Concept
Why Noncompliance Needs a Remedy
Remedies for secured party's noncompliance
Remedies for Noncompliance
Why Noncompliance Needs a Remedy
After default, Article 9 gives a secured party wide freedom to enforce. It may dispose of collateral by public or private proceedings, by one or more contracts, as a unit or in parcels, and at any time and place and on any terms.1 One condition limits that freedom: every aspect of the disposition, including its method, manner, time, place, and other terms, must be commercially reasonable, and the debtor cannot waive that duty by agreement.2 Freedom of that breadth invites abuse. An older Code comment observed that the default situation offers great scope for overreaching.3 A duty with no consequence is only advice, and § 9-625 supplies the consequences.4
Every remedy in § 9-625 rests on the same premise: the secured party failed to comply with Article 9. A court may order or restrain collection, enforcement, or disposition of collateral only if it is established that the secured party is not proceeding in accordance with the article.5 A debtor who dislikes the result of an enforcement that followed the rules therefore has nothing to enforce under this section.
The remedies run from preventive relief to compensatory damages to a statutory floor. At the preventive end, a court may order or restrain collection, enforcement, or disposition of collateral on appropriate terms and conditions, so it can step in before the harm is complete.6 After the harm occurs, a person who failed to comply is liable for the loss the failure caused. That loss may include the debtor's inability to obtain alternative financing, or the higher cost of financing it did obtain.7 Subsections (c), (d), and (f) qualify that liability, and the units that follow take them up. Where the collateral is consumer goods, a person who was a debtor or secondary obligor when the secured party failed to comply with Part 6 may recover in any event at least the credit service charge plus 10 percent of the principal amount of the obligation, or the time-price differential plus 10 percent of the cash price.8 That floor protects a consumer whose actual loss is hard to prove.
The remedies would mean little if the security agreement could waive them. A secured party could write its own immunity into the form, and the duties the remedies enforce would lose their sanction. Article 9 closes that gap. Rights under §§ 9-625 and 9-626, which deal with the secured party's liability for failure to comply with the article, appear on the list of rights that cannot be waived.9 The policy has deep roots. Courts have long viewed with suspicion agreements designed to cut down the debtor's rights and free the secured party of its duties. No mortgage clause was ever allowed to clog the equity of redemption, and that suspicion was grounded in common sense. The 1999 Code has no comment saying so, but the same sentiment underlies its non-waiver provisions.10