Concept
Tender Requirements
Right to redeem collateral
Tender Requirements
Redemption has a price, and § 9-623(b) names it: to redeem collateral, a person shall tender, and the subsection then lists what the tender must contain.1 The list has two items. The first is fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral; the second is the reasonable expenses and attorney's fees described in § 9-615(a)(1).2 The last section showed who may redeem. This one shows what that person must do, and the verb matters: a redeemer must actually offer the secured party both items, and an offer that omits either one does not redeem.
Redemption is the right to free the collateral from any lien or encumbrance and regain absolute title by payment of the amount due.3 The secured party gives up something real in exchange. After default it may dispose of the collateral by sale or lease under § 9-610(a),4 and a redeemer who tenders in time stops that sale.5 The two tender items match what the secured party loses by forgoing it: payment of the debt the collateral secures, and reimbursement of the enforcement costs it has already spent. A redemption on lesser terms would shift part of the cost of the default onto the secured party.
Most redemption disputes turn on the first item, because the debt to be tendered is the whole secured obligation and not merely the overdue part. The next subsection takes up that item, the one after it adds acceleration, and the last covers expenses and fees.
All Secured Obligations
Section 9-623(b)(1) sets the first component of the tender: “fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral.”6 The word that controls is all. What the collateral secures sets the measure. The amount in default does not, and neither does the total the debtor owes the secured party. A tender that pays some secured obligations and leaves others open fails the condition, so redemption requires full payment of what the collateral secures, and a partial payment does not redeem.7
The reason follows from what redemption does. It frees the collateral from the lien by payment of the amount due,8 and a lien that stands behind several debts is satisfied only when all of them are paid. If a debtor could reclaim collateral by paying one overdue note, the secured party would give up the asset behind the remaining debt just when the debtor had shown trouble paying, and a secured claim would become unsecured. The limit also runs the other way. A debt that the security agreement does not tie to this collateral is not an obligation the collateral secures, so it stays out of the tender.
The security agreement answers which obligations the collateral secures, because it defines the debts for which the security interest was granted. One security interest can stand behind several obligations, and one of them can be current while another is in default. A redeemer who asks only what is overdue will usually tender too little. The analysis begins with a list and ends with the arithmetic.
The $4,000 tender fails because of the word all. The fleet secures both notes, and the current note remains a secured obligation even though no payment on it is overdue. A short tender does not by itself end the right to redeem, because that right runs until a cutoff taught below.9 But the lender offered only part of what the fleet secures may decline the offer and proceed to sell.
Every person who redeems measures the tender the same way. A debtor, secondary obligor, other secured party, or lienholder redeems by tendering fulfillment of all obligations the collateral secures,10 so a guarantor or another lienholder who wants to stop the sale must pay everything the lien secures.
Students usually err in one of two directions. The first error measures the tender by the default and treats the missed payments as the price of getting the collateral back. The second adds every debt the debtor owes the secured party, including debts that the security agreement does not tie to this collateral. Asking first which obligations the collateral secures corrects both. How the answer changes when the agreement accelerates the balance is the subject of the next subsection.
Effect of Acceleration
An acceleration clause makes the entire unpaid balance due in one installment when the debtor defaults. When the agreement contains one, the redeemer must tender the entire balance and not just the missed payments, which is the rule of Official Comment 2 to § 9-623.12 The result follows from § 9-623(b)(1). Once the clause operates, the whole balance is an obligation the collateral secures, and the redeemer must fulfill all such obligations.13 A debtor who catches up on the overdue installments pays only the part of the debt that fell due before acceleration, and the rest of the secured obligation stays open.
The reason lies in what the secured party bargained for. It agreed to take payment over time, and the acceleration clause lets it end that arrangement on default and claim the whole debt at once. A redeemer who tenders only the arrears asks the secured party to abandon the sale and resume an installment plan that the default allowed it to end, while the secured party bears the risk of a second default. Tendering the accelerated balance gives the secured party what the clause promised: the whole debt at once. The collateral is then freed by payment of the amount due.14
The usual fact pattern is a debtor who has missed a few payments and demands the collateral back after repossession. Two facts decide the case: whether the agreement accelerates the balance on default, and what the debtor actually offered.
The rejected check did not cost the buyer the right to redeem. That right runs until the secured party collects the obligation, disposes of the collateral, or retains it in satisfaction,15 and the lender had done none of those things. What the first offer lacked was a proper tender. The same total binds every redeemer, because the amount depends on what the senior lien secures and not on who is paying. On exam facts, confirm that the agreement contains an acceleration clause and that the default has triggered it before measuring the tender by the whole balance.
One qualification keeps this rule from being overread. Local consumer statutes may allow a consumer debtor simply to bring the outstanding debt current,16 so a consumer who offers only the arrears may be able to keep the collateral under the statute. That result comes from the consumer statute and not from § 9-623. Reinstatement revives the installment plan, while redemption pays the whole secured debt and ends the lien. When a stem says that a family bought a car for personal use and that state law lets debtors bring an account current, the analysis has two parts: the arrears-only offer is not a redemption under the Code, and whether the consumer may keep the car anyway depends on the terms of the statute.
Expenses and Attorney's Fees
The second item in the tender comes from § 9-623(b)(2), which requires “the reasonable expenses and attorney's fees described in Section 9-615(a)(1).”18 The redeemer tenders this item together with the secured obligations and not in place of them. Paying the whole debt, even a whole accelerated balance, satisfies only the first item. Two limits come with the cross-reference. Expenses must be reasonable. Attorney's fees and legal expenses count only if the security agreement provides for them and law does not prohibit them, and then only in a reasonable amount.19
The tender includes these charges because a default costs the secured party money before any redemption is offered. To retake collateral, a secured party may pay for a tow and a storage lot, and it may hire a lawyer to manage the process. A redeemer who paid only the debt would leave the secured party to absorb the cost of the default. Adding the charges to the tender puts the secured party where payment in full would have put it.
The limits exist because the redeemer pays a bill it had no hand in writing. The secured party chooses the tow company, the storage lot, and the lawyer, and the person who wants to stop the sale sees the invoice only after the money is spent. If the secured party could bill without limit, it could set the price of redemption by padding the expense line. The reasonableness limit therefore applies to every charge in the tender, so a storage bill far above the going rate counts only up to a reasonable figure.
The second limit applies to attorney's fees and legal expenses. A lawyer's bill is a cost the secured party chose to incur, and it passes to the redeemer only if the security agreement provides for it and no law prohibits it. The two conditions work separately. An agreement with no fee clause gives the secured party no basis for adding fees to the tender, however large the lawyer's bill, and a fee clause cannot make collectible a charge that a statute forbids. Both conditions sit on top of reasonableness, so even a valid clause entitles the secured party only to a reasonable amount. Ordinary enforcement expenses such as towing and storage need only be reasonable, because the agreement-and-law condition attaches to the legal charges.
When a payoff demand arrives with a legal bill attached, the first question is whether the security agreement provides for fees at all.
A second lender shows the rule operating when the agreement does supply a basis.
Reasonableness cuts in both directions. A redeemer who tenders the reasonable amount has met § 9-623(b)(2) even though the secured party's invoice is higher. A redeemer who shades the figure below what is reasonable has tendered short and has not redeemed, so a dispute over a single charge is also a dispute over whether the tender was complete.
The usual exam error is to stop at the debt. A stem that says the debtor tendered the entire accelerated balance has not yet said the redemption is complete, because towing, storage, and any authorized fees may still be missing. The opposite error treats the lawyer's bill as automatic. The sound order of analysis is to confirm that the security agreement provides for fees and that no law prohibits them, and only then to test the amount for reasonableness.