Concept
Certainty in Proving Damages
Plaintiff's burden of proving negligence
Certainty in Proving Damages
A verdict on liability tells the jury that the defendant owes the plaintiff something, but it does not say how much. For that, the plaintiff must prove a second set of facts, and Restatement (Second) of Torts § 912 states the condition. A person to whom another has tortiously caused harm is entitled to compensatory damages “if, but only if,” the plaintiff establishes by proof the extent of the harm and the amount of money representing adequate compensation, with as much certainty as the nature of the tort and the circumstances permit.1 Compensatory damages are the money that makes up for a loss the plaintiff actually suffered.
The rule has three working parts: the extent of the harm, the amount that compensates it, and the firmness of the proof for both. The subsections below take them in that order and end with the hardest case, a loss the plaintiff has not yet suffered.
Extent and Amount of Harm
Section 912 splits the plaintiff’s proof into two pieces, and each calls for its own evidence. The extent of the harm is a fact about the plaintiff’s life: what the injury is, how serious it is, how long it lasts, and what it costs. The amount of compensation is the dollar figure that turns those facts into a judgment. A plaintiff who proves extent without amount has shown a loss with no measure, and a plaintiff who proposes an amount without proving extent has offered a number with nothing underneath it. Because recovery is available “if, but only if” both are proved, a plaintiff who has established duty, breach, cause, and harm holds a verdict on liability and nothing more until the evidence shows what the loss comes to.2
The passenger lost the damages portion of his case because compensation measures a gap, and the gap exists only in the evidence. A successful plaintiff is entitled to be made “whole” by recovering damages for the losses that proximately resulted from the defendant’s tortious act or omission.3 Without proof of those losses, a jury must take its figure from somewhere else, such as sympathy for the plaintiff or disapproval of the defendant, and an award built on either no longer compensates anything.
What the plaintiff must prove depends on what was lost. For damaged property, damages are measured by the loss in value or the cost to repair or replace, whichever is less.4 If a collision cuts a van’s value by $5,000 and repairs would cost $7,000, the measure is $5,000. A bodily-injury recovery has two parts. Special damages are the out-of-pocket losses, which consist mainly of health-care expenses and lost earnings or lost earning capacity. General damages compensate non-economic loss, often called pain and suffering, which can include physical and emotional suffering, disfigurement, and loss of life’s enjoyments.5 Special damages tend to leave documents behind, such as bills, treatment records, and pay records. Intangible loss leaves none, and the next subsection explains how the law adjusts.
Both the passenger and the worker won on liability, and only the worker built the record that section 912 requires.
Defendants who contest the size of the loss need evidence of their own. In one case, the defendant’s evidence that the plaintiff’s smoking and obesity caused difficulty in healing a fracture was inadequate. In another, an instruction appeared to approve a mitigation defense, which argues that the plaintiff could have reduced the loss, without proof that efforts to mitigate would have reduced the plaintiff’s damages. A later and more accurate instruction probably cured that error.6
As Much Certainty as Permitted
How firmly must the plaintiff prove extent and amount? Section 912 answers with a sliding scale: “as much certainty as the nature of the tort and the circumstances permit.”9 Certainty here means the degree of definiteness the evidence must reach before a jury may rely on it. The nature of the tort tells you what kind of loss is at stake, since a repaired fender and a lifetime of chronic pain are measured in different ways. The circumstances tell you what proof the plaintiff can realistically produce. Because both vary from case to case, one plaintiff may face a demanding standard on one item of loss and a forgiving one on another.
Either fixed alternative would fail. A rule demanding exact figures would defeat recovery for losses that resist pricing, and pain and suffering leaves no receipt. A rule excusing precision would let a plaintiff who holds the pay stubs offer a guess, and the defendant would pay a sum that no evidence supported. Tying the demand to the available proof avoids both results. Where records exist, the plaintiff is expected to use them, and where the loss is intangible, approximation is accepted because nothing more exact exists.
The two ends of the scale correspond to the two kinds of bodily-injury damages. Out-of-pocket losses are tangible: health-care expenses and lost earnings or earning capacity. Pain and suffering compensates intangible losses, including physical and emotional suffering, disfigurement, and the loss of life’s enjoyments.10
Neither result turns on how large the claimed loss is. Each turns on what proof the circumstances made available.
Jurisdictions attach different labels to the requirement. In some, the ordinary rules for proving the elements of the claim govern damages too, so the plaintiff must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the claimed losses have occurred or will occur. In others, the traditional rule survives that the plaintiff must prove damages “to a reasonable certainty.” The reasonable-certainty rule probably arose because damages take the form of one particular dollar amount, and it was thought that a specific amount could not be proved by a preponderance of the evidence.11 Under either label, section 912 tells the plaintiff what to aim for: the best proof that the nature of the loss and the circumstances allow.
Proving Future Loss
A plaintiff with a continuing injury must prove, at the one trial, losses that have not yet happened. The reason is the principle of a single recovery: in the ordinary tort case the plaintiff recovers once, and that recovery compensates past and future losses together.14 Section 912’s condition therefore governs the future component as it governs the past. The plaintiff must establish the extent and amount of the expected loss with as much certainty as the circumstances permit.15
Nothing remains to be claimed later, because the law recognizes no independent cause of action for inchoate or future loss, meaning loss not yet incurred.16 A loss that still lies ahead has no lawsuit of its own to wait for. It enters the case as part of the damages for the injury already suffered, at this trial, or it does not enter at all.
The single recovery has both advantages and disadvantages. For the defendant, it brings repose much like the expiration of a statute of limitations. Once the case has concluded and the defendant has paid, the defendant’s financial exposure to the plaintiff has ended, and economic planning can proceed without uncertainty about further liability.17 The plaintiff pays for that finality in proof. The plaintiff must establish at this one trial that the claimed losses have occurred or will occur.18
The two formulations described above apply to future loss as well. Some jurisdictions require proof by a preponderance that the losses will occur, and others retain the demand for proof to a reasonable certainty.19 The future cannot be documented with receipts, so proof of it is necessarily an estimate, but under either formulation evidence that a loss could happen is not evidence that it will.
Both plaintiffs faced the same single trial and the same burden. The bookkeeper recovers for the future because his evidence made the loss probable, while the driver offered only the chance that it might happen.