Concept
Skill as a Circumstance
Professionals, skilled actors, and other special classes
Professionals and Special Skill
Skill as a Circumstance
A surgeon, a lawyer, and a gas-station attendant are all measured by the same yardstick. Negligence law asks of each whether the actor used the care a person of ordinary prudence would use under the circumstances, and skill enters the analysis as one of those circumstances. The point is easy to miss because the rules for professionals sound like a second, stricter duty laid over ordinary negligence. They are not, and the rest of this chapter makes more sense once that is clear.
The California Supreme Court's decision in Flowers v. Torrance Memorial Hospital Medical Center states the framework. Negligence is conduct that falls below the standard the law sets to protect others against unreasonable risk of harm, so the actor must exercise the care a person of ordinary prudence would exercise under the circumstances.1 Because that principle is applied to facts, the amount of care a case calls for varies from one case to the next. The standard itself stays constant: due care commensurate with the risk, taking all relevant circumstances into account.2
The constant standard is easiest to appreciate by imagining its opposite. If each defendant's own ability set the bar, a jury would first have to grade the defendant's skill before judging the conduct, and the least capable actors would owe the least care to everyone they endanger. One objective standard, filled in by the circumstances of the case, avoids both problems.
Restatement (Second) of Torts § 299A applies the framework to skilled work. Unless the actor represents that he has greater or less skill or knowledge, one who undertakes to render services in a profession or trade must exercise the skill and knowledge normally possessed by members of that profession or trade in good standing in similar communities.3 Read as a duty-creating rule, it looks like a new obligation. Read alongside the general standard, it tells a jury what reasonable care means for someone doing skilled work.
Circumstances reach well beyond the physical scene. The resources available to the actor count. Exploratory surgery may be reasonable where less invasive diagnostic methods are unavailable and unreasonable where they are available, and a general practitioner may reasonably litigate an antitrust case in northern Maine, where antitrust lawyers are scarce, but not in Washington, D.C., where they are everywhere.4 The actor's position counts as well. A companion Restatement rule says an act may be negligent if it is done without the competence that a reasonable person in the actor's position would recognize as necessary to prevent an unreasonable risk of harm to others.5
For professionals, two obligations follow. They must exercise due care in what they do, and they must also possess and exercise a standard minimum of special knowledge and ability.6 Lay jurors are not equipped to decide what reasonable care means in professional work unless they can measure the actor's conduct against that of other professionals.7 The same reasoning reaches a hospital. Its business is caring for ill persons, so its conduct is measured against that of a person of ordinary prudence under the circumstances, and the patient's illness is a vital part of those circumstances.8
A greater amount of care is not a different standard of care. California's high court has said that the law knows no degrees of care, only different amounts of care as a matter of fact. Those who deal with dangerous instrumentalities must use more care than those in less responsible capacities, yet the former are no more negligent than the latter for failing to use the care the situation required.9 How much care is enough follows from the size of the risk weighed against the burden of avoiding it. In the treatise's railroad example, a $12 million overpass would avert six likely accidents with an expected injury cost of $3 million, and the decision not to build it may well be reasonable.10 The distinction matters most when a lawyer drafts a jury instruction.
The requested instruction announces a separate legal standard, and that misstates the law, which recognizes different amounts of care but no degrees of care.11 The reasonable person under the usual standard simply takes more care when the circumstances carry high risk.
Both defendants are therefore held to reasonable care under the circumstances. For the attendant, the decisive circumstance is a high risk of explosion, which raises the amount of care. For the surgeon, the circumstances include a specialist's role and training, so the jury compares her conduct with that of reasonably competent practitioners in her field.12
The same logic explains why the law looks past credentials. The public properly relies on the special expertise of those who undertake skilled work, so anyone who undertakes it, even gratuitously, is judged by the standards of those properly qualified to do it, whether or not the actor is a recognized member of the group. A pharmacist who undertakes to diagnose an illness described by a customer and to prescribe medication for it is judged by the standards applicable to a physician.13
Professional status does three practical jobs in a negligence case.14
- It marks the relationship and expectations of the parties, which is the only basis for any special rule applied to professionals.
- It supplies a relevant circumstance, because a professional is expected to bring the special expertise the profession carries.
- It signals that technical proof, often through qualified experts, may be needed to show breach, because jurors frequently cannot judge professional conduct unaided.15
The next section shows how the law turns this idea into a working rule by defining the skill and knowledge that a professional's circumstances make part of reasonable care.