Concept
Others Who Share the Possessor's Role
Harm to persons outside the land and related special rules
Others Who Share the Possessor's Role
The possessor rules above each name a “possessor of land” as the defendant. A possessor answers for an activity carried on there that he realizes or should realize creates an unreasonable risk to people outside the land, and an owner who alters a condition of his land must use reasonable care for those outside it.1 Real facts do not always supply that defendant. The person at the controls of the machine may be the owner's adult son, and the person who dug the hole may have no right to be on the land at all. Two Restatement rules cover those cases. Section 382 puts a household member in the possessor's position, with the possessor's burdens and the possessor's protections. Section 381 makes a trespasser answer to others on the land for the dangers he creates. Household members come first, then trespassers as defendants.
Household Members
Section 382 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts reaches people who live on the land without holding it. A member of the household of a possessor who does an act or carries on an activity on the land is subject to the same liability, and enjoys the same freedom from liability, for physical harm caused to others upon and outside the land as though he were the possessor.2 The rule works in both directions, and students tend to remember only the protective one.
The burdens come through the activity rule. A possessor is liable for physical harm to others outside the land from an activity he carries on there when he realizes or should realize that it involves an unreasonable risk, judged as though the activity were carried on at a neutral place.3 Section 382 seats the household member who carries on the activity in the possessor's chair for that test. The neighbor's claim then turns on who ran the activity and on whether a reasonable person running it anywhere would have seen the danger. The name on the deed does not enter the analysis.
The protections come through the possessor's reduced standard toward trespassers. That standard arises from the possessor's privilege to exclude persons in protection of property rights.4 Persons in actual occupancy of the land who exercise control over it, as well as members of the possessor's household, may take advantage of these limited-duty rules.5 Occupancy and control, rather than title, carry the protection. For the household extension of the possessor's immunity in the case law, see Sohn v. Katz.
The borrowed protection reaches only as far as the possessor's own, and that standard has a floor: the reasonable duty of care still attaches in the case of imperiled and helpless trespassers.6 A household member who finds a trespasser imperiled and helpless in the yard stands where the possessor would stand.
Trespassers as Defendants
Section 381 puts the trespasser in the defendant's chair. A trespasser on land is subject to liability to others whom he should recognize as likely to be on the land, as servants of the possessor or as invitees, licensees, or trespassers, for physical harm caused to them by any act done, activity carried on, or condition created while upon the land by the trespasser which he should recognize as involving an unreasonable risk of causing such harm to them.8 The household rule lends the possessor's standing to someone close to the land. This rule addresses the person with the weakest claim to any standing there and holds him responsible for the dangers he creates. A plaintiff must connect three links in order.
The first link ties the trespasser to the danger. The rule reaches an act he does, an activity he carries on, or a condition he creates while on the land. A person who walks past a hazard that was already there has created nothing, while a person who digs a pit, lights a fire, or runs a machine has authored the risk. The made-condition limb echoes the earlier rule that an owner who alters a condition of his land must use reasonable care for those outside it, as with damming a stream into a malarial pond or piling sand where the wind may blow it.9 In both settings, the defendant's own alteration of the land makes him answerable.
The second link asks whether the trespasser should have recognized that other people were likely to be there. The rule names servants of the possessor and invitees, licensees, and other trespassers, so nearly everyone who might be on the land is covered and the victim's own status drops out of the analysis. Even a fellow intruder can recover. The limits come from two words: likely, and the objective phrase should recognize. A trespasser cannot excuse himself by saying he never thought about who might come, and he does not answer to everyone who turns up by remote chance.
The third link asks whether he recognized, or should have recognized, that his conduct involved an unreasonable risk of physical harm to those people. This mirrors the activity rule above, which asks what a possessor realizes or should realize about an unreasonable risk to outsiders.10 The second and third links work together, because he must foresee both that people are likely to be present and that his conduct endangers them. If either recognition is missing, the claim fails.
A common mistake is to carry the possessor's reduced standard toward trespassers over into this rule. That standard arises from the possessor's privilege to exclude persons in protection of property rights.11 A trespasser who injures a third person asserts no property right against that person. The worker or driver hurt by his pit intruded on none of his land and infringed no interest of his, so the reasoning behind the reduced standard has nothing to attach to. That standard protects the possessor's property and gives an intruder no shelter from claims by third persons.
A matched pair of scenes shows where the links bite. Both scenes are illustrations built from the text of § 381, not holdings from decided cases.
Both trespassers made the dangerous condition, and both injuries were physical, so the first and third links are met on each side. The difference lies in the second link: the farm made the presence of others likely, and the remote tract gave its intruder no reason to expect visitors. The analysis therefore centers on what the trespasser should have recognized when he acted, and the victim's later status plays no part.