Concept
The Reasonable Person Baseline
Children, mental condition, and physical disability
Modified Standards of Care
The Reasonable Person Baseline
Negligence law measures nearly every actor against a single yardstick: the conduct of a reasonable person under like circumstances. The Restatement (Second) of Torts writes the one exception into the rule's opening words: unless the actor is a child, the reasonable-person standard governs.1 The yardstick is objective. A court compares what the defendant did with what an ordinary, reasonably prudent person would have done in the same situation, and it does not ask what this defendant was personally capable of or sincerely believed.2
The classic case shows why the law refuses to bend the yardstick to fit the defendant. In Vaughan v. Menlove, the defendant built a hay rick near the boundary of his land, close to the plaintiff's cottages. The plaintiff alleged that the rick was likely to ignite, that the defendant had notice of the danger and negligently left the rick in that condition, and that it did ignite and the fire spread to burn the cottages.3 Menlove's proposed test would have judged him by the best he could do. The courts have stuck instead with the test of a reasonable person under the circumstances.4
The rejected test would have cost the law a great deal. Negligence would have had not one standard of care but a million, and trials would have examined each defendant's character and intelligence in place of his conduct. The perennially careless would have enjoyed the right to endanger their neighbors with impunity.5 The objective test supplies what that alternative lacks. It allows impartial application, spares courts subjective judgments about individual character, and lets people predict some of the consequences of their conduct.6
The standard is a legal judgment, not a moral one. Morally, we could hardly fault a Menlove for a judgment that was the best he could do. Legally, we need a standard that defines fault in some predictable, universal way, and the reasonable-person test serves as a neutral instrument for deciding disputes rather than a verdict on anyone's character.7
The same logic defeats the plea that the defendant simply did not know better. In a standard teaching example, Mitch is held to what an ordinary person in the community, here Minneapolis, would know: that the glistening white powder was snow, not cocaine. The ordinary, reasonably prudent person standard makes no allowance for differences in intelligence, education, or temperament, so an actor cannot lower the bar by pointing to his own.8 The alternative would ask the courtroom to gauge each defendant's intelligence and temperament and to decide whether he acted in good faith or to the best of his ability. That is a task of mind-reading, which the law leaves to juries deciding mens rea in criminal cases.9
The phrase under like circumstances still raises a question that organizes everything that follows: which personal characteristics count as circumstances? The reasonable person is a fictitious construct, but real people each have unique physical and mental characteristics, and the standard accommodates some of them.10 Three answers are previewed here and developed in the sections below. Youth counts: a child is measured against a reasonable person of like age, intelligence, and experience.11 Physical disability counts: an actor who is ill or physically disabled is measured against a reasonable person under like disability.12 Mental deficiency does not count: unless the actor is a child, insanity or other mental deficiency does not relieve the actor of liability for conduct that falls short of the reasonable-person standard.13
On an exam, sort each trait the facts attach to the actor into one of two piles. Good faith, honest best effort, poor judgment, and limited intelligence, education, or temperament are not circumstances, and they cannot lower the standard. Youth and physical disability are the traits that do count, each through its own rule, and an adult's mental deficiency does not.