Concept
Return of Converted Chattels
Remedies and damages for intentional torts
Return of Converted Chattels
A judgment for a converted chattel's value works like a forced sale: the converter pays the price and keeps the goods. That arrangement assumes the owner no longer has the chattel. When the chattel comes back, the arithmetic changes, and Restatement (Second) of Torts § 922 supplies the adjustment.1 Subsection (1) reduces the damages by the chattel's recovery or acceptance by a person entitled to possess it.2 Subsection (2) lets a court, in its discretion, reduce the damages by a tender of return, but only if the conversion was in good faith and under a reasonable mistake and two further conditions are met.3
The two subsections divide on a single question: who decides whether the goods count against the judgment? When the owner takes the chattel back, the credit follows from the owner's own act. When the owner refuses an offered return, a court may apply the credit anyway, but only for an innocent converter and only as a matter of discretion.
Recovery or Acceptance
Section 922(1) provides that the amount of damages for conversion of a chattel is diminished by its recovery or acceptance by a person entitled to its possession.4 The reason lies in the value measure. A judgment for the chattel's value presumes the owner no longer holds the chattel, so an owner who collected that value and also kept the chattel would take both the goods and their price. The credit prevents that double recovery. The text reaches the owner who gets the chattel back and the owner who takes it when the converter offers it, so long as the chattel lands with someone entitled to possess it.
A return shrinks the recovery without ending the lawsuit. When a converter offers the goods back and the owner accepts, the return does not bar the action, but it must be taken into account to reduce the damages recovered.5 How far the damages shrink depends on what the owner still lacks. If the chattel is in the same condition as when it was taken, has not changed in value, and the owner suffered no special damage from being deprived of it, the effect may be to reduce the recovery to nominal damages.6 If the chattel comes back impaired, or the detention cost the owner something, the credit covers only what came back. Conversion damages also reach any further pecuniary loss that the deprivation legally caused and compensation for loss of use not otherwise compensated, and those items remain recoverable after a return.7
A fact pattern that says the chattel was returned therefore does not describe a defense to liability. Compare the chattel's condition and value on return with its condition and value at the taking, then ask whether the detention itself cost the owner anything.
The same reasoning governs an owner who takes the price instead of the goods. An owner may end up holding either the goods or their price, and the law does not allow both. Payment of the chattel's value by a converter to the original owner effects a common-law forced sale of the chattel and precludes the owner's further recovery of damages for later conversions.8 Baram v. Farugia, 606 F.2d 42 (3d Cir. 1979), applying Pennsylvania law, illustrates the rule. A trainer gave an owner's race horse to the defendants in payment of the trainer's debt. The owner sued the defendants for conversion and won the horse's value plus punitive damages. On appeal, the court found that the owner had already collected the horse's full value from the trainer, so accepting that payment was a forced sale to the trainer, and the owner had no conversion action against the defendants.9 The owner who takes the goods back loses the part of the damages the goods replace. The owner who takes the price has sold the goods and has no conversion action left.
Tender in Good-Faith Cases
Section 922(2) governs the owner who is offered the converted chattel back and refuses it. A tender is an offer to hand the chattel over to the person entitled to possess it, and the subsection allows a court, in its discretion, to diminish conversion damages by one.13 Three conditions must first be met. The conversion must have been in good faith and under a reasonable mistake; the chattel's value to the person entitled to it must not be substantially impaired; and the tender must have been made promptly after discovery of the mistake and kept open.14
The older rule gave the owner the last word. An owner who refused the offered return could insist on the full value of the goods as the measure of damages, and the converter had to keep them.15 The rule could be hard on a converter whose only fault was a mistake, but the mistake was no excuse. A converter who takes a chattel under a mistaken belief still means to assert dominion over it, and tort law places the consequence of that mistake on the converter.16
The English courts and some American jurisdictions have softened that rule for a conversion that was innocent and committed under an honest mistake. The court may require the owner to take the goods back and credit the converter with their value, provided the goods are undamaged and the owner's position has not changed.17 Section 922(2) states a similar rule with three express conditions. Discretion remains central. The matter lies within the sound discretion of the trial court, and even in these jurisdictions the converter has no absolute right to force the return as a matter of law.18 Under the older rule the owner's refusal ended the discussion. Under § 922(2) it is one fact the judge weighs, and meeting the three conditions makes the credit available without compelling it.
Good faith and a reasonable mistake must both be present. The rule is built for the innocent converter, so a converter who knew the chattel belonged to another does not qualify, and neither does one whose belief in his right to it was unreasonable. A buyer who pays a small fraction of a chattel's worth, receives no papers, and suspects the seller is a thief holds no reasonable belief of that kind.
The chattel's value to the owner must not be substantially impaired. A chattel that comes back damaged, or unfit for the purposes its owner had for it, is worth less than what was taken, and the owner may decline it and hold out for the price.
The tender must be prompt and must stay open. Promptness runs from discovery of the mistake, so a converter who learns the truth and holds the chattel for months does not qualify. An open tender means the owner can take the chattel back at any time, so an offer withdrawn when the owner hesitates does not count.
Each failure leaves the owner free to refuse the chattel and take the price. When a court does credit a tender, it credits the converter with the chattel's value, and the owner is left with the chattel and with whatever the deprivation itself cost, the same position an accepted return produces under § 922(1).19
The real difference between the two subsections is who decides. Under § 922(1), the owner's acceptance triggers the reduction. Under § 922(2), the court may reduce the damages over the owner's refusal. A fact pattern that reports only an offer to return the chattel has therefore described no defense yet. The answer depends on whether the owner took the chattel back and, if not, whether all three conditions are met and the court is willing to apply the credit.