Concept
Working Through a Fact Pattern
Failure to act: no duty to rescue, special relationships, and undertakings
Working Through a Fact Pattern
Restatement (Second) of Torts § 314 supplies the baseline for every problem in this chapter: realizing, or having reason to realize, that another person needs help does not by itself require anyone to give it.1 A crowded scene tests that baseline hard, because everyone present sees the same danger and yet each person lands on one side of the line for a different reason. The exceptions from earlier in the chapter therefore work best as a fixed sequence of questions, put to one defendant at a time.
The sequence follows the order in which the chapter built the doctrine, and each step either ends the inquiry or decides which limits come next. Classification comes first, because an omission that is part of the defendant's own risk-creating conduct is judged as ordinary negligence; no exception is needed to reach it, and a student who skips the step may spend a whole answer hunting for a relationship the claim never required. Causing the peril comes second, because a duty that rests on the defendant's own conduct needs no relationship and no promise: one whose conduct, tortious or innocent, has injured another and left him helpless and in danger of further harm must use reasonable care to prevent that harm.2 Relationship comes third, because a tie such as carrier and passenger fixes the duty before any emergency begins.3 Only then does the analysis reach the volunteer routes, where the defendant owed nothing until he undertook to help, took charge of a helpless person, or interfered with someone else's aid. The last step comes last because its limits govern those volunteer routes. A duty from a relationship or from the defendant's own conduct needs neither increased risk nor reliance. A duty from an undertaking that benefits a third person needs one of three alternative showings: that the failure to use care increased the risk, that the defendant undertook a duty the other owed the third person, or that the harm came from reliance on the undertaking.4
A roadside problem shows each step at work. Six people figure in it, and the question concerns the claims of only one of them, Ace. King's driving causes an accident that leaves debris in the lane, and Ace is later hurt because the road has not been cleared. Phil goes to help King. Queen stops and does part of the job of clearing the road. Deuce, who has some medical training, drives past. Trip, King's partner, is traveling with King to a joint paint job.5 Because the question concerns only Ace, every duty discussed below must be a duty owed to Ace.
King comes first because the earliest events are his. Whether the accident itself was negligent is a breach question under ordinary principles, since King was driving. The duty question that matters to Ace is narrower: once the accident had happened, did King owe a duty to do something about the debris? Most courts would say yes. Because King caused the accident that created the risk, he must do what he can to mitigate it, whether or not he was negligent, as Restatement (Third) of Torts § 39 provides.6 The reasoning behind every conduct-based exception shows here: the person who turned a safe road into a dangerous one is no stranger to the danger.
Deuce lands on the other side of the line, because every step of the sequence comes up empty. His omission is pure inaction, he did nothing to cause the debris, he has no relationship to Ace, and nothing in the problem suggests he began to help or interfered with anyone. Even if he saw the debris and knew someone should clear it, that knowledge creates no duty.7 His medical training changes nothing either. The skill that would make him a competent rescuer imposes no duty to aid, and Ace's claim concerns the failure to stop and clear the road, not the failure to give medical care, so the training is irrelevant twice over.8 The general rule likewise refuses to find a duty because rescue would be easy, because it would be morally appropriate, or because the risk is great; skill adds nothing the rule has not already rejected.9 Whatever King and Deuce each knew, what separates them is that King's conduct produced the hazard.
Queen presents the volunteer question. She began as a bystander in Deuce's position, so the issue is whether she assumed a duty to Ace by stopping and doing part of the job.10 Step five decides it. Unless Ace dealt with her directly, he is a third person to her undertaking, and the third-person rule governs: one who undertakes, gratuitously or for consideration, services he should recognize as necessary to protect a third person is liable for physical harm caused by a failure to use reasonable care only if one of the three showings above is met.11 The parallel rule for services to the person to be protected asks the first and last of those questions, increased risk and reliance.12
Stopping to clear part of the road is therefore a reason to ask the volunteer question, not an answer to it. A related rule draws a similar line for a rescuer who has taken charge of a helpless person: it ties liability for discontinuing aid to leaving the other in a worse position than when the rescuer took charge.13 A partial clearing that left the road no more dangerous than the debris alone, with nothing to show that anyone counted on it, supplies none of the showings, so no duty to Ace attaches. A partial clearing that pushed hazards into the lane would supply increased risk. One that led other drivers to assume the road was being handled would supply reliance. And because King owed Ace a duty to mitigate, a court could also ask whether Queen took over King's job. A strong answer names the facts that would supply each showing and says whether the problem contains them.
Phil's route runs through the undertaking rules, because nothing suggests he caused the debris or stood in any relationship to Ace. His help went to King, and the third-person rule reaches services the defendant should recognize as necessary to protect the third person, so the question is what Phil's help was meant to protect.14 Help aimed at King's own situation does not become a duty to protect Ace from the debris merely because it was help. The picture changes if the facts show that Phil took over King's job of clearing the road, because an undertaking to perform a duty that King owed Ace satisfies the assumed-duty showing without proof of increased risk or reliance.15 If Phil did owe a duty to clear the debris, his going to help King instead raises a separate breach question, and the answer must keep the two issues apart.16
Trip is the hardest case. As King's partner, he was traveling with King to a joint paint job, and the question is whether that shared venture supports a duty to stop and assist. At least one court has imposed duties on persons engaged in a joint venture to assist each other, based on their relationship: Farwell v. Keaton, 240 N.W.2d 217 (Mich. 1976). That rationale would support a duty for Trip to assist King, though perhaps not a duty to act to protect Ace, who was a stranger to the venture.17 A second route runs through step two. An argument can be made that Trip, who engaged in risk-creating conduct with King by driving to the job, must like King act to mitigate the danger their joint activity caused.18 The problem leaves Trip's duty open, so credit goes to the answer that lays out both routes and states the rule each rests on.
The interference rules drop out of this problem. Liability under them requires that someone prevent or disable a third person from giving aid: intentionally in one rule, and negligently in the other when the defendant knew or had reason to know that the third person was giving or ready to give aid.19 On these facts nobody blocks another's rescue, and a good answer says so in a sentence and moves on.
A correct conclusion earns little when the rule behind it is missing. An answer that says Trip owed a duty because he was King's partner leaves the grader guessing whether partnership works as vicarious liability, as a special relationship, or as shared risk creation, and it shows none of the reasoning.20 State the rule first, apply it second, and explain third why the facts do or do not satisfy it. Then stay with the question asked, which here is Ace's claims; time spent on claims King or Phil might bring earns nothing.