Concept
Privilege as Affirmative Defense
Privilege as a defense to intentional torts; incomplete privilege
Privilege as Affirmative Defense
The Restatement uses the word privilege to mean that conduct which would ordinarily subject the actor to liability does not, because of particular circumstances.1 That definition does not say who must bring those circumstances before the court, or who loses if they go unproven. The general answer is that privilege is an affirmative defense: the defendant must plead it and prove it.2
A defendant who pleads a privilege says, in effect, that even if the plaintiff has shown every element of the tort, additional facts relieve the defendant of liability.3 The plaintiff proves the prima facie case, and the defendant proves the additional facts. A defendant who cannot prove them is left facing the tort the plaintiff established.
Courvoisier v. Raymond shows the allocation at work. The jewelry store owner there committed a battery on a police officer, so the only question was whether a privilege excused it. If the owner acted reasonably, the privilege of self-defense precludes his liability to the officer.4 Because self-defense is an affirmative defense, the owner bore the burden both to raise it and to prove the facts that establish it.5 What reasonableness requires of a defendant who is mistaken about the threat is taken up in the later section on mistake.
Sorting the defendant's answer tells you who carries the burden. Some answers dispute the plaintiff's prima facie case by denying that contact occurred or that the defendant intended it, and the plaintiff keeps the burden on those. Other answers concede the prima facie case and rely on additional facts that allow the defendant to avoid liability.6 Privilege belongs to that second group, and the steps below put the sorting in order.
The first and third steps mark the line that matters most. A defendant who says the contact was an accident need prove nothing, because the plaintiff must still show intent. A defendant who says the contact was deliberate but justified has conceded the plaintiff's case and must prove the justification. Step four is the exception, taken up next.
Consent and the Burden of Proof
Consent is the privilege whose burden is most likely to be reversed. Historically, actual consent was technically not a privilege in the intentional torts that invade the person (assault, battery, and false imprisonment), as opposed to the torts that invade property interests. Lack of consent was an element of those torts, and the plaintiff ordinarily had to establish it as part of the prima facie case. That rule is evolving, and some jurisdictions now treat consent in these cases as an affirmative defense.9
The courts have not settled the question. Some cases treat consent, like most privileges, as an affirmative defense that the defendant must raise and prove if she claims the plaintiff consented to the contact.10 The Third Restatement's volume on intentional torts to persons takes no position on the burden of proof for consent.11
The uncertainty reaches false imprisonment as well. Consent, the privilege to detain a customer to investigate apparent shoplifting, and the privilege to arrest are the three most common privileges asserted, and it is not entirely clear whether the plaintiff must prove their absence as part of her prima facie case. Logically, they should probably be viewed as defenses that the defendant must plead and prove.12 What counts as consent is a separate question, taken up in the next section.
Consent in the person torts is therefore the clearest exception to the rule that a privilege is the defendant's burden. When an exam problem raises consent in a battery, assault, or false imprisonment claim, check how the problem's jurisdiction treats it. If the facts do not say, note the split and give the result under each approach.