Concept
Custom as Relevant Evidence
Custom as evidence of the standard of care
Custom and the Standard of Care
Custom as Relevant Evidence
Proving negligence works like proving any other fact: each side offers direct and circumstantial evidence, often in conflict, about what happened, and the fact-finder draws inferences and weighs credibility.1 Custom is one of the most useful kinds of evidence in that contest. It is also the first of three major forms of proof that bear especially on negligence claims; safety statutes and regulations, and res ipsa loquitur, are the other two.2
Custom does its work when no statute, regulation, or earlier decision has fixed the standard of conduct. In that situation the trial judge or the jury applies the standard of reasonable care to the facts of the case,3 and the Restatement (Second) of Torts directs them to take into account the customs of the community, or of others under like circumstances, as factors in deciding whether conduct was negligent.4 The operative word is factors. Custom informs the judgment without replacing it, and the Restatement adds that custom does not control where a reasonable person would not follow it. A later section develops that limit.
Either side may offer custom, and each uses it for its own purpose. A plaintiff's claim ordinarily gains strength from proof that the defendant ignored a customary safety standard, and a defendant's position ordinarily gains strength from proof that it met the standards of its industry.5 Custom reaches a plaintiff's own conduct too. When a roofer falls from a two-story building, it is relevant to his own negligence whether roofers ordinarily wear safety harnesses when reshingling buildings of that height (or ordinarily do not), and if most roofers regard working without a harness as an acceptable risk in exchange for freedom of movement or saved time, they may well be right.6 That possibility is the case for treating custom as evidence: people who do the work every day have often weighed the risk against the benefit, and their collective judgment is information a jury can use.
Trimarco v. Klein shows a plaintiff using custom against a no-duty argument. A tenant injured by the glass door of his shower enclosure sued his landlord. The door was ordinary glass, between one sixteenth and one quarter of an inch thick, and it looked no different from tempered safety glass, which the tenant and his wife had assumed it to be; nothing suggested the landlord ever told them otherwise.7 The tenant's proof of custom was reinforced by a showing that, over the relevant period, bulletins from nationally recognized safety and consumer organizations and official federal publications had warned of the dangers of plain glass in hazardous locations, including bathtub enclosures. And the landlord's own managing agent, long familiar with multiple dwellings in the New York City area, agreed on examination that since at least 1965 landlords who installed glass for shower enclosures, whether to replace broken glass or to meet a tenant's request, customarily used plastic or safety glass.8
The Appellate Division majority nevertheless reasoned that, even assuming a custom of substituting shatterproof glass and that it was a safer way to enclose showers, the landlord had no common-law duty to replace the glass unless the tenant or an earlier similar accident had put it on notice.9 The custom proof answers that reasoning directly. It speaks to what a reasonable landlord would have done without waiting for notice, and the court held that the proof was enough to put the landlord's reasonable care before the jury. The admission mattered especially because it came from the defendant's side, which made it hard to argue that the practice was unknown or unusual in the trade.
Custom earns its place for two reasons. First, it educates jurors. Many nineteenth-century jurors could judge a farming accident almost without help, and modern jurors can readily judge whether a driver in an ordinary collision drove reasonably, but they know far less about the shipping industry or the advantages and disadvantages of shatterproof glass. Evidence of how others in the field act, or of a failure to act as they do, puts jurors in a position to decide with better information.10 Second, custom is built into the standard itself. Reasonable behavior in negligence law is grounded in community norms, so whether an actor behaved as similar actors customarily behave in the same situation goes to the heart of the negligence inquiry, which is why the traditional formulation asks whether the actor failed to exercise ordinary care. In a products case, industry custom may also tend to show the foreseeability of a risk and the cost, feasibility, utility, and acceptability among consumers of the safety measure the plaintiff says the defendant should have adopted.11