Concept
The Tort of Assault
Assault
Assault and Apprehension
The Tort of Assault
When a man lifts his cane or fist at another in a threatening manner, or strikes at him and misses, Blackstone calls it an assault.1 Nothing touched the victim, yet the law gives him a claim. The Restatement (Second) of Torts compresses that idea into one sentence with two working clauses. An actor is subject to liability for assault if (a) the actor acts intending to cause a harmful or offensive contact with the person of the other or a third person, or an imminent apprehension of such a contact, and (b) the other is thereby put in such imminent apprehension.2
The first clause supplies the intent element and the second supplies the apprehension element. Every assault problem therefore asks what the defendant was trying to bring about and what the plaintiff came to expect as a result. The intent clause is written in the alternative. A defendant who aims at a contact satisfies it, and so does a defendant who aims only at an imminent apprehension of a contact, which means assault can occur even when the defendant never meant to touch anyone.3 The word apprehension carries a technical meaning. The plaintiff must perceive the threat of an imminent contact, but need not be frightened by it.4 A plaintiff who watches the blow coming and is too courageous to be intimidated has still been put in apprehension, although the plaintiff must be aware of the threatening act while it is still under way.5
Beneath the definition lies a choice about which interest the tort protects. Battery guards the plaintiff's physical well-being and bodily autonomy. Assault guards mental peace, meaning freedom from the apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact.6 The injury consists of the apprehension itself, and that is why the elements say nothing about contact, bodily injury, or proof of actual loss.7 The justification is personal security. In Beach v. Hancock, the New Hampshire court put it this way: "We have a right to live in society without being put in fear of personal harm."8 Assault, like battery, protects that right by authorizing damages for a threatened invasion of the person.9 The action also deters conduct that often leads to disturbances of the peace.10
The courts have long treated the threat itself as the wrong. In I de S et ux. v. W de S, Chief Justice Thorpe held that there was harm and a trespass for which the plaintiffs should recover damages, because the defendant had made an assault upon the woman, "although he did no other harm." The damages were taxed at half a mark.11 Blackstone said the same thing in 1765. Although no actual suffering is proved, the injured party may recover damages as compensation for the injury.12 A plaintiff who proves the elements therefore does not need to show some separate harm.
Later courts spelled the tort out in more words. In Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Hill, the court observed that every battery includes an assault but an assault does not need a battery to complete it. It described the tort as an intentional, unlawful offer to touch another in a rude or angry manner, made in circumstances that create in the plaintiff's mind a well-founded fear of an imminent battery, joined with the apparent present ability to carry out the attempt if not prevented.13 That wording speaks of a well-founded fear and of present ability where the Restatement speaks of apprehension, but the essence of the definitions is similar, and the Restatement distills it.14 Under that formulation the defendant must act with intent, either to place the victim in apprehension of a harmful or offensive contact or to make such a contact, and the victim must reasonably be placed in apprehension of such a contact.15
The tort is narrow by design. It protects against one kind of mental distress, the apprehension of immediate physical aggression, and it is definitely not a general remedy for interference with mental tranquility.16
An exam stem that supplies hostility, insult, or humiliation without a threatened touching is testing this limit. The assault claim fails at the apprehension element however distressing the conduct.
Assault and battery often occur in a single incident, but either tort can be committed without the other, so the two terms must be kept apart.17 The sections that follow take the definition apart in the order a fact pattern requires. They cover the intent element first, then apprehension, then the requirement that the threatened contact be imminent, and finally how words and conditional threats can create or defeat an assault.