Concept
Production and Persuasion
Plaintiff's burden of proving negligence
Production and Persuasion
The Restatement (Second) of Torts puts the burden of proving a negligence claim on the plaintiff.1 That burden has two parts, and they work at different stages of the trial before different decision-makers.2 The burden of production asks the judge whether the plaintiff’s evidence is enough to go to the jury. The burden of persuasion asks the jury whether it is actually convinced. A plaintiff can satisfy the first and still lose on the second, so the two must be kept apart.
The order matters. The judge screens the evidence first, and only a case that clears the screen reaches the jury. Once the evidence goes to the jury, the plaintiff carries the burden of persuasion.3 Both burdens run element by element: breach, injury or loss, and causation.
Burden of Production
The burden of production, sometimes called the burden of “going forward with the evidence,” requires the plaintiff to introduce evidence that, taken as a whole, would support a jury’s inference that the defendant breached the standard of care, that the plaintiff suffered injury or loss, and that the breach caused it.4 Because the plaintiff proves breach by showing negligence, the question is whether an inference of negligence is permissible. The inference need not be compelled. A plaintiff who meets that test has made out a prima facie case.
The judge, not the jury, decides whether the plaintiff has met this burden, and the decision is a ruling on the legal sufficiency of the evidence. At the close of the plaintiff’s case, the defendant may move for a directed verdict, also called judgment as a matter of law (JML). If reasonable people could disagree on each element, the motion is denied. If the evidence is legally insufficient on even one element, the motion is granted, and the defendant prevails without the jury deciding anything.5 The judge asks whether a reasonable jury could find for the plaintiff. The judge does not ask whether the judge would, or whom the judge believes, because the jury determines the “weight” of the evidence.
Clearing the screen therefore guarantees a jury and nothing more. Evidence that permits an inference of negligence does not compel it, and where an inference of negligence is permissible, an inference of no negligence is permissible too.6
A plaintiff in an intersection collision shows how little it can take to get through. The plaintiff testifies to proceeding through the intersection when the defendant’s vehicle, which was required to stop at a stop sign, collided with the plaintiff’s own and broke the plaintiff’s arm. Ordinarily that testimony makes out a prima facie case. If the jury believed it, the jury could find that the defendant failed to yield, that the failure was negligent, and that the negligence caused the broken arm and the damaged vehicle, though the jury would not have to.7 The plaintiff’s own testimony can suffice, and a defense witness who tells a different story creates a dispute for the jury to resolve. The judge does not resolve it by preferring the defense witness.
The opposite case is a plaintiff who offers nothing. P alleges that D drove through a red light, produces no affirmative evidence of it, and does not cross-examine when D testifies, “The light was green when I drove through.” No other evidence bears on the signal. The court must direct a verdict for D on negligence, because a party who carries the burden of proof cannot rely solely on the jury’s possible disbelief of the adversary’s denials.8 Disbelieving D’s denial removes evidence without adding any. Jurors who reject the testimony that the light was green are left with no evidence that it was red. The two plaintiffs differ in one respect only: one offered evidence of what the defendant did, and the other offered none.
The evidence must also fit the element it is offered to prove. A professional is not liable for a “mere error of judgment,” so a plaintiff who sues a professional must offer more than proof that the defendant made a mistaken judgment call.9
Burden of Persuasion
Once the plaintiff has met the burden of production and the evidence goes to the jury, the plaintiff bears the burden of persuasion. The jury is instructed that the plaintiff has satisfied it only if the jury is persuaded, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the defendant breached the standard of care, that the plaintiff suffered injury or loss, and that the breach caused it.11 Production asked whether a reasonable jury could find for the plaintiff. Persuasion asks whether this jury does.
To satisfy the standard, the jury must be persuaded that the alleged facts on each element are “more probable than not” true. Whether the plaintiff gets there depends on whether the jury believed the plaintiff’s testimony, what the defendant and the other witnesses said, and whether the jury believed them.12 In the typical case both sides offer evidence on each disputed issue, so the jury’s task is to decide which side’s contentions are more probably true by comparing how persuasive the parties’ positions are. The jury does not calculate probabilities.13
The burden decides the case when the jury cannot choose. If the jury finds it only as probable as not that the defendant breached the standard of care, the evidence on that element is in equipoise, meaning evenly balanced, and the plaintiff has not satisfied the burden of persuasion. The jury must be persuaded that the defendant “more probably than not” breached the standard, or the plaintiff loses on that element.14 The same is true of every element on which a party bears the burden, so a tie goes against the party who carries it.15 The defendant does not have to persuade the jury that he stopped. The plaintiff has to persuade the jury that he did not.
The plaintiff’s evidence was the same in both versions, and it satisfied the judge’s screen in both. The outcomes diverge only in what the jury made of that evidence once the defendant’s account was on the scale. If the jury believes the plaintiff and finds it more probable than not that the defendant failed to yield and caused the collision, the plaintiff prevails on those elements.16 Because the jury determines the weight of the evidence, satisfying the burden of production never guarantees a verdict.17