Concept
Excessive Force
Defense of property: land and chattels
Excessive Force
A possessor who may use force against an intruder may not use as much as he likes. The privilege exists to stop an intrusion, and the Restatement (Second) of Torts holds it to that purpose in two steps. Section 81(1) caps the means: the actor may use no means intended or likely to cause bodily harm or confinement beyond what the actor correctly or reasonably believes necessary to prevent or terminate the intrusion.1 Section 82 then says what follows when a possessor crosses that cap.2
Section 82 yields three separate consequences. The actor is liable for so much of the force or confinement as is excessive.3 The intruder's liability for the intrusion is not affected.4 And the intruder may defend himself against the excess.5 The last consequence means that a single encounter can begin with the possessor as defender and end with the possessor as aggressor. The four subsections below take the steps in order: the means a possessor may not use, what the possessor owes for the excess, what the intruder still owes, and what the intruder may do about the excess.
Excessive Means Barred
The cap in § 81(1) turns on three phrases. The means is the instrument and manner the possessor chooses. Intended or likely directs attention to what that means could be expected to do when it was chosen. And correctly or reasonably believes necessary gives the possessor two ways to stay inside the privilege: the force was in fact needed, or it was not needed but the possessor reasonably thought it was.6 The cap governs the ordinary range of defensive acts (a grab, a shove, a blow, a locked door) and works alongside the separate bar on deadly force.
The cap ties force to the job at hand. The privilege is one to prevent or end an intrusion, so harm beyond what that job takes serves no defensive purpose. Self-defense law draws the same line. The privilege does not encompass retaliation or revenge, and the defender may use only as much force as is, or reasonably appears to be, immediately necessary.7 Smith may block a slap or push Jones away but may not knife Jones in the ribs.8 A possessor has the same range of choices and must keep the means tied to ending the intrusion rather than to anger at the intruder.
The belief language does a second job. A possessor picks a means in seconds, so the rule asks what the possessor correctly or reasonably believed, not what a calm review later shows would have been enough. A possessor who reasonably but wrongly thought a gentler step would fail stays inside the privilege. A possessor who treats the intrusion as an occasion to hurt someone does not. The test therefore looks at two things: the means chosen, and the situation as it reasonably appeared when the possessor chose it. Asking afterward whether a milder measure would in fact have worked is the hindsight error.
Katko v. Briney, taken up with mechanical devices below, isolates the setting in which this ceiling operates. The Iowa court asked whether an owner may protect personal property in an unoccupied, boarded-up farmhouse against trespassers and thieves with a spring gun capable of inflicting death or serious injury, and it set to one side an owner's right to protect home and family.9
Two ordinary cases show where the line falls. In Emmons v. Quade, a mill worker used a club on a twelve-year-old boy scooping spilled grain from a railroad car, and the force was unreasonable. The boy put a small quantity of loose grain at stake, and a club is likely to cause real injury to a child, so the harm the worker was ready to inflict bore no sensible relation to the interest he was protecting. A refused request to leave would not change that result, because § 81(1) measures the means against what ending the intrusion required.
Brittany's punch at the start of this chapter falls on the other side. Zachary raised a sledgehammer over her Mercedes and announced he would bash in the hood. She punched him and knocked him out cold, and his battery claim fails because she was privileged to use reasonable force to protect her property.10 Both scenes involve a blow struck to protect property, so the blow alone cannot explain the different results. What differs is the proportion between threat and means. A raised sledgehammer threatens serious damage, and one punch is a modest answer to it. Spilled grain is a trivial loss, and a club is far more than ending that taking called for. Zachary's knockout also shows that the injury suffered does not settle the question by itself. The means is measured against the threat as it appeared.
What follows when a possessor crosses the line is the next question.
Liability for the Excess
A possessor who goes past the privilege answers only for the part that lies beyond it. When the actor applies force or imposes confinement beyond what is privileged, the actor is liable for so much of the force or confinement as is excessive.12 The rule treats the encounter as two layers. Force within the privilege stays privileged. The layer above it is an ordinary tort, battery for excess force and false imprisonment for excess confinement, and the possessor pays for the added harm it caused.
Apportioning liability keeps it on the wrongful part of the conduct. If one excessive blow forfeited the privilege for the whole encounter, a justified shove would become a tort because of what came after it. If the excess went unremedied, force the privilege never covered would meet no check once an intrusion was under way. Liability for the excess alone answers both problems.
Self-defense follows the same pattern. A defender who becomes the aggressor exceeds the privilege and is liable to the extent of the damage caused by the excessive force. The defender may not keep using violence after the other person is subdued, disarmed, helpless, or has clearly withdrawn.13 Excess in defense of land and chattels comes from facts of three kinds. The means may be harsher than the situation required, as § 81(1) provides. Force may continue after the intrusion has ended or the intruder has given up. Or a confinement may outlast its purpose. An owner who keeps a trespasser locked in a tool shed for hours after the trespass has ended presents the confinement case. The privilege to hold the trespasser lasts only as long as it serves to prevent or end the intrusion, so the owner answers for the hours that followed, and the original detention stays privileged.14
Brittany's knockout punch marks the same boundary. Had she struck Zachary again as he lay unconscious, that second blow, and only that blow, would have been the excess.
Students often conclude that an overreacting possessor loses the privilege for the whole encounter and owes for the first shove too. The rule does not say that. It finds the point where the force passed what the situation reasonably required and assigns liability from that point forward.
Intruder Remains Liable
A possessor's overreaction leaves the intruder's own liability untouched. Under § 82(b), when the actor uses excessive force or confinement, the other person's liability for any intrusion upon the actor's land or chattels is not affected.16 The encounter therefore holds two wrongs, and each party answers for his own. The intruder entered or took without right, and that wrong was complete before the possessor reacted. The possessor then applied force the privilege did not cover. Neither claim is netted against the other, and nothing the possessor does afterward supplies a right to have been there.
Both alternatives fail. If a harsh response erased the intruder's liability, an intruder could buy immunity for the entry by provoking an overreaction, and the possessor's claim would turn on restraint rather than on whether the entry was wrongful. If the intruder's wrong excused the excess, the ceiling in § 81(1) would bind possessors against no one, since every intruder who meets the privilege has done something wrongful. Keeping the two wrongs separate avoids both results.
A problem that describes a possessor's overreaction invites an answer that stops once the possessor is found liable. The complete answer also asks whether the intruder remains liable for the entry, and it treats the two claims as independent. Whether the intruder may also resist the excess while it is being applied is a different question, taken up next.
Intruder's Self-Defense
When the possessor uses or attempts to use excessive force or confinement, the intruder has a privilege to defend himself against it.18 The two preceding subsections fixed what each side owes. This one gives the intruder something to do, and it reverses the roles. Until the possessor passes the privilege, the possessor may use force and the intruder has no justification for resisting. At the moment the possessor's force exceeds the privilege, the possessor has become an aggressor, and the intruder is a person defending his own body.
The baseline is that an intruder has no privilege of self-defense against force the possessor is entitled to use.19 A privilege to use force would mean little if the person it is used on could lawfully strike back, because every confrontation at a gate or a car door would become a contest in which both sides were justified. An intruder who resists privileged, non-deadly force therefore commits a battery of his own. Had Zachary stayed on his feet and swung the sledgehammer at Brittany after her punch, he would have had no self-defense claim, because her punch was within the privilege. His swing would have threatened her with bodily harm, and the ordinary self-defense rules would then have governed her response.20
Excess removes the baseline because the intruder's wrong, the entry or the taking, supports only the force needed to end it.21 Once the possessor applies more, the possessor has no privilege to invoke for the excess, and the intruder is simply a person under attack. Two shortcuts fail. One treats a trespasser as having given up every protection by trespassing, but the trespass explains only the force the privilege covers. The other gives the intruder a defense against any force at all, but § 82(c) opens the privilege only against the excess.
The top of the range shows the reversal most clearly. An owner who uses deadly force against a thief who is not threatening the owner's life or limb has exceeded the privilege, as the earlier bar on deadly force provides. The thief may then defend himself under the ordinary self-defense rules, which permit deadly force against a threat of death or serious bodily harm.22 The shift can also run the other way. If the thief meets the owner with what reasonably appears to be deadly force, the owner may answer with deadly force in self-defense, because the thief's resort to deadly force has turned a defense of property into a defense of human life.23 In either direction, the party who first brings a threat to life or body into the encounter loses the shelter of the property rules.
Section 82(c) covers attempted excess as well as completed excess, because it speaks of the actor's use or attempted use of excessive force or confinement.24 The intruder need not wait to be struck, shot, or locked in. Because the privilege is one of self-defense, it carries the usual limits. The intruder may use only as much force as is, or reasonably appears to be, immediately necessary against the excess, and an intruder who answers a modest excess with far greater force exceeds the privilege in turn.25 Nor does the privilege cancel the intruder's earlier wrong, so one encounter can end with the possessor liable for the excess and the intruder liable for the entry.26
The woman had no privilege at the first stage and a privilege at the second, and the only thing that changed was the amount of force the caretaker applied. Her privilege answers the lunge, so it ends with the lunge. A problem that asks whether an intruder could fight back is best solved by testing the possessor's force first.