Concept
When Redemption Ends
Right to redeem collateral
When Redemption Ends
The right to redeem has no expiration date. Section 9-623(c) lets a person redeem “at any time before” the secured party takes one of three steps.1 Those steps are collecting the collateral, disposing of it or contracting to dispose of it, and accepting it in full or partial satisfaction of the debt. Each is an act of the secured party, so the cutoff depends on what the secured party has done and not on how much time has passed.
The Code departs from some real estate law and pre-Code secured transactions law by setting no fixed period after foreclosure or sale in which redemption is permitted.2 A redeemer therefore cannot ask how many days remain. The question is whether the secured party has taken any of the three steps, and which one came first. On an exam stem that supplies a timeline of repossession, notices, and a sale, find the earliest of those steps and compare the debtor's tender against it.
Each step moves the collateral beyond the reach of a simple payoff. Collection turns a right to payment into cash applied to the debt, a disposition or a contract for one commits the collateral to a buyer, and acceptance makes the secured party its owner. Until one of those happens, the collateral is still in the secured party's hands in its original form, and a redemption costs the secured party nothing, because the redeemer must tender all secured obligations plus expenses.3 The three cutoffs follow in the order the statute lists them.
Before Collection
The first cutoff arrives when the secured party “has collected collateral under Section 9-607.”4 Collection is the remedy for collateral that consists of money owed to the debtor, and the standard illustration is accounts. The debtor’s customers, called account debtors, owe it money, and after default the secured party may direct them to pay the secured party instead.
The operative word is “collected.” A letter telling customers to pay the secured party is a step toward collection and is not collection itself. Until a customer actually pays, the secured party holds only the debtor’s right to be paid, and a redemption still costs it nothing, because the tender gives it the full secured debt plus expenses. Once customers have paid and the secured party has applied the money to the debt, the right to payment has become cash already used against the obligation. A debtor who then offers to redeem is asking for collateral that no longer exists in its original form.
The two scenes share a security interest, a default, and notices to customers. They differ only in whether money was collected, and the statute’s wording, “has collected,” makes that the deciding fact. A stem that says only that the secured party notified account debtors has not yet shown that the right to redeem ended. The cutoff also fits only collateral that someone can pay over. Repossessed equipment or inventory is not collected from anyone, so for goods the deadline comes from the disposition and acceptance cutoffs that follow.
Before Disposition
The second cutoff arrives when the secured party “has disposed of collateral or entered into a contract for its disposition under Section 9-610.”6 A disposition under § 9-610 includes a sale or a lease after default.7 The text names two events, and either one ends the right: the completed disposition, in which the secured party transfers the collateral to a buyer, and a contract to make that transfer. A contract is signed before the goods change hands, so in a typical sale the contract is the event that closes the right.
The contract is the cutoff, and the closing and delivery are not. A secured party and a buyer who have made a binding agreement for the sale have entered into a contract for disposition, whatever remains to be done. Payment, delivery, and transfer of title usually follow days or weeks later, and none of them appears in the statute as a cutoff event. A debtor cannot argue that the right survived because the goods were still in the secured party’s yard or because the buyer’s money had not yet arrived.
Brandt’s tender arrived two days before the closing and still failed, because a full payment offered after the right has ended does not redeem. An exam stem often supplies the contract date, the closing date, the delivery date, and the date of the debtor’s tender. Only the contract date matters. Compare the tender with it and ignore the rest.
The line sits at the contract for a practical reason. A buyer who signs expects to receive the collateral, and a right to redeem during the weeks between signing and closing would leave the secured party promising goods it might have to return. Before the contract, redemption costs the secured party nothing, since it receives the full secured debt and its expenses. After the contract, redemption would collide with a commitment to a third party.
Because the right ends at the contract, the Code gives the debtor no grace period after the sale. A debtor whose collateral has been sold cannot redeem within some number of days afterward, which departs from some real estate foreclosure law and pre-Code practice.8 The date to locate is the date the contract was made.
A scene from the other side of the line shows how much the cutoff leaves open.
Repossessing the collateral, giving notice of a sale, advertising it, and fixing a date for it are all steps toward a disposition, and none of them is a disposition or a contract for one. Until the secured party is bound to a buyer, a timely tender redeems and the planned sale cannot proceed. Timing is only one of two requirements, though. The tender must also fulfill all obligations secured by the collateral and cover the reasonable expenses and fees, so an early offer of too little fails on amount, and a full offer made after the contract fails on timing.9
Before Acceptance in Satisfaction
The third cutoff closes the right to redeem once the secured party “has accepted collateral in full or partial satisfaction of the obligation it secures under Section 9-622.”11 This is the alternative to selling: the secured party keeps the collateral and treats its value as payment of the debt, the remedy known as strict foreclosure.12 Collection and disposition turn the collateral into cash or into a buyer’s property. Acceptance turns it into the secured party’s own property, and the statute marks that moment by the secured party’s act of accepting.
Acceptance ends redemption because of what it does to the debt and to the debtor’s interest in the collateral. It discharges the obligation to the extent the debtor consented, transfers all of the debtor’s rights in the collateral to the secured party, discharges subordinate security interests, and terminates other subordinate interests.13 Two of those effects defeat a later redemption directly. Redemption requires a tender of fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral,14 and when acceptance has discharged the debt in full, no secured obligation remains to be fulfilled. The debtor’s rights in the collateral also already belong to the secured party, so a payment has nothing left to restore. The right must therefore be exercised before the obligation is discharged under § 9-622 by the secured party’s retention of the collateral.15 The same logic reaches other secured parties and lienholders, who may redeem under § 9-623 but whose interests acceptance terminates, so they too must act before it.
A proposal to retain the collateral is a different and earlier event than acceptance. Retention depends on the debtor’s consent, and when the debtor does not consent, or objects to the proposal, disposition is required instead.16 A proposal alone discharges no debt and moves no rights. A cutoff set at the proposal would let a secured party end redemption by mailing a letter, before the debtor had a chance to consent or object. Setting the cutoff at acceptance keeps the right open while the debtor decides how to respond.
The exam version of this issue begins with a lender’s letter and asks whether the right to redeem has already ended. The answer turns on whether acceptance has occurred, and the next two scenes separate the cases, beginning with the one in which it has.
Okonkwo’s tender fails because acceptance had already done its work and the money had nothing left to buy. The same cutoff applies to a partial acceptance. When a lender keeps the collateral in partial satisfaction, some debt may survive, yet the debtor’s rights in the collateral have still passed to the lender, so the surviving balance does not reopen the right to redeem.17
Teller’s tender succeeds because the proposal changed nothing about the debt or the lien. The two scenes share a default, a repossession, and a full tender with expenses, and they differ only in whether the lender had accepted the collateral when the money arrived. Timing is only half of redemption, since the amount must still meet § 9-623(b). Suppose Teller had offered only the missed payments on a loan the lender had accelerated. The right would still have been open, but the redemption would fail on amount, because an acceleration clause makes the entire balance the sum to be tendered.18
The usual exam error runs in both directions. A student who treats the lender’s proposal as the end of the right cuts the period short, and a student who lets a debtor redeem after acceptance because the goods are still in the lender’s yard, or because part of the debt survives, extends it past the statute’s line. The date to find is the date the lender accepted the collateral. Taken together, the three cutoffs keep the right open until the secured party collects the collateral, contracts to dispose of it, or accepts it, whichever comes first. The right is not beyond bargaining, either: an agreement entered into and authenticated after default can waive it, except in consumer transactions, a topic taken up next.19