Concept
Applying the Elements
Battery
Applying the Elements
A battery claim can fail at any one of four points, and a strong showing on the other three does not save it. Section 13 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts makes an actor liable who acts intending to cause a harmful or offensive contact with another's person, or an imminent apprehension of such a contact, when a harmful contact with that person directly or indirectly results.1 Section 14 requires that the contact be caused by an act of the person whose liability is in question, and §18 supplies the offensive-contact version of the result element.2 The rule therefore divides into act, intent, contact, and causation, the four parts the preceding sections examined one at a time. Each is its own way to lose: a contact that someone else's force produced is not the defendant's act, a defendant who neither wanted nor knew a contact was coming lacks intent, and a contact that is neither harmful nor offensive is no battery however deliberate. Serious injury is the usual reason a missing element goes unnoticed, since grave harm makes liability feel settled before anyone has asked what the defendant intended. A good answer keeps every element open until the facts have closed it.
When a problem supplies a decision to rely on, each element's discussion gains a layer. The answer explains what the decision held and on what facts, then compares those facts with the client's, arguing that a court would reach the same result where the facts are similar and distinguishing the decision where they differ.8 For the contact element, the authority in the Trapp problem below is Polk, which held that the forceful dispossession of Polk's plate in an offensive manner was sufficient to constitute a battery. The court's rule was that unpermitted and intentional contact with anything so connected with the body as to be customarily regarded as part of another's person is actionable as an offensive contact with the person, and it allowed damages for mental suffering without any physical injury.9
The Trapp problem shows the method at full length. Miller sought an impromptu backstage interview with Trapp, and Trapp grabbed her phone from her hand with enough force to dislocate her shoulder.10 The act element takes a sentence, because the grab was Trapp's own intentional movement. Intent takes more. In Franklin it is enough that the defendant intended to cause a contact that turned out to be harmful or offensive, so Trapp's reasons for grabbing, and whether he meant any harm, do not matter.11 His strongest reply is narrower: he wanted the phone, not contact with Miller. The answer to it is that the phone was in her hand, and anything so connected with the body as to be customarily regarded as part of the person counts as the person, so intending to seize the phone from her grasp is intending contact with her.12 That reply joins the intent element to the contact element, and the answer should say so outright.
The contact element has two routes, and the answer takes both. The contact was offensive because Trapp made unpermitted and intentional contact with a phone that was in Miller's hand and so connected to her body as to be regarded as part of her person, and Polk is the authority for that step.13 It was also harmful, because a dislocated shoulder is a physical impairment of the body and the pain that went with it is physical pain, both of which count as bodily harm.14 Either route completes the element, so asserting both protects the claim if a court doubts one. The comparison with Polk costs nothing here: Polk recovered for mental suffering with no physical injury, because personal indignity is the essence of battery and liability reaches offensive contacts as well as harmful ones, and Miller's physical injury only adds a second route.15 Causation is direct, since Trapp's own hand applied the force. The dislocation then raises the rule on unintended injury. Even if Trapp meant only to take a phone and not to hurt a shoulder, an act done intending an offensive contact that causes a bodily contact is a battery although the actor did not intend the resulting bodily harm.16 Consent closes the answer. Miller did not consent, since nothing about seeking an impromptu backstage interview signals agreement to a forceful grab, and her being upset afterward points the same way.17
Intent is the element on which a vivid injury most often misleads, and one changed fact in the Trapp problem shows how it can drop out of the case.
The Peavey and Dorwin problem works the same discipline in miniature, because its facts concede every element but one. Peavey was walking peacefully along a public street when Dorwin, whom he had never seen before, picked up a rock without provocation or warning and struck him with it, and Dorwin was later established to be mentally ill and to suffer recurrent hallucinations.18 Swinging a rock is an act, the blow is a harmful contact, and Dorwin's own hand delivered it, so a student who runs the elements finds that only intent is open. The hallucinations do not change what intent asks. Intent in battery concerns the contact, and it is met by purpose or by knowledge to a substantial certainty. As the Washington court put it, the mere absence of any intent to injure, to play a prank, to embarrass, or to commit an assault and battery does not absolve a defendant who had that knowledge.19 Dorwin deliberately struck Peavey with a rock, and what he understood about the wrongfulness of the blow is no part of the inquiry.
Longer examination problems reward the way an answer handles a weak element. In one, Jessica threw her high-heeled slippers out of a fifth-floor window, and a harmful contact resulted.20 The contact element is easy: the harm came indirectly, through slippers Jessica threw, and §13 reaches a contact that results directly or indirectly.21 Intent is the hard element, and the model answer says so. It may be difficult to find knowledge to a substantial certainty, because the slippers were soft, the drop was five floors, far enough that Jessica could hardly believe any contact possible, and nothing shows she took aim. Against that, the slippers were high-heeled and she threw both. The answer concludes that it is questionable whether she knew with substantial certainty that she would make contact.22
The answer does not stop at that doubt. It turns to a second route: Jessica had the intent required for an assault, and that intent transfers to satisfy the intent for the battery.23 The Restatement reaches the same place without the label. Section 13(a) lists an imminent apprehension of contact among the things an actor may intend, and §16(1) makes an actor who acts with that intent liable for battery when a bodily contact results, although the act was not done with the intention of bringing about the resulting harm.24 The pattern is the lesson: state the best case against liability in the facts' own terms, concede what is genuinely doubtful, and show the independent route that survives the doubt.
Facts that arrive after the contact belong to a different part of the answer. In the problem of Sam, Jerry, and Spot, the closing scene has Sam insisting that Jerry ride with him to the hospital, where a doctor tells him that his fall caused bleeding in his brain and that he needs immediate surgery.25 Those facts establish how grave the injury was, and the answer must still trace the injury back through act, intent, contact, and causation, because a serious injury proves none of them. The method carries from the shortest multiple-choice stem to the longest essay: state the rule, test each element in turn, find the one the defendant can actually contest, and answer that contest on its own terms before concluding.