Concept
What a Privilege Is
Privilege as a defense to intentional torts; incomplete privilege
Privilege and Incomplete Privilege
What a Privilege Is
The Restatement (Second) of Torts uses "privilege" throughout to name a single situation: conduct that would ordinarily subject the actor to liability does not do so under particular circumstances.1 The definition carries the whole idea. Striking another person or entering another's land normally produces liability, and some added set of circumstances switches that liability off. The rules of privilege say which circumstances qualify.2 Because the conduct would be tortious without those circumstances, they work as a justification. A defendant who establishes them has committed no tort, even if every fact needed for the plaintiff's prima facie case can be proved.3
Privileges fall into two groups: consent, and privileges the law creates irrespective of consent. The second group arises where the defendant's conduct carries some important and overriding social value, even though it harms the plaintiff.4 The law of intent shows why that second group needs its own mechanism. A defendant who acts with the desire to affect the plaintiff, but for a permissible or laudable purpose such as shooting in self-defense, still satisfies the intent requirement. Liability disappears only if the conduct is privileged.5 A good motive therefore cannot defeat the elements. The elements cannot tell a justified blow from a wrongful one, and privilege does that sorting.
The sorting happens at a specific point in a lawsuit. The plaintiff first offers proof of each element of the tort. The defendant then has two ways to answer. One is to deny an element, saying the touching never happened or was never intended, which attacks the plaintiff's own case. The other is to accept that the elements are met and add facts that avoid liability anyway, which is the structure of an affirmative defense.6 The affirmative defenses tied most closely to the events of the incident are the privileges, and self-defense is the classic example. Suppose Jones sues Smith for battery. Smith may plead that she hit Jones because she was warding off a blow from Jones. If that is true, Smith was privileged to inflict the contact and is not liable for it.7
The two stories lead to different places at trial. The first leaves the plaintiff to prove the defendant acted at all. The second concedes the plaintiff's case and asks the jury to accept facts the defendant supplies, a burden the next section takes up. Not every defense that concedes the elements is a privilege, however. A defendant may admit an intentional harmful touching and still plead the statute of limitations, arguing that suit came too late, or point to a release the plaintiff signed earlier.8 Both defenses rest on facts that have nothing to do with what happened in the incident, so neither says anything about whether the conduct was justified. The act stays as wrongful as it was, and the defense only removes the plaintiff's right to sue on it.
The word also names a different set of rules in the law of evidence. There, a privilege gives a witness the option not to disclose information in court, particularly information first communicated in a professional or confidential relationship.9 Those rules govern what may be said in testimony and have no bearing on whether conduct was tortious. Here and throughout this chapter, privilege means the tort defense.
The same line separates privilege from defenses that work on the plaintiff's recovery rather than on the defendant's wrong. Contributory negligence is the familiar example. It reduces or bars the plaintiff's recovery but does not negate the tortious nature of the defendant's conduct.10 A defendant whose carelessness injured the plaintiff remains a wrongdoer even when the plaintiff's own carelessness defeats the claim. A privileged actor is in a different position, because the privilege goes to whether a wrong occurred at all. The sections that follow identify the recognized privileges and then test their limits.