Concept
Consent to Enter Land
Consent
Consent to Enter Land
The consent rules developed earlier in this chapter apply to land without change: the rules on the effect of consent to the actor's conduct govern both entering and remaining on land.1 The rules on defective consent travel with them. Duress exerted on the possessor, whether by the actor or by a third person to the actor's knowledge, makes the consent ineffective for entry;2 the rules on misrepresentation and mistake, including mistake about the validity of purported legal authority, apply to entry;3 and so does the rule on capacity to consent.4 A trespass problem in which the defendant had permission is therefore a consent problem first, worked in the order this chapter has used throughout.
Land adds a map and a calendar. A possessor may admit a guest to one part of the property, for one period, on stated terms, and the consent then protects the guest only within those limits.5 This unit begins with the basic defense and then follows the three limits in turn: conditions, area, and time.
Consent Defeats Trespass
Paredes invites Marshall to his birthday party. At the appointed time Marshall arrives and knocks on the door, and Paredes declares her a trespasser.6 Measured by the elements alone, Paredes appears to have a claim: under Restatement (Second) § 158, Marshall intentionally entered the land of another, and nothing in the definition excuses an entry merely because the entrant had permission.7 Consent supplies the answer. It is best treated as a defense, or privilege, that defeats recovery even though the prima facie elements of intent, entry, and land of another have all been proved.8 Paredes cannot recover because one who effectively consents to conduct intended to invade his interests cannot recover in tort for the conduct or for harm resulting from it.9 The same defense answers battery and trespass to chattels.10
The defense turns on the possessor's consent, and an entrant's belief that consent was given cannot take its place. Consent is willingness in fact for conduct to occur; it may be manifested by action or inaction and need not be communicated to the actor.11 Words or conduct that another reasonably understands as intended consent are apparent consent, and they are as effective as consent in fact.12 Either way, the willingness, or the words and conduct that express it, must be the possessor's.
A person can also become a trespasser after a welcome entry.13 Paredes's invitation reached a party. If Marshall wanders away from the festivities and takes his horse for a ride, she becomes a trespasser even though she entered with permission.14 The invitation still covers the hours she spent at the party, because consent that is exceeded is ineffective only for the excess.15 And if she returns a week later to fish in his pond, she is a trespasser again, provided the reasonable understanding of the invitation was that it limited entry to the party itself.16 Consent to entry on one occasion or for one purpose is not general consent to entry. The next three subsections trace these limits through conditions, area, and time.
An exam stem that tells you the defendant had permission has not ended the analysis. The elements of trespass will usually be met, so ask two questions. Did the possessor consent, in fact or by words or conduct reasonably read as consent? And did the defendant's conduct at the moment of the claimed trespass fall within what the possessor allowed? Two yeses defeat the claim. A yes followed by a no leaves the defendant a trespasser as to the excess, and a no to the first question leaves a sincere belief in an invitation without force as a defense.
Conditional Consent
A possessor who admits a guest often attaches terms, and the law holds the guest to them: a conditional or restricted consent to enter land creates a privilege only in so far as the condition or restriction is complied with.18 This is the general rule for consent restricted as to time, area, or other respects, applied to entry on land.19 The words 'in so far as' make the privilege divisible. A guest can be inside the permission for one part of a visit and outside it for another, so the same person may be a welcome guest at one moment and a trespasser at the next.
Paredes's party shows the division. Marshall's presence at the party sits inside the invitation. When she wanders away and takes his horse for a ride, she becomes a trespasser though she came onto the land with permission.20 The ride does not reach back and spoil the evening before it, because consent that is exceeded is ineffective only for the excess.21 Liability attaches to the part of the visit that went past the permission and to nothing else.
Whether an invitation carries a condition, and how far it reaches, turns on how a reasonable person in the guest's position would understand the possessor's words and conduct, the same measure that governs apparent consent.22 A guest unsure of the terms can ask, and a possessor who wants a term honored can say so.
On an exam, a stem that reports permission to enter has left open the question of permission to do what, and on what terms. Match the permission, as a reasonable person would understand it, against what the entrant actually did. A mismatch makes the entrant a trespasser as to the mismatched portion only. The next two subsections apply the same rule to restrictions of area and of time.23
Limits of Area
A possessor who opens land in pieces creates a privilege only for the piece opened: consent to the actor's presence on a part of the land creates no privilege to enter or remain on any other part.25 This is the general rule for consent restricted as to area, applied to land.26 The question in a trespass problem is therefore whether the entrant had permission to be on that part of the land, not whether she had permission to be somewhere on the property. Conditions, the subject of the preceding subsection, set the terms of a visit; an area limit sets a place, one that could be drawn on a map.
A store whose owner invites customers into the showroom shows the rule at work. A customer browsing there is where the owner asked her to be. If she climbs the stairs to the owner's apartment and settles in to watch television, she has gone where no invitation reaches, because an owner who invites customers into the showroom does not consent to their coming upstairs to his apartment.27 Her standing as a customer attaches to the part of the building the invitation covered, so it follows her through the showroom and stops at the foot of the stairs.
Because the rule speaks of entering or remaining, it reaches both the moment a guest crosses into a closed area and any lingering there. It leaves the rest of the visit alone. The customer's time in the showroom stays privileged, and liability attaches only to the excess, which is the rule that consent is ineffective for the excess applied to land.28
Where the possessor's line falls depends on what a reasonable person would understand the possessor's words and conduct to include, the measure that governs apparent consent generally.29 Where words are silent, the setting often draws the line: a showroom open to the public invites the public, while a stairway to living quarters does not.
An exam stem that says the plaintiff invited the defendant onto the property has not finished the consent question. Identify the part of the land the possessor opened, locate where the defendant was when the claimed trespass occurred, and compare the two. Presence inside the opened area defeats the claim. Presence outside it leaves the defendant a trespasser as to that part, even though the entry onto the land was welcome. The next subsection applies the same reasoning to time, where the line falls on a calendar and not on a map.
Limits of Time
A possessor's consent to the actor's presence on the land during a specified period of time creates no privilege to enter or remain on the land at any other time.31 The preceding subsection drew its line on a map, and this one draws it on a calendar; both apply the general rule that consent restricted as to time, area, or other respects is effective only within the limits of the restriction.32 Because the rule speaks of entering and remaining, it reaches the guest who arrives before the period begins, the guest who stays past its end, and the guest who comes back on a later occasion.
An invitation to a party does not let the guest stay as long as she says the celebration continues. By inviting Marshall to the party, Paredes does not acquiesce to her staying for a week, even if she claims she is still celebrating.33 Her claim describes her own state of mind, while the privilege follows what Paredes manifested, as a reasonable guest would understand it.34 The period need not be stated in hours, because an occasion can supply it, and an invitation to a party describes a party. Marshall's hours at the party remain privileged, since consent that is exceeded fails only for the excess.35
A later return is a different problem from a week-long stay. If Marshall comes back a week later to fish in Paredes's pond, she is a trespasser, provided the reasonable understanding of the invitation was that it limited entry to the party itself.36 The stay overstays an entry that was privileged when made, while the fishing trip is a fresh entry with no privilege to outlast. The invitation reached one occasion and one purpose, and the fishing trip fits neither. Nor does Paredes need to withdraw the invitation, because a consent restricted to a specified period ends when the period lapses,37 a point the later sections on termination of land consent develop.
The second group shows that a time limit divides a visit and does not condemn all of it. A separate privilege of reasonable egress protects an entrant whose consent has ended, so long as the entrant leaves with reasonable promptness and in a reasonable manner. It does not protect an entrant who knew or had reason to know the time of termination a reasonable period in advance,38 which describes a guest whose invitation names its own end. The later section on reasonable egress takes up the privilege in detail.
On an exam, a stem that reports an invitation has not yet reported what the invitation covered in time. Identify the period the possessor specified, whether by clock, by date, or by naming an occasion, and read it as a reasonable guest would. Then place the defendant's presence on the same calendar. Presence inside the period is privileged, while presence before it, after it, or on a later visit is trespass as to those times only. The guest's own belief that the welcome continued adds nothing, because the privilege follows what the possessor manifested.