Concept
Recovery Without Pecuniary Loss
Damages for mental distress and other intangible injuries
Recovery Without Pecuniary Loss
Most of what a seriously injured plaintiff loses never appears on a receipt. A hospital bill and a missing paycheck are pecuniary losses, meaning dollars spent or dollars not earned. A year of chronic pain, a scarred face, and a lost hobby are not. A damages rule limited to pecuniary loss would leave the second group unpaid. The Restatement (Second) of Torts rejects that limit: compensatory damages that may be awarded without proof of pecuniary loss include compensation for bodily harm and for emotional distress.1
The rule rests on the general principle that a successful plaintiff is entitled to be made “whole” by damages for the losses proximately resulting from the defendant’s tortious act or omission.2 For intangible losses, the vehicle is pain-and-suffering damages, which compensate physical and emotional suffering, disfigurement, loss of life’s enjoyments, and similar losses.3 The out-of-pocket items, such as medical bills, trace to a receipt and are called special damages. The intangible items are general damages, and nothing in the world fixes their price.
No receipt exists for a sleepless night or a year of fear. Because pain does not occur in money, the jury must translate the harm into dollars, and the award serves a symbolic function.4 The link between a physical injury and pain is close enough that some courts will not merely permit but require an award for pain once the jury finds physical injury. A verdict that pays medical expenses but awards nothing for pain is often treated as insupportable or inadequate, because paying for treatment implies that the jury found pain for which some compensation is due.5 General damages thus follow from the injury itself and do not wait on a second showing of money loss.
The intangible award also does practical work. Plaintiffs usually pay their lawyers a percentage of the recovery, so even a plaintiff fully reimbursed for out-of-pocket expenses ends up with less than full compensation. Among other functions, the pain-and-suffering award gives the plaintiff a sum out of which to pay the attorney.6 One commentator finds that function awkward and suggests that counsel fees would more sensibly be treated as another compensable out-of-pocket expense than collected through pain awards “under the table.”7
The rule says such damages may be awarded, and that verb matters.8 The rule presupposes an established claim, because liability comes first. In negligence the plaintiff must prove actual harm, usually personal injury or property damage, and nominal damages are not available. Most victims who suffer only economic loss, or emotional distress without physical harm, cannot recover at all.9 The rule therefore dispenses with proof of money loss and leaves every other requirement in place.
An exam question built on this rule may tempt you to read it as a promise of distress damages whenever the plaintiff is upset. A second scene shows why that reading fails.
The measure for property harm is the loss in value of the property or the cost to repair or replace it, whichever is less, with consequential losses such as diminished profits added.10 It reflects a broader principle that a remedy should track the right invaded: when the right is purely economic, the remedy does not include damages for emotional distress.11 Both plaintiffs are upset, and both may have modest receipts. The first suffered bodily harm, which is the injury the rule names. The second lost only property.