Concept
Freedom of Movement Protected
False imprisonment
False Imprisonment
Freedom of Movement Protected
Battery shields the body from unwanted contact, assault shields against the fear of imminent contact, and trespass answers intrusions on property. None of them helps a person whom someone has shut in a room. False imprisonment fills that gap by protecting freedom of movement, the right to go freely through the world and not to be confined against one's will.1 Confinement is a drastic intrusion on personal liberty and a humiliating blow to a person's sense of dignity and independence, which helps explain why the tort dates to the earliest days of the common law.2
The gap is real because battery and assault depend on contact or the apprehension of it. A defendant who locks a person in a storeroom may touch no one and threaten no blow, so neither tort applies, yet the person has lost the freedom to leave. Courts recognized early that this kind of interference is objectionable enough to be actionable by itself. The essence of the tort they recognized is the restriction of the plaintiff's freedom of movement, not harmful or offensive contact.3
The word "false" means unjustified, not deceptive.4 One standard definition describes the tort as a restraint of a person in a bounded area without justification or consent, and it reaches private detention as well as governmental detention.5 A shop owner or a neighbor is as exposed as a police officer. The justification element also allocates the burden at trial: once the plaintiff shows an intentional confinement, the defendant must prove legal justification.6 Consent and privilege, taken up near the end of this chapter, are the main ways a defendant tries to carry that burden.
The Restatement (Second) of Torts supplies the structure for everything that follows. An actor is subject to liability for false imprisonment if all three of these conditions are met:7
- The actor acts intending to confine the other, or a third person, within boundaries the actor fixes.8
- The actor's act directly or indirectly results in such a confinement of the other.9
- The other is conscious of the confinement or is harmed by it.10
Each condition does separate work. The first looks into the defendant's mind. The intent that counts is intent to confine, and carelessness is not enough.11 The second looks at the defendant's act and its result, and the confinement must be total: forcing a plaintiff to take the long way around to a destination does not qualify.12 The third ties the tort back to its purpose. The essence of the wrong is the mental harm of knowing one is not free to move about at will, so where the confinement causes no other harm, the plaintiff must have been aware of it at the time.13
Keeping a person in differs from keeping a person out, and that difference settles many cases. Suppose Munoz blocks the door of her store and refuses to let Maxwell in. She has restricted Maxwell's movement in one direction but has not confined him, because he is free to go anywhere else. The same is true of someone who blocks the plaintiff's way in the street while another route remains open.14
The cause of action is specifically and exclusively for false imprisonment, not a general claim for intentional interference with bodily autonomy. Because courts built it to deal with this one problem, they have developed specific rules. The confinement must be total rather than partial. The plaintiff generally must be conscious of it. The restraint must be intentional, although physical force is not necessary when there is a threat of force.15 The sections that follow take those rules one element at a time.