Concept
The Traditional Baseline Rule
Duty owed to licensees
The Traditional Baseline Rule
The common law of land possession starts by classifying the entrant as a trespasser, a licensee, or an invitee, and then assigns each class a different duty. Only invitees are owed the standard duty of care, that of the reasonable and prudent person under similar circumstances. Trespassers and licensees are owed a lesser duty, and the two lesser duties are closely similar.1 For the licensee, that lesser duty is the baseline this section teaches. Rowland v. Christian states it this way: a trespasser and a licensee or social guest must take the premises as they find them as to any defective condition, and the possessor owes them only the duty of refraining from wanton or willful injury.2 The rules that follow in this chapter are best read either as exceptions to that baseline or as comparisons with it.
Taking the premises as found has three practical consequences. The licensee cannot demand ordinary care in general, because that standard belongs to invitees.3 The licensee cannot demand that the possessor search the land for dangers, because the possessor's liability for a condition begins with knowing, or having reason to know, that it exists.4 And the licensee cannot demand that the possessor repair the land or make it safe for the visit.5 What the licensee keeps is protection against willful or wanton injury. A host therefore owes a dinner guest no sounder porch than the one the host already has.
Two explanations support the baseline. The historical one is that the special rules for possessors are often traced to the high place land held in English and American thought, the dominance of the landowning class while the rules were forming, and the heritage of feudalism.6 So strong was that land ethic that the special limits favoring possessors were restricted only in the last third of the twentieth century.7 The practical explanation is an intuition about guests: a visitor does not ordinarily expect the host to inspect and repair on the visitor's account, and a guest who walks into a house sees what the host sees. The intuition is the quicker guide to how far the rule reaches. The history explains why the rule lasted so long and why courts have since cut it back.
An exam stem in which a guest falls through a rotted board invites the answer that the host should have checked the deck. For a licensee, that answer fails at the duty stage.
Vega escapes liability because Vega never learned of the rot, and Hollis does not escape because Hollis did. That difference is the first exception to the baseline: a possessor who knows of a concealed condition that the guest will not discover must warn the guest or make the condition safe.8 The baseline lifts the burden of searching for dangers. It does not protect a possessor who keeps quiet about a danger already found.
Read literally, the willful-or-wanton formula would let a possessor be careless even toward a person the possessor can see walking into danger. Courts often avoid that result by defining willful or wanton conduct to include a failure to exercise ordinary care after the licensee's presence has been discovered, or should reasonably have been expected.9 The definition fits the baseline's own logic. The burdens the baseline removes are burdens of advance preparation for visitors who may never come, and once the possessor sees the person and the danger, the only precaution left is ordinary care, so the case for excusing it weakens. Not every court has made that move; some still hold that the possessor need only refrain from willful or wanton injury.10
The baseline is a starting point with two limited exceptions. Rowland describes a retreat from the older position as regard for human safety grew, beginning with active operations, where the occupier came to owe the licensee reasonable care.11 The Restatement (Second) of Torts states both exceptions. Section 342 reaches concealed conditions that the possessor knows or has reason to know of, and § 341 reaches the possessor's activities. Each applies only if the possessor should expect that the licensee will not discover the danger and the licensee does not know or have reason to know of it.12 Most courts still begin by classifying the entrant, even though a substantial number now extend the duty of ordinary care to licensees, or even to trespassers.13