenticated notification, and application of the proceeds in the statutory order.24 The real property route replaces that package with the foreclosure law governing liens on land. Electing it switches off the other Part 6 provisions, so the notification, commercial-reasonableness, and application rules taught above do not govern the enforcement.25
Subsection (c) adds a removal remedy and attaches conditions to it. Subject to the other provisions of Part 6, a secured party holding a security interest in fixtures that has priority over all owners and encumbrancers of the real property may, after default, remove the collateral from the real property.26 Three requirements sit inside that sentence. A default must have occurred, the secured party must outrank every owner and encumbrancer, and the removal must stay within the rest of Part 6.27 The last requirement carries the earlier Part 6 rules into the removal itself. The first means that a lender merely uneasy about the debtor's finances cannot pull a furnace out of the wall.
The priority condition follows from what removal does. Taking a fixture out of the real estate subtracts something from the land, so the rule asks whose claim to that something ranks first. A mortgagee that lent against the building may have counted the fixture as part of its security, and an owner of the land other than the debtor holds an interest in the property of which the fixture is part. Requiring priority over every such claimant confines the secured party to taking what it was already entitled to take.28 The ranking contest is not decided here. For ordinary equipment, non-purchase-money security interests rank by time of filing or perfection, and purchase-money status changes the analysis,29 while fixture priority has its own rules, which are reviewed elsewhere in the treatise.30 The treatise's priority sections, including those on buyers of goods, supply the contest rules in full.31
The word all in the statute is what defeated the second supplier. Outranking the landlord is not enough when a mortgagee ranks higher, because removal requires priority over every owner and encumbrancer. A stem that reports a plain default and an attached piece of equipment is therefore asking a ranking question, and the answer depends on the fixture priority analysis, not on how clearly the debtor defaulted. The removal right also carries a duty with it. A secured party that removes a fixture must repair certain physical injury to the real property, which the next subsection takes up.
Reimbursing Removal Damage
Section 9-604(d) attaches a price to the removal right. A secured party that removes collateral must promptly reimburse any encumbrancer or owner of the real property, other than the debtor, for the cost of repairing any physical injury caused by the removal. It need not reimburse that person for any diminution in value of the real property caused by the absence of the goods removed or by any necessity of replacing them.33 The question that decides every case under the subsection is whether the loss is damage to the structure or merely the absence of the fixture. A secured party with priority in a furnace may take it out of the building on default. The mortgagee is then owed the cost of fixing whatever the removal physically broke and is owed nothing for the lower value of a building without a furnace.34
The two halves of the rule rest on different reasons. Priority entitles the secured party to the fixture and to nothing else. The wall, the pipes, and the floor belong to the owner and are part of what the encumbrancer lent against, so damage to them is harm outside what the secured party was entitled to take. Without the repair duty, a secured party could pull the fixture out by the cheapest route and leave the bill with people who played no part in the default, and the word promptly keeps those people from carrying the cost in the meantime. The diminution limit works the other way. The value a fixture adds to a building is value that the secured party's superior interest reaches ahead of every owner and encumbrancer, so a lower building value after removal is simply the result of the secured party taking what it was entitled to take. The subsection pays for what the secured party broke and leaves unpaid what it only took.
Those owed reimbursement are the encumbrancers and owners of the real property other than the debtor. A mortgagee of the building and a landlord who owns it are covered, and the debtor is not, even when the debtor owns the building.35 A person who has otherwise agreed is also outside the protection.36 The debtor's exclusion follows from its position. The debtor granted the security interest and then defaulted, and the secured party is enforcing the rights the debtor gave it, so the debtor cannot claim under this subsection to be made whole for the consequences. Outsiders stand differently, because they did not default and the building they own or lent against is what the removal physically touches.
The last sentence of subsection (d) lets a person owed reimbursement protect that right before the removal happens. That person may refuse permission to remove until the secured party gives adequate assurance of performing the reimbursement obligation, which in effect lets the owner or encumbrancer demand security as the price of allowing the removal.37 A duty to pay after the fact is only as good as the secured party's willingness and ability to pay, and once the fixture is gone and the wall is open, the owner is a creditor holding a repair bill. The assurance right moves the owner's bargaining position to the moment before removal, when the secured party still needs permission.
The repair bill and the appraisal drop in that scene come from one removal, and the subsection pays the first and not the second. A stem reporting an owner's demand for the value lost once a fixture leaves is testing diminution, and the answer is no reimbursement. A stem reporting a gouged wall is testing physical injury, and the answer is yes, with the debtor excluded and the assurance right available to everyone else who is owed.