Concept
Comparing the Three Standards
Children, mental condition, and physical disability
Comparing the Three Standards
Every actor except a child is held to the conduct of a reasonable person under like circumstances, and the three modifications in this chapter answer one question: which personal traits count as those circumstances?1 Youth counts. A child is measured against a reasonable person of like age, intelligence, and experience.2 Physical disability counts. An actor who is ill or otherwise physically disabled is measured against a reasonable person under like disability.3 Adult mental deficiency does not count. Unless the actor is a child, insanity or other mental deficiency does not relieve him of liability for conduct that falls short of the reasonable-person standard.4
The pattern invites an objection. A blind actor is compared with a reasonable blind person, yet an actor of poor judgment is not compared with a reasonable person of poor judgment. One source puts the point sharply: if a blind person is not held to the standard of a sighted person, why should Menlove be held to the standard of a person with good judgment?5 In Vaughan v. Menlove, the defendant argued that he had exercised his judgment to the best of his ability and should not be liable merely because his best was not very good. The law made allowance for physical disabilities and none for the circumstance that a person lacks good judgment, is hasty, awkward, or perennially oafish.6
Two practical features of physical disability answer the objection. A sighted person is unlikely to feign blindness successfully before a jury, and other people can usually detect an identifiable physical disability and adjust their own behavior.7 The disability must also be significant and ascertainable. A driver who calls his tennis partner to testify to his total lack of coordination will not lower the standard of care that way.8
Adult mental deficiency runs into the opposite problems. The evidence of it is often unsatisfactory and easy to feign. The trier of fact has difficulty determining its existence, nature, degree, and effect. There is also some fear of importing into tort law the confusion that has surrounded such a defense in the criminal law. Advances in medical and psychiatric science may lessen those concerns, but for now they remain a major obstacle to any allowance for mental deficiency.9
The refusal is a legal judgment, not a moral one. Morally, we could hardly fault Menlove for the best judgment he could give, or a mentally ill defendant for conduct compelled by delusion or neurosis. The reasonable-person-under-like-circumstances test is a neutral instrument for deciding disputes and says nothing about a person's character. Its message to an actor who has trouble meeting it is to curtail activity or exercise particular self-restraint, or be restrained by others, to avoid liability.10
Exam questions press on the boundaries, and no standard resolves them mechanically. Each standard tells the jury whom to imagine, and when no concrete rule makes reasonableness more definite, different juries may resolve the same or highly similar facts differently.11 A good answer therefore picks the right comparison figure, applies the stated reasons, and argues to a conclusion.
Consider first an adult whose intellectual functioning resembles a child's, as Lou's does. The child rule speaks to actors who are children, and for everyone else mental deficiency does not relieve liability.12 Weak intelligence is among the traits the law will not accommodate, so the actor must curtail activity or exercise particular self-restraint.13 Dana's limited intelligence counts because she is eleven, and Lou's identical limitation does not count because he is thirty.
A condition that seems to straddle the physical and mental categories calls for reasoning, not a label. A physical disability earns an allowance because it is significant, ascertainable, hard to feign, and detectable by others.14 A mental deficiency earns none because the evidence of it is unsatisfactory, easy to feign, and hard to assess.15 Test the condition against both sets of reasons, say which it matches more closely on the facts, and note the alternative result.
The disability allowance fixes the comparison figure and does not approve every choice the actor makes. A blind person who decides to get behind the wheel of a car acts unreasonably even with blindness counted among the circumstances. The same person on a sidewalk with a white cane and a guide dog is expected to act differently from a fully sighted pedestrian.16 The questions are whether the activity was reasonable for a person with that disability and, if so, whether the person took the precautions the disability called for.
Finally, do not confuse limited judgment with an error of judgment. Professional-negligence doctrine says a professional is not liable for a 'mere error of judgment,' and the phrase describes one element of the professional standard, the exercise of a discerning judgment, alongside knowledge and skill.17 It does not make an ordinary adult's poor judgment a circumstance, and Menlove's plea that he did his best failed for that reason.18
Sympathy for the actor settles nothing at any step. The category the trait falls into does.