Concept
Resisting Privileged Force
Self-defense and defense of others
Resisting Privileged Force
A person cannot use self-defense against force the law permits the other to use. The Restatement (Second) of Torts puts the rule in one sentence and builds its exception into the same sentence: the actor is not privileged to defend himself against any force or confinement that the other is privileged, for any purpose, to inflict on him, except where the other's privilege rests on a reasonable mistake of fact that the actor did not cause by his own fault.1 The sentence holds a bar and an exception, and each has its own logic.
The bar follows from a word the earlier sections have carried all along. Section 63(1) privileges reasonable force only against an "unprivileged" harmful or offensive contact, so a contact the other is privileged to make gives self-defense nothing to answer.2 The criminal law reaches the same limit from the defender's side. Force in self-defense must oppose force that is unlawful, meaning in general that it would be a crime or tort for the adversary to use, and so a person cannot properly defend himself against known lawful force or against force to which he has consented.3
Because the bar reaches force privileged "for any purpose," it does not matter which privilege the other person holds. A lawful arrest is the familiar case, and a person who knows the arrest is lawful may not strike the officer to get free. Crime prevention is another: one who reasonably believes that a felony, or a misdemeanor amounting to a breach of the peace, is being committed or is about to be committed in his presence may use reasonable force to terminate or prevent it.4 Self-defense is a third, and it catches the aggressor. Someone who attacks without privilege and meets reasonable force from his victim faces privileged force, so he cannot answer it with self-defense. The normal privilege returns to him only against the victim's excessive force or confinement.5
The exception covers a different situation, one in which the other person's privilege exists only because he made a mistake. Some privileges rest on a reasonable belief about a fact and survive even when the belief later proves false. The law generally privileges such a mistake where it appears necessary to act quickly to protect an important interest that does in fact exist, or where the actor is under a duty to protect the public interest.6 Self-defense itself works this way. The privilege exists if the actor reasonably believes that the other intends to inflict a harmful or offensive contact on him, even though the other in fact has no such intention.7
If the bar applied to that mistaken believer without exception, the person on the receiving end of his force would have to take the blow even though he had done nothing wrong. The exception lets him protect himself, so that two people acting without fault may each be privileged against the other. Two conditions limit it, and each has its own reason.
The first condition is that the mistake be reasonable. The test is objective. It asks what a reasonable person, whose chief qualities are ordinary firmness and courage, would have concluded from the circumstances the actor knew or should have known.8 A belief that fails the test creates no privilege at all. The bar never comes into play, and the contact is an ordinary unprivileged one that the target may resist under § 63(1).9 In the Restatement's illustration, B is abnormally timid and unreasonably believes that A, who is reaching into his hip pocket for a handkerchief, is about to pull out a revolver. B is not privileged to knock A down.10 The exception therefore matters only in the middle ground, where the mistake was reasonable, the other person is privileged, and the target would otherwise be helpless.
The second condition is that the actor's own fault not have caused the mistake. A person whose wrongful act leads another reasonably to fear attack has created the occasion for the reaction, and the exception does not let him fight it. The general rule on induced mistakes points the same way: where the plaintiff induced the defendant's mistake, the defendant is absolved of liability for it so long as he did not act unreasonably.11
The Restatement's practical-joke illustration shows the condition at work. A, as a joke and intending only to frighten B, draws back his hand as if to strike while within striking distance. B reasonably believes that A is about to strike him, seizes A's arm, and accidentally scratches his hand severely. B is not liable to A.12 B's privilege rests on a reasonable mistake, but A's own joke produced the mistake, so the exception is unavailable to A and he has no privilege to resist B's grab.13 Inés and A stand in the same position, since each is seized by someone who wrongly feared an attack. The difference is who made the danger appear.
Two errors recur. The first treats privileged force as privileged without limit, so that a lawful arrest or an act of crime prevention that turns into a beating still bars self-defense, when in fact the person keeps the ordinary privilege against the excess (step two). The second stops after finding a reasonable mistake and misses that the exception is lost to the person whose own fault created the appearance of danger (step five).
The same question, who keeps a privilege when a mistake is involved, returns in the next section, where one person defends another. One condition of the intervenor's privilege is that the circumstances give the third person a privilege of self-defense.14 Courts divide over a mistake about that. Some hold that the intervenor assumes the risk of being mistaken and is privileged only if and to the extent that the third person was. Other courts, and Restatement (Second) § 76, hold that a reasonable mistake does not negate the privilege.15