Concept
Possession and Standing
Trespass to land
Possession and Standing
Trespass protects the right to exclusive possession of land, and that choice of interest decides who may sue.1 The Restatement's wording follows it. One who intentionally enters land "in the possession of another" is liable "to the possessor," even if the entry harms neither land nor person. Its description of entry uses the same phrase, land "in the possession of the other," whether the defendant enters personally or causes a thing or a third person to do so.2 The plaintiff is therefore the possessor. A person is in possession when he is "in occupancy of land with intent to control it," and a tenant under a lease has both occupancy and intent to control.3
Possession rather than title decides standing because the two can belong to different people. The claim goes to the party with the right of possession. When the land is leased, that party is the tenant, and when the owner holds possession himself, the owner is the possessor.4 A hypothetical makes the split concrete.
The leased field shows the same division when something is actually lost. Farmer leases Grangerford's field for a year, and Shepherdson deliberately drives his sheep onto it, where they eat Farmer's grain. Farmer has full control of the field while the lease runs, so he is in possession and may sue in trespass for the value of the grain the sheep consumed.7 Grangerford holds a reversionary interest, which is a right to possession at some later date but not now. Traditionally a reversioner could not sue in trespass, because the defendant had not interfered with a right to possession he did not presently hold.8
The owner is not left without a remedy when the intruder injures the land itself. Where a trespasser damages the owner's interest in the property as well as the possessor's, courts have allowed the owner to recover for that damage under one name or another.9 The California court in Smith v. Cap Concrete, Inc. took this approach, asking what interest the entry injured rather than what the claim should be called. The owner's claim is commonly described as one on the case, and it requires actual damage to the reversionary interest. The owner must show some permanent injury to the property that will still affect him after the land reverts.10
The two plaintiffs differ on proof of harm because their interests differ. A possessor's grievance is the occupation itself. Take Zarvas, who has his lot surveyed and learns that Fox's pipe runs under one corner of it. The pipe does no harm, and it may even keep the lot dry, but it is on his property.11 Nothing in that grievance depends on injury, which is why the Restatement makes an intentional entry actionable although it harms nothing. The reversioner has no comparable grievance, because no one has taken a possession he does not yet hold. His interest lies in the condition of the land when it returns to him, and an entry that leaves that condition unchanged costs him nothing. He recovers only by proving harm to that interest, and the label matters less than that requirement. The common mistake is to hand the suit to whoever holds the deed, when the test points to whoever was occupying the land with intent to control it when the entry occurred.