Concept
Consumer-Goods Minimum Recovery
Remedies for secured party's noncompliance
Consumer-Goods Minimum Recovery
A consumer whose repossession was botched often cannot show that the botching cost anything. A secured party usually wants the highest price the collateral will bring, because it has no assurance that a debtor already in default can pay a deficiency judgment. Many Part 6 failures also barely touch the price: a missing notice causes no actual loss if the debtor would not have acted on it, say by drumming up bidders.1 Under the loss-based rule of § 9-625(b), that consumer would recover little or nothing. Section 9-625(c)(2) closes the gap with a fixed floor.
If the collateral is consumer goods, a person that was a debtor or a secondary obligor at the time the secured party failed to comply with Part 6 may recover for that failure in any event an amount not less than the credit service charge plus 10 percent of the principal amount of the obligation, or the time-price differential plus 10 percent of the cash price.2 The nature of the collateral triggers the rule. Once it applies, the formula sum is the least the claimant can recover, and the words "in any event" mean the claimant receives it whether or not the claimant can show what the defective repossession or sale cost. The text sets a minimum, so it does not cap recovery at the formula sum. In Coxall v. Clover Commercial Corp. the court described the minimum as a device designed to ensure that every noncompliance in a consumer-goods transaction results in liability.3
The formula offers two alternatives, and the terms of the transaction decide which one fits. One pairs the credit service charge with a tenth of the principal amount of the obligation. The other pairs the time-price differential with a tenth of the cash price. Both have the same shape, the cost of the credit plus a tenth of the size of the deal, so the sum rises and falls with the transaction it comes from. Section 9-625 does not define the formula's terms. The official comment leaves their construction and application to the court, taking into account the purpose of providing a minimum recovery.4
Coxall supplies a worked calculation. Clover Commercial repossessed Mr. Coxall's vehicle and failed both the requirement of reasonable notification and the requirement of a commercially reasonable disposition.5 His contract showed a time-price differential of $1,036.24, and 10 percent of the cash price was $810. The statutory recovery was therefore $1,846.24, and he was entitled to it even if he sustained no actual loss.6 Every figure came from the contract. The same opinion shows what a loss-based claim demands by contrast. Mr. Coxall said personal property left in the vehicle was never returned, and the court recognized that he would be entitled to its value, but he introduced no admissible evidence of that value.7 The floor needed no such proof.
The court also decided how often the floor can be collected. Clover Commercial had violated two separate requirements, yet the court held that it was obligated for only one statutory damage remedy.8 The formula has no variable for the number of violations. It measures the cost of the credit and the size of the deal, so a second failure in the same transaction adds nothing.
The floor also reaches a narrower group of claimants than the damages right taught in the previous section. Only a person that was a debtor or a secondary obligor at the time of the failure qualifies, and a secondary obligor is someone, such as a surety, who answers for the debt as a backstop to the borrower.9 A surety on a consumer's car loan therefore takes the floor. A junior lienholder on the same car stands outside this class and must rely on the loss-based remedy. The formula is built from the consumer's credit transaction, the charge for the credit and the price of the goods, so it fits the people on the borrowing side of that transaction. As with the broader class, status is judged when the failure occurred.
Coxall also shows how the floor behaves when the secured party's own claim fails. The court reasoned that denying a deficiency to the noncomplying secured party should not preclude the debtor's recovery of the statutorily prescribed minimum damages.10 The next section takes up how a lost or reduced deficiency interacts with damages more generally.