Concept
Subsequent Reasonable Care
But for and substantial causes
Subsequent Reasonable Care
A defendant who creates a risk through negligence and then works carefully to contain it still answers for the harm that risk produces. Section 437 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts says so directly: if the actor's negligent conduct is a substantial factor in bringing about harm to another, the actor's exercise of reasonable care after the risk was created, to keep it from taking effect in harm, does not prevent liability for the harm.1
The rule rests on timing. Negligence is judged when the actor creates the risk, by asking whether the choice made then fell below reasonable care. A later effort to contain the danger is a separate act, and good conduct at that second moment cannot reach back and repair the first. The rule therefore removes one tempting defense, that a careful rescue wipes the slate clean, but it operates only after the earlier negligence has been found to be a substantial factor in the harm. It does not relax the causal showing taught earlier in this chapter.
The third question is where a reasonable response belongs, and it is also where students over-credit it. Reasonable conduct in an emergency bears on whether the actor was negligent in responding. It says nothing about whether the actor was negligent in creating the emergency.
The hypothetical separates two defenses that students tend to blur. Careful conduct after the risk arose is no defense under § 437. A failure of causation is a defense, and it comes from the earlier sections of this chapter.
The rule preserves liability for harm that occurs, and a successful rescue leaves no harm to which that liability can attach.3 A partly successful rescue follows the same logic, because liability reaches the harm that actually resulted. On an exam, a stem that dwells on the defendant's diligent response after the danger arose invites the conclusion that careful conduct cancels earlier fault. Resist it. Locate the breach at the moment the risk was created, treat the quality of the response as a separate question, and check whether any harm took effect.