Concept
Death and Survival
Damages for mental distress and other intangible injuries
Death and Survival
At common law, a personal tort claim died with either party, whatever the cause of death, and unless a statute provides otherwise that remains the general rule.1 The rule had no rational support. It persisted because of stare decisis, and it probably began in an age when tort law was part of a law of wrongs whose chief functions were retribution and punishment.2 Survival statutes now displace it, and the Restatement (Second) of Torts says what they do to damages. Under a statute providing for the survival or revival of tort actions, the damages for a tort not involving death are not affected by the death of either party before or during trial.3 Two exceptions follow, one for each party.
The death of the injured person limits recovery for loss or impairment of earning capacity, emotional distress, and all other harms to those suffered before the death.4 A survival action therefore carries pain and distress forward only as far as the date of death. The limit follows from what the action is: it preserves the claim the injured person held at death, and the estate takes that claim as it stands. A living plaintiff recovers for future pain and future lost earnings because the plaintiff will be there to live through them. Death removes the one person who would have felt that pain or collected those wages, so the harms that would have come afterward never enter the claim. Pain, distress, medical expenses, and earnings lost up to the date of death stay in it.
The law does not ignore those later harms, because the people who depended on the victim may have claims of their own. Wrongful death is a separate claim, brought for the survivors, and it compensates what the death took from them. The jury values the beneficiary's probable future loss, judged largely by the support, contributions, and services the decedent supplied in the past, under the same damages rules as other personal injury cases, including reduction of future pecuniary loss to present value.5
The nonpecuniary items vary most from state to state. Most jurisdictions now let the jury award damages for the loss of the decedent's society, companionship, love, and affection, called consortium damages, at least for beneficiaries such as spouses, children, and parents, and some impose a ceiling. Most jurisdictions still refuse damages for the survivors' own grief and mental anguish, although several permit them, a few by statute.6 The two items sit close together but measure different things. Consortium measures the benefits of the relationship the survivor has lost; grief measures the survivor's emotional reaction to the loss.
Each claim answers a separate question about whose loss is being compensated and when it occurred. The survival claim asks what the injured person suffered before death, and the wrongful death claim asks what the survivors lost because of the death. The statutes and decisions handle the overlaps. Medical expenses incurred between the injury and the death, if not recovered in the survival action, usually may be recovered by whoever paid them or by the estate, in the wrongful death action or in some states a separate action, and a majority of jurisdictions allow funeral and burial expenses.7 A minority of jurisdictions, chiefly those with a survival-type death statute, measure wrongful death damages by the loss to the decedent's estate, typically probable future earnings minus personal expenses, and almost never allow nonpecuniary loss under that kind of statute.8 Because of that variation, an exam answer should say which claim is asserted and note that the jurisdiction's statute controls the details.
The death of the tortfeasor has a different effect: it terminates liability for punitive damages.9 Compensatory damages continue against the tortfeasor's estate, because the general survival rule leaves damages unaffected by either party's death. Punitive damages exist to punish and deter the wrongdoer, and a defendant who has died can no longer be punished or deterred. Collecting them would burden only the estate's beneficiaries, who did nothing wrong. The rule is not universal, since some courts allow punitive damages against the estate.10 Wrongful death actions follow their own pattern. In most jurisdictions punitive damages are not recoverable there, usually because the statute is read to permit compensation for pecuniary loss only, and Alabama is the exception, where punitive damages are the only damages its wrongful death act allows.11
The second step carries most of the points on a survival problem, because the decedent's story usually includes a long imagined future, and that future lies outside the estate's claim. Sorting each item to the right claimant, the decedent's pain to the estate and the lost support and companionship to the survivors, resolves most of the question.